Bread Making Book Reviews

    Bread baking books on a shelf

    Allow me to introduce some of my humble bread making library...

    These are books I actually own, I've actually read and baked with, occasionally got a little flour/crumbs on, then shoved whatever improvised bookmark in my most recent bake (note the yellow lens cleaning cloth in "Advanced Bread and Pastry" on the far left), and ultimately written an opinion based on my own views with no AI assistance whatsoever.

    Now, I'm not a pro baker. I'm just a hobbyist, albeit an enthusiastic one. There are loads of folks with more books than I have, but if they've reviewed their impressive collection of books, I've often found that I'm left wondering:

    • "If they're all so great, wouldn't any of the books do a good job?"
    • "What makes one book special, relative to the next?..."
    • "Do I have time to read this book?" or
    • "How much does this cost?"

    .... and many more... "real world" questions that obviously impacts a person's willingness to choose a good bread book.

    If you want to know a little more, then please make yourself comfortable. Grab a drink and a snack, and feel free to skip to interesting books, or just read this article in drips and drabs when you have time. You won't get much more in-depth than what I've presented here... At least, not without me breaching copyright and sharing the actual book content. :-)

    Time for a little honesty/expectation management...

    I don't want to imply that I've made each and every recipe in every single book. There are literally over 2200 recipes of actual bread/pizzas, and other bread/pastry doughs... (and counting) in these books. There's over 1600 additional meal/snack/dessert recipes that pair with, are mixed in with, or are built using  the aforementioned breads.... and I would take years to do that, even full time. We simply cannot eat that much bread, and we'd have exploded like Mr. Creosote from Monty Python's "Meaning of Life" if we had every pastry, tart, cake, etc. on top! The point here is to improve the quality of home-made food by learning, not overwhelm ourselves with sheer quantity... however enticing it may be at times.

    The hobbyist baker's "dirty little secret"....

    We're shameless collectors and hoarders of both bread baking equipment and books. The problem with this is that the overwhelming majority of books are aimed at beginners, and re-hash the same information, over and over again. While it is repetitive at a broad level, each book does delivers information with different priorities, focal topics, ultra-brief-and quick intros versus in-depth "hand holding" instructions. Even so, beginner books can only go so far. However, short of buying baking textbooks or specialty books (gluten free, Nordic breads, pizza, or "heirloom"/"rustic"/"ancient" grains, antique/historical recipe books, etc...), you're going to see the same basic stuff a lot. 

    Why doesn't one book satisfy a hobbyist like myself?

    We hobbyists keep buying books in the hope that some small nugget of wisdom, different recipes, a new technique, or some refinement of the process can be found. To be fair, that happens a lot, at least, for a while. However, there is a point where the cost of the books go up, and the benefit dwindles. So I humbly encourage you to grab a few books that most interest you, then actively seek exotic or more advanced books.

    P.S. If you're wondering why I have two copies of the same Women's Weekly "Simply Bread" It was misplaced, and was missing for over a year. I bought another... then the original showed up a week or two later. Typical!

    Ham holding two bread books for comparison

    Before you rush to the bread books...

    Popularity isn't always the best indicator:

    Many, think that "Popular books must be popular for a reason, right?"

    That's not always the smartest approach... popular books are often reserved for months in advance at the local library and can have shorter loan times. That's often considerably harder than borrowing one of the unsung heroes in the genre.

    If borrowing isn't your thing, popular books are often more expensive (or less likely to be steeply discounted on sale). Unless, they're popular because of a relatively low price point of course.

    What about "older editions?"

    Unless I am doing a formal class and need to follow along with the other students, as a hobbyist, an "older edition" is often better than the latest in many ways.

    These books are often overlooked by many, but they may have only slight differences in content to the latest edition and offer substantial discounts.

    The formal approach?

    Seeing which books are used to teach baker apprentices at the start of their career is very handy, especially with older editions because they offset the higher text book prices considerably.

    Look at the recommended reading lists for official courses, and there's usually one core text book and a handful of other "assorted books" (possibly from this list) that offer something important at a more affordable price.

    So what type of books can you expect here?

    There's a few popular books, there's a few formal texts, there's new books, old books, ones aimed at beginners, and some aimed at experienced bakers. I sometimes scrounge the local "bargain bins" and markets ... sometimes I just get books handed to me... some you've probably never heard of.

    CONTENTS:

    There's over 36 book reviews (and counting) on this page, totalling 14,000+ pages worth of material, and that doesn't include the associated A.I. assistants (see Sourdough Framework below), and other addendums, or the YouTube videos and documents found on various linked sites.

    Similarly, I've baked a lot of bread from these books over years. I've discussed some of my personal experiences while using recipes from the books that I haven't made before in order to closer-emulate a situation where you've just been handed the book and want to get on with it. Hopefully that can provide you with some valuable insight(s) into each book that other review pages rarely provide.

    All this info can lead to a lot of unnecessary scrolling. So to make life easier, pick a book, click on the image, and it'll skip to that review. When you're done, simply hit "back" on your browser to come back here. Since this page is a constant work in progress, the books at the bottom may not have working links. Pick one that's closer, and scroll the rest of the way.

    If that helps you to avoid a causing/exacerbating a repetitive strain injury (RSI) or a Musculoskeletal Disorder (MSD) that's great, but just be careful when stirring/kneading stiffer doughs by hand ok? I can't help you with that issue. :-)

    Alt Text
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Alt Text
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Alt Text
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    25 techniques for wood fired ovens by A. Cort Simmes
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Bread Baker's Apprentice
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    The Sourdough Baking Book by Miro Van Vreckem
    Image
    Image
    Image

    Some bread-adjacent books...

    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image

    Coming soon: Ham's Commentary Section

    Ham looking at screens

    On with the reviews!

    Be warned, these reviews are probably a lot more in-depth than you'll find elsewhere. So please grab yourself a snack, perhaps a tasty beverage, and put some nice relaxing music on.

    Hendrik Kleinwächter - Sourdough Framework Book Cover

    Hendrik Kleinwächter - Sourdough Framework

    The Sourdough Framework is not just a book. It's much, much more than that.

    It's an open-source, freely downloadable, frequently-updated e-book (and hard cover book if you buy it). Interestingly, if you have a sourdough question and need answers fast, use the "Loafy A.I. Assistant" that translates to almost any language "on the fly". All answers are generated from the book, but it's pretty good and getting better.

    "The Sourdough Framework" is a link to a rather vibrant community of fellow bread bakers. (Click on image to go to the official book site and the A.I. assistant "Loafy" or click on the button below to go to the author's YouTube channel for access to numerous videos.

    Hendrick Keinwächter is the creator of "The Bread Code", a web site and YouTube channel who has applied his software engineering mindset to rigourously researched and tested bread baking information, techniques and of course, recipes.

    Like all open-source projects, people are able to chime in, suggest improvements, or just provide their results from various trials. This is why the book is actually managed on GitHub (a collaborative platform for developing software.... which if you think about it, is just computer executable text files, so a book is no problem). This has flow-on effects too, improving the Loafy AI.

    The Bread Code YouTube Channel

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: A freely-shared Introduction to sourdough techniques & knowledge, ranging from starters, through to baking and ultimately, storage. The few recipes are largely for illustration... but they do work.

    Total page count: 194 (at the time of writing)

    No. of pages before recipes: 51

    Metric/imperial units? Metric

    Number of recipes: 3 actual bread recipes. (I may have missed a couple, but there's very few specified "Ingredients" & "Method" sections that I generally look for in a recipe.

    Photos for every recipe? No.

    Price range (new): Free download! The hardcover book is $50 (USD) or $79 (AUD).

    Price range (used): N/A (not found)

    Notable Features & FYI: Despite the extremely low number of recipes, it's enough to get you started, and understand the entire process to a very good degree. That said, the troubleshooting section is amazing and would augment any other book (sourdough or not) in this list. I also like the "Mix in" section for adding fruits/seeds/herbs, and beyond. The linked videos, as well as the "I need answers quick, my bread's misbehaving, help me Obi-wan McLoafy!"

    The Sourdough Framework Book - Pros and Cons

    Firstly, you can read the entire book on the book's official site. You can download it for free in both epub and PDF formats. There are also downloadable shortened versions (under TL:DR which means "too long: didn't read") which is less empowering, but get's you most of the way to great bread in minimal time.

    If you're on a budget and can't afford a book on the subject, simply offer to contribute to help the community through their Discord (forum) on www.the-bread-code.io in any number of ways. For example, there's translation, (if you speak foreign languages) there's testing and reporting of recipe results, or unusual troubles that you experience, I'm sure there's a way anyone can help if you have some spare time.

    That said, you can of course, donate money, or buy the published book too if you want to help support Hendrik's efforts. I heartily encourage you to do so if you're able.

    I love open source software, and I love freely shared information like The Sourdough Framework so I feel I need to re-share this information wherever I can.

    The book itself...

    At only 150-ish pages long, (not counting the glossary, index, bibliography and such) it covers a lot of ground, and while it's not as polished as professionally published books. You'd be pretty darn knowledgeable by reading all the way to the end. It certainly has one of the best bread baking "troubleshooting" sections I've seen, so it would augment any of the other books quite well for that reason alone.

    The Sourdough Framework covers a decent introduction to the science of bread, the differences you can expect between using a regular starter, a liquid starter, or "stiff" starter, and how best to use them. It discusses different styles of breads as well as their respective pros and cons. I like the fact that there's separate chapters for wheat sourdoughs, and non-wheat sourdoughs which expands further than many books for those concerned about gluten.

    Most chapters are a casual 10 pages or so. However, the most complex type (wheat sourdoughs) is a healthy 40 pages. (That's roughly 30% of the entire book). There's more steps in sourdough, so they covered that, and trimmed bloat from the rest wherever they could. That makes it a much easier read overall. However, there are also a ton of related YouTube videos through "The Bread Code" channel which depicts much of that material in a multimedia format.

    The cons...

    Despite being circa 150 pages, there's surprisingly few actual recipes. However, if you make one from each bread type in the book.. and learn how to tweak each in the various ways discussed, you're well on the way to making any bread you want. Consequently, it's hard to hold the number of recipes against the book, given it's shared so freely, and it is a solid bread baking book.

    Conclusion:

    Given it's freely available, and it augments other books well. You have no reason not to grab this book, and maybe learn a bit from the associated forums. I highly recommend it.

    Australian Women's Weekly - Simply Bread Book Cover

    Australian Women's Weekly - Simply Bread

    Starting (as the title suggests), quite simply, this book is a collection of magazine recipes, all dressed up into a hard cover book with lots of pretty photos. While it's fundamentally "a recipe book", it does offer basic bread making theory, some history, tales regarding the role of bread in various cultures and locations, from "Amish Friendship Loaf" to "New York Bagels".

    Honestly, we've tried a few recipes, and frankly, not all of them suit our particular tastes, and our first attempts didn't always come out like the pictures suggested.. I think our kitchen was a bit cool that day, but that's not a negative reflection on this book.

    In this household, the simple white loaf is probably one of the top 10 bread recipes made by frequency because it's drop-dead easy, it's quick to make, and it is a very versatile, general purpose bread.

    If you're looking for a "coffee table book" or something to give as a gift, then Simply Bread is also a solid choice.

    Despite being a hard cover, with lots of pretty pictures, it's actually at the cheaper end of the book price range. I got mine for just $38 (Australian) in a Jindabyne Newsagency (It's made by the same folks who do the Women's Weekly Magazine, afterall). So it should be more ubiquitous than other books in Australia, but it's probably less available abroad.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Beginner oriented. Easy to read, very pretty. The wide range of overwhelmingly bread-centred recipes, is surprising, and only about 20% of the recipes are pastries. The rest, all bread.... although a few are are sweeter breads.

    Total page count: 288

    No. of pages before recipes: 15

    Metric/imperial units? Metric

    Number of recipes: 79 total. 14 basic breads, 12 sourdoughs, 13 quick breads, 12 healthy breads, 13 sweet breads, and 15 pastries/desserts.

    Photos for every recipe? Most. Many have opposite page, full-page photos. Some are more distant from the recipes too. Step-by-step images are littered here and there.

    Price range (new): $30-$49 (AUD) hardcover.

    Price range (used): $25-$60 (AUD) for a hardcover.

    Notable Features & FYI: This has some intro/theory sections, but it's very light compared to some others. The strength of this book is the high recipe count for the price, the diverse recipe range (even expensive "Pro" or advanced books rarely include teff-based breads). Another strength is the overall extremely pretty presentation and sheer simplicity for absolute beginners.

    Simply Bread - Pros and Cons:

    I think the recipes are good, and most of them have turned out well, (if not exactly perfectly) on the first try. Second attempts have been solid though. That has a lot of merit in building confidence.

    Would I buy this as a definitive bread book? No. It's not just designed to be that way. While I do like the book for bread making, it's not just bread that it centres around. There are of course, desserts and crackers and other things you can make with similar ingredients to bread as well.

    After a great deal of thought, I feel that the book caters to a wide variety of tastes, but this is a double-edged sword for three reasons:

    1. The recipe number is high-but-finite, and it has spread those recipes across a range of styles and tastes. If you're eclectic in your tastes, thats fine, but most people have their preferences and fall into particular bread styles for one reason or another.... and stick to them. I'm not a big olive fan, and so the olive infused varieties are immediately "no go's" for me. Which leads to my second issue...
    2. There's a number of recipes in Simply Bread that either incorporate unusual bread ingredients that we don't always have on hand... and would have little use for otherwise. So if you have a pantry with limited space, filled to the rafters, it's a bit of a gamble if you find that you don't like that style of bread. Then you're stuck with either "trying to find a use" for the left over ingredients, or they're slowly pushed to the back of those hard-to-reach shelves gathering dust and taking up space. In short, some recipes are "too specific" in taste, even if the underlying bread is amazing. Don't be afraid to keep it a bit simpler.
    3. While there's almost certainly a bread for almost everyone in this book.... You might find that you only like one or two styles of bread, (or that several recipes are too involved for you to bother making) and so most of the book will be useless to you. The recipes might be simple, but that doesn't mean they can't be time-consuming to make, particularly the sourdough varieties.

    That said, if you find one or more recipe that you actually love and use a lot, (like we did because Ren adores the simple white loaf for it's quick and easy process that adapts well to tweaks) then it's fair to pay for the book in order to support those who provided it.

    I really like the fact that I can read the whole book in under 2 hours because there really is a high number of pictures here. If you're the kind of person who gets intimidated by wordy tomes, this is one of the better beginner books for it's relaxed learning curve, and lots of pretty/inspiring images that help compare your results with theirs. Many of the more advanced books are a bit spotty on this point, and I think it has a lot of value to home bakers who are often working alone, so any pictorial reference point is a big help.

    Simply Bread's

    Milled by Ham, baked, sliced, carved, (and photographed) by Ren

    I wasn't kidding when I mentioned that Ren loves quick bread recipes. This is Simply Bread's "Simple white loaf" recipe with a freshly milled wholewheat twist, (about 30% of the flour has been replaced by our home made flour made from "hard winter wheat". The actual grains that were milled to make this whole wheat flour are actually placed on the left-side of the image. The milled flour is on the right. Honestly, given that Ren was the one doing this, I'm surprised this isn't a sweeter option like honey bread, or fruit & cinnamon toast... which this recipe could be adapted to.

    Side note: Ren actually carved that wooden spoon from a pruned branch of our apricot tree. I'll talk about that in my wood working section soon. Not sure where the disposable wood knife came from though.

    The Bread Bible by Rose Levy Beranbaum

    Rose Levy Beranbaum - The Bread Bible

    In some circles, this is a very mainstream bread making book, but in other circles, it's quite unusual. That's a shame, because it really is quite good. I think it's a problem with the title.. (see my rant of biblical proportions at the bottom of this page).

    Alas, I digress....

    Now, this is a perfectly serviceable, beginner-friendly, well-rounded bread baking book. It's not trying to make you a pro baker, nor is it centred around any particular bread baking topic like sourdough, or covering in-depth science. It's just getting you to make good bread reliably, and it does that very well.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Wider-than-average range of general bread baking with a hint of brioches, biscuits, and pizza. It covers more bread types than most books, and some from underrepresented countries that aren't found in other books.

    Total page count: 640

    No. of pages before recipes: 97. There's also chapter-specific intros for each type of bread, and extra information at the end of the book, pertaining to both ingredients and equipment that would normally be put before the recipes.

    Metric/imperial units? Both

    Number of recipes: 88 total. 22 simple/batter breads, 11 flat breads (two pizza doughs), 11 sandwich loaves/dinner rolls, 24 hearth breads, 6 sourdoughs, and 9 brioches.

    Photos for every recipe? No. Actually this is perhaps one of the worst image arrangements I've ever seen. There are several sections in the book, each with a selection of full-page colour photos batched together, sometimes as much as 108 pages away from the recipe. (Rosemary foccacia image is on page between pages 95-96, but recipe on page 205, despite the fact there's another colour page section between page 192/193 much closer! Eeeesh!) There are also recipes with no photo at all.

    Price range (new): Kindle ebook $39 (AUD). Hardcover from $45-$130 (AUD, delivered)

    Price range (used): $ $33-50 (AUD, delivered).

    Notable Features & FYI: There's a lot of recipes and technical data for this price, especially second hand, so it's good value. The recipes work well and are extremely tasty. Although the broad range of recipes will definitely suit a wider audience. I also like the broader-than-average range of breads, notably the potato/sweet potato/less wheaten breads. Pictures are lacking, and in woeful placements relative to the recipes they depict. The full page photos are NOT included into the page counts, they're just 5-9 double sided colour photo pages, wedged between consecutive text pages. This makes them impossible to reference from the recipe pages. Don't assume they're in the closest batch of photo pages, either.

    That said, the recipes are very tasty, and work quite reliably.

    Ham's worked with this bread baking book too - Ciabatta!

    Ham's massively oversized ciabatta

    Here's my massively oversized ciabatta "slipper" (what loaves of ciabatta are sometimes called). I'd argue it's more akin to a ciabatta clown shoe in this case.

    The left image shows it in the oven, on a 16" (40.5cm) pizza stone with the short side facing the camera. Actually, it had slipped off the back of the pizza stone when I pulled the stone out slightly... so it's probably about 16" long. If it was shaped as a circle... the diameter would be about 15" (37.5cm)... and anyone who knows pizza, knows that's over 1.5x a normal 12" (30cm) pizza.

    It doesn't look tall, but it's 4cm tall on average (about 1.5")

    Honestly, I think I squashed it down a bit too far when I "dimpled" my ciabatta... but it's tasty and goes great with olive oil and a little salt.... or sliced into sections, works really well in a bruschetta. I also had to proof it for twice as long to get the tripling of my dough volume... it was a bit cold in the kitchen.., and I'd actually bake it darker next time, despite the convention to stop somewhere around "golden brown". So other than these quibbles, for a first go with Rose's recipe, the dough was a dream to work with, and really does taste like a freshly made ciabbata! (Although, it really is best consumed on the day it's made... it lasted about 3 days).

    Bread Baker's Apprentice - Book Cover

    Peter Reinhart's Bread Baker's Apprentice - 15th Anniversary Edition

    If you search for "Bread Baking Book" in your search engine of choice, chances are that this is definitely in the top 10. No review page would be complete without this award-winning book. (Interestingly, it's also a book I actually won).

    It's popular for a reason. It's definitely enough to get you baking amazing bread from a complete beginner state, and not only gives you much more detail on basic theory and recipes, but anecdotes about various professional bakers, the industry, and even Peter's reminiscences of how he got to where he is today. Every recipe is not only tested, but tested by professionals. So if you're a fan of Recipe Tin Eats (who tweak and constantly refine their base recipes into a reliable and achievable product), and expect that from your culinary books as well, you've come to the right place.

    The Bread Baker's Apprentice is a very pretty book and is probably in the library of most hobbyist bread bakers. If you're on any of the bread baking forums and you want to discuss books, this is one book that you're sure to find fellow readers.

    Why choose a Reinhart book?

    You can obviously see the two award logos on the cover, but I want you to focus on the top one, the "James Beard Foundation Book Award".

    Peter has written three bread books that won the award (the only author on the planet to do so). This is the second of that trilogy.

    • 2001: "Crust and Crumb"
    • 2004: "The Bread Baker's Apprentice"
    • 2010: "Peter Reinhart's Whole Grain Breads: New Techniques, Extraordinary Flavour" (This is on my "To Review" list).

    This is by far the most popular/main-stream one though, and after doing some number crunching, comes out with an identical average ranking of 8.66 (basically 9th position) across the three biggest bread-book ranking lists on the Internet. This average ranking of 8.66 is shared by the ever-popular "Tartine" by Chad Robertson. However, "Flour, Water, Salt, Yeast" by Ken Forkish, actually has the highest average rank of 4.33 (basically 4th position). Which just happens to be the next review!

    That said, rankings aren't everything and I've learned important lessons from most of these books, some of which aren't even on any of top 100 ranking lists (or top 139 as Goodreads has listed).

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Bread, bread, and more bread. Even the "sweet treats" are sweet buns. Oh, and "pizza Napoletana", and a couple of cheese-infused "torpedoes" (which are just big buns/small baguettes)

    Total page count: 321

    No. of pages before recipes: 114

    Metric/imperial units? Both

    Number of recipes: 46 (almost all are savoury-ish breads, maybe 4-5 are sweet buns/cinnamon infused snacks, there's also a single cracker recipe, and a pizza dough.

    Photos for every recipe? No. There's a few, here and there, but many don't have any images.

    Price range (new): $16-30 AUD (ebook) $46-80 (hardcover)

    Price range (used): $45-75

    Notable Features & FYI: This has an excellent, rather detailed bread making introduction and covers quite a bit of ground... which you'd expect with 100+ pages of knowledge and techniques before the first recipe.

    Once you get into the recipes, it's actually a quite-diverse and well-rounded bread recipe collection, featuring most of the more famous breads that many will at least be familiar with at a superficial level. (That helps when comparing home baked stuff to the commercial stuff you've had before). There's sure to be something for most people. Whether that's a simple white, to sprouted rice & wheat sourdough, a braided challah, English muffin, New York bagel, Italian ciabatta, or Swedish rye.... and 30 odd others!

    That said, the truly non-mainstream breads like Teff flour breads, or gluten-free options... are not heavily covered in this book. So you might need to look at other books for that stuff.

    While beginners could use the recipes in this book, just know that there's not a huge amount of photos to show what each recipe should look like. That said, there's a lot of good instruction in section two, and helpful photos that will help with various techniques and processes.

    The Bread Baker's Apprentice - Pros and Cons:

    If you're the kind of person who doesn't blink at spending extra on "artisan bread" at the bakery and want to "have a go" at making it at home (or know someone who does), this book will get you where you want to go, and prepare you for a wide variety of bread styles if you want to go even further.

    This book has a lot of fans, and I count myself as one of them. Although I must confess that I haven't felt so obsessed that I've completed "The Reinhart Challenge" (Which means you've made every recipe in the book). Yet I can see the appeal to those trying to find "their style" in the bread baking world.

    Reinhart is a serious authority, who's studied bread making in multiple countries, bakeries, and culinary institutes. He artfully paints a real picture of the trends in bread making over time (particularly with the updated 15th anniversary edition) but also connects and contrasts this to the rich history of family bakeries that have been running for generations. This book goes way beyond a simple recipe book, and that's what actually makes it readable.

    Ok sure, on one hand, it is a bread baking recipe book.. and the recipes have worked for us quite well in our house. However, it's one of the few books that I've actually read "cover to cover", and actually enjoyed it.

    That said...

    It covers a lot more material, so don't expect it to be a short read in a lunch break or something. Unless of course, you're a prodigiously fast reader.

    If you're just looking for a bread recipe book, then this will work like that. However you'll get more out of it if you read the section on the basics, and the other related bits (often linked within the recipes too). That said, it's definitely the recipes that will keep you coming back to this book and why I have it in my bread-related library.

    How good/accurate are the recipes?

    From the recipes we've made, they've come out very well, and they do taste great. However, you may have to develop your own interpretation that separates a "sticky dough" from a "tacky dough"... and so my advice is to accurately follow the recipe by weight measurements (not volume) if at all possible. It may take a few goes to really train your senses and skills, and that's completely expected.

    If any tweaks are needed, (like adding water) start by adding minimal amounts, and doing it once, then seeing how it goes after at least 30 seconds of mixing, give it time to infuse properly. Sometimes mixing takes a while to take effect!

    I find that if you're not multiplying the recipe quantities, and doing it "in the stated amounts", then a tweak is usually less than or equal to one tablespoon (or 2% by weight, whichever's smaller) of water/flour total. Obviously, if you're multiplying the quantities involved, then multiply that one tablespoon limit accordingly (and you may not need all of it). Judgement is a key skill to develop in home bread baking, and that only happens when you spend more time with doughs of various types. That said, keep the changes small from most recipes while you're developing your familiarity with dough.... that way you can't go "too far off the rails". When I started, I "tweaked it by untrained eye"... and it wasn't as good as it could be... that's for sure. :~P

    From absolute beginner to seasoned baker, I just don't think you can really go wrong with this book, for any circumstance. To some, I can see why it might look like a coffee table book, but it's also one of the best general bread baking books in this list. I do wish there were more pictures for each recipe.. because many simply don't have one. The recipes are good, but without pictures, I didn't always know just "how brown" I should bake the crust, nor did I have a good answer when I asked: "Is this a low-rise bread or did I do something wrong?".

    The sweet pastry section is definitely my better-half's favourite, and we adore the cinnamon buns. Meanwhile, I've been really enjoying their ciabatta and lighter sourdoughs. I've fallen into the trap of making my familiar favourites... so there's a still a number of recipes on our "to do" list.

    At $45-$150 Australian for a hard cover, (and sometimes ridiculous sums like $350+ for a soft cover... I'm looking at you Amazon) I highly recommend shopping around. If you're like us and tried to borrow it from the library, we found the only copy to be booked up months in advance. That told us that it might be something worthy of purchase, and when I won a Booktopia book voucher for reviewing books (what a shock) I grabbed this one with great enthusiasm. I'm certainly not regretting it at all. :-)

    Three loaves of

    Ham's first attempt at Pane Siciliano

    According to Peter, these should be shaped into S-shaped scrolls.. but that doesn't exactly go into the toaster very well. So here I've made them into loaves instead.... partly to make my life easier, and partly to try my new silicone loaf pans. The pans (by the way), are so much easier to get the loaves out than my old metal loaf tins. Although I had to reduce the temperature of the bake to their limit (220C/428F) and cook a bit longer. I chose to extend the 30min bake to 36mins and got this result.

    Actually, I'm extremely happy with how these turned out and the toasted seasame seeds, combined with slow rise, and the use of semolina with freshly ground flour (I replaced 30% of the plain bread flour for an extra boost in the flavour) and the honey lend it a complex sweetness. I didn't get those blisters that Peter mentioned due to my lower baking temp but it's pretty tasty all the same.

    Flour, Water, Salt, Yeast - By Ken Forkish (book cover)

    Ken Forkish's Flour, Water, Salt Yeast

    You may have noted in the cover image, that it has the same two awards as The Bread Baker's Apprentice. I also got this with the remainder of my winnings.

    Built from the "ground up" for home bakers exclusively without being limiting or too specific. It really is "pitched just right" for most people.


    In this book, Ken assumes no prior knowlege, and all recipes were tested on Ken's home oven, using equipment that's found in many homes or easily afforded. The book has loads of beautiful photos for a helpful reference, it's well presented, and every recipe is extensively tested.

    Flour, Water, Salt, Yeast is not just the title, it's the layout for every recipe in the book. Listing the ingredients in descending order by weight, and all recipes have 1kg of total flour weight for easy comparison. That gives you a great starting position from which to branch out from, and simplifies things from a learning perspective. No other book I've read does this. It might seem weird, but it provides real structure that teaches you how specific changes to the recipe impact the finished bread.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: General bread making, pizzas. Focusing on techniques which incorporate time and temperature as "ingredients"

    Total page count: 263

    No. of pages before recipes: 77

    Metric/imperial units? Ingredients are metric, equipment imperial (go figure). Temperatures, both (thankfully).

    Number of recipes: 36 in total.19 bread types, 4 pizza doughs, 3 pizza sauces, and 10 pizza/foccacia topping meal ideas.

    Photos for every recipe? Most, but not all.

    Price range (new): .$42-70 (AUD) typical hard cover. $12-24 (AUD) e-Book

    Price range (used): Same as new pretty much, depending on source and condition.

    Notable Features & FYI: Interesting side notes are worth a read. More advanced bread chapters have their own introductory knowledge/techniques/tools section prior to recipes. Chapters 2-4 are key, and really do set you up for success with most (if not all) later recipe sections. Later chapters with more advanced recipes have their own training sections becore the recipes that need to be read if you want positive and reliable results.

    Flour, Water, Salt Yeast - Pros and Cons

     Ken is yet another former IT guy (who worked for IBM) who ditched it all to chase his dream of being a baker. (What is it about IT guys and baking? Said the IT guy reviewing bread books... hehe) 

    This is another extremely popular bread making book that is right up there in "beginner friendliness", "informative", and altogether useful bread baking books, even to experienced bakers. Ken is not trying to simply provide reliable recipes (which he does), but the techniques to ramp up flavour intelligently, so you can really enjoy the finished product, in a multitude of situations. All of which will hopefully convince you that squeezing in a little bread making into your life here and there... however you can manage it, is worthwhile.

    Honestly, I don't think many books are quite as good at bread making "public relations" as this one. They all do it to some degree and all have their "hook" to get you to read (and buy) their book.

    However, if you're looking for a truly inspirational book as a gift, a coffee table book, a general knowledge/interest piece, or help you to fit bread baking into your busy schedule with few if any compromises.. this is it. Particularly if you have pizza lovers in the household.

    Wait, what has pizza got to do with it?

    Pizza dough is (as quoted in Flour Water Salt Yeast):

    "A natural extension for the bread baker.... Similarly, bread is a natural extension to pizza making... Read the basic instructions, then start at either end of the book and once you've mastered one, the other type is easier".

    Start at either end?

    Because the last quarter of the book is entirely dedicated to making great pizza. So if you've got a family so set in their ways, that anything beyond the whitest, most commercial bread ever is practically a sin.. the one thing pretty much everyone can agree on is a fierce love of pizza.

    So where The Bread Baker's Apprentice, Simply Bread, and many other bread books augmented their recipes with sweets like cakes and pastries to literally "sweeten the deal", Make Ahead Bread" did a little of that, but found a niche by offering tasty butters/spreads. Ken's gone a much more savoury route which I have to say, totally worked on me.

    While my focus is indeed on the bread side, being able to bake a great pizza to wow the masses either indoors on a miserable day, or outdoors on a charcoal barbecue from scratch has never disappointed anyone, and I've even been asked to "invite them over" whenever I feel like making a pizza.

    Timing is everything!

    I truly appreciate that Flour, Water, Salt Yeast (or "FWSY" on some bread making forums), provides various suitable timelines for every recipe so that almost anyone can find a convenient time to start baking great bread, all without compromising anything in the end result. If that's not "come to the dark side, we have great bread/pizza" ...I don't know what is!

    What makes this book worthwhile?

    Honestly, I like how it starts with Ken's back story, of learning to bake from several teachers, then the trials and tribulations of starting a bakery. Obviously he was ultimately successful, but people's appreciation of bread just 20 years ago was much different, and people didn't always appreciate good bread if it's not what they expected or were used to. He outlines some of his greatest criticisms, misfortunes, and mistakes, along with the successes and the help he got along the way. It's not a long-winded self-pity party for one, it's just acknowledging his shortcomings, and successes. I think that makes him far more credible as a writer, but also more relatable. Any bread baker will have ups and downs too. So I think it's good to know that even the pros struggle at times.

    Chapter 2: Theory/Techniques

    Ken talks about time and temperature as "ingredients". It even goes so far as mentioning that sometimes, the ingredients really are less impactful on the finished bread than the techniques used. Now, of course, that will upset some people, but that simple statement, when used intelligently, seems true enough from my experience.

    FWSY isn't just "Do this and you'll be good". It takes Ken's personal preferences and findings, the rationale behind them, how they were discovered, then discusses across several key techiques/processes like:

    • Using autolyse techniques,
    • the pros/cons of different preferments,
    • how using minimal commercial yeast but increasing the hydration levels and longer fermentation times develops stronger flavours,
    • the need to manage temperatures across the whole process,
    • why you might want to bake your breads "dark".
    • the importance of notes/observations in improving your bake from one loaf to the next.
    • How to adapt to a variety of different issues.

    ... amongst others.

    Chapter 3 covers the equipment side of things you'll need for bread, pizza and beyond, and why you'd benefit from them.

    So the first 61 pages are backstory and general theory. After that, we're into recipes. That said, there's more theory and guidance in each section as the book focusses on the specific "ins and outs" needed to make different breads.

    Ham's first attempt at Ken Forkish's "Overnight Country Blonde". Hehe

    Ham's first attempt at Ken Forkish's

    Ok, I did something a little bit different with "Flour, Water, Salt, Yeast"... like I didn't use yeast. At least, not the usual industrial yeast.

    Ken Forkish called this recipe "Overnight country blonde"... which conjures up all manner of interpretations. :-P Basically, it's a "pure levain" (or sourdough) but whether or not it's actually sour greatly depends on the starter culture that's used, and how slowly it's allowed to develop. This is the first of two very large loaves that I made in this batch.

    Actually this loaf is quite mild in the sour tang, but has a hearty rustic flavour from whole wheat and rye, and when you char it in a wood-fired manner (as shown here) it's really good. Honestly, Ren knew I had to be joking when I said that "I'd stayed up to play with my two overnight country blondes..." Mostly because no cheater would actually admit that, and that she was within earshot the entire time. :-) In my defence, I didn't name this recipe... I just had fun with it.... and who let's the truth get in the way of good story? It's more interesting than "I baked two large loaves of bread"... obviously.

    Evolutions in Bread by Ken Forkish

    Ken Forkish -
    Evolutions in Bread

    While it's inpired by Ken's "other bread books, like "Elements of Pizza" most directly, I find that it also extends on Flour, Water, Salt Yeast (FWSY) in several important ways. Firstly, it incorporates information that Ken has learned in the decade or so since the first books were published. It also makes keeping sourdough starters more efficient (less waste in the upkeep) and astute Forkish fans will see that "Evolutions in Bread" uses familiar artisan doughs to make pan loaves, new-but-still reminiscent dough recipes to do the same thing in a simplified way, or sometimes, a little of both!

    I like this book because it brings the lofty artisan goals of FWSY and aims it at making everyday breads, like everyday pan loaves, easy pizzas, etc. Every refinement has been made to encourage routine baking, and to make a loaf pan/Dutch oven shaped loaf and make it way better than commercial alternatives, all while using less ingredients.

    What I find most interesting of all, is that you can make the same dough, shape and bake it into a boule like in FWSY and make great bread, or shape and bake it into a loaf pan as described here, shape/bake it a little differently and get a different bread altogether that's still amazing. That was actually new for me.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Artisanal loaf breads fit for routine baking.

    Total page count: 249

    No. of pages before recipes: 80

    Metric/imperial units? Ingredients: Metric, Equipment: Both!

    Number of recipes: 21

    Photos for every recipe? Yes (ish)... not always the finished product.

    Price range (new): Hardcover range $46-$110 (Australian)

    Price range (used): Hardcover range $36-$70 (Australian)

    Notable Features & FYI: This is highly reminiscent of FWSY. The new sourdough techniques (even though Ken calls them "Levain" breads in the recipe section) are definitely a refinement from the previous books. This book is aimed at getting a higher "reward to effort" ratio, and reducing the complexities somewhat.

    I particularly like the discussion on various flour types, the home milling options, and the encouragement for you to simply try mixing the flours up with a little experimentation.

    Evolutions in Bread Pros and Cons:

    There's a lot to like about this book, and there's something for everyone. It may not have the high recipe count that you might expect from such a books, but it makes up for that in detailed explanations that's thoughtfully laid out across the entire book.

    The chapters explain ingredients and equipment, then methods and techniques, there's a chapter on levain/sourdough, then the rest is recipes. Although this is broken down into "same day recipes", "overnight cold proof recipes", "enriched dough recipes" and "dutch oven levain recipes".

    Want to bake a rye bread?  There's a recipe for that with a detailed-but-very-readable explanation about why you don't want to more than 50% of your flour to be made with rye. The answer? It has a very weak gluten structure... so unless you like really dense flat bread.. you need some non-rye in there.

    It also includes recipes that use spelt  flour, emmer/einkorn, hazelneut/pecan breads, brioche, as well as white and black bread recipes. So whether you like easy white breads, rustic einkorn sourdoughs, Japanese milk bread, or sourdough starter-based pizza bases... there's a little something for everyone. Honestly, I'm particulart excited to try the apple-cider levain breads, but I have to do that when I'm the only one left in the house.

    Things that could be improved...

    I'd really like to see a recipe index, or entries for each recipe to be in the index, as well as, the contents too if at all possible. The generalised same-day, overnight, sourdough chapters don't include what recipes are where.

    I personally find the way some recipes are writtten painful to read. I'd like it in sections like "ingredients for the roux and instructions for making it", then "this is the ingredients and related procedure for the next bit", rinse-lather-repeat. This has all the ingredients in one section, and all the instructions in another, and you might have steps that aren't actually about making the components, but are in the overall assembly that relate to component construction/handling.

    Bottom line: Read the entire recipe before starting, plan it out, but don't assume the bits are perfectly in order and complete in just one section.

    The other thing that I'd like to note, that unlike Ken's other book "Flour, Water, Salt, Yeast" the flour weights are aimed at loaf pans, not 1Kg amounts. Whether this suits your particular loaf pan.. is dependant on several factors like recipe density, environmental conditions and yeast activity to say the least. I think most pans would be ok with careful handling, but if you have a big loaf pan, then you may be underwhelmed or overflowing with a smaller one. You have to keep an eye on your dough, because I had two different loaf size from the same dough. Have a look at this:

    Shokupan or Japanese Milk Bread


    Ham's first attempt at Shokupan (Japanese Milk Bread) - Photo: Ren

    This is an unusual recipe in the simple fact that it uses a roux (cooked flour + water based sauce/slurry) as part of the process. In most other ways it's a slightly butter-enriched milk loaf.

    Believe it or not, these loaves with their substantially different proofing rates came from the same batch of dough. I don't know what happened there, they're the same amount of dough, down to the nearest 2g resolution of my kitchen scale. Hmmm.

    Whether you like a tight domed loaf, or a loaf wearing a beret though, I've got it covered! :-)

    The flavour is reminiscent of the Pain De Mie but it's softer on average, but slightly more dense... if that makes any sense to you. It's tasty though, cuts easily, and works in many situations.

    Alt Text

    The Basic Rye Loaf from "Evolutions in Bread" - Baked by Ham.

    To test Ken's "Evolutions in Bread" recipes. I started with one of the basic ones. Here's my first bake of the "the basic loaf". I doubled the recipe for two loaves, tweaked it a bit to suit our ingredients on hand (and tastes) but I think it came out pretty well. The process was sound, it's just that my execution, baking into the small hours of the morning (my fault) was less than ideal.

    The sliced (and notably shorter) loaf was baked in my prehistoric dented/rusty metal loaf tin, while the taller uncut loaf was baked in a silicone tray. The metal tray sapped some of the heat out of the dough during proofing, hence the lower rise.

    We ran out of baking paper, so I improvised with foil for the first time. That was a mistake, and took a lot of effort to remove every tiny bit of foil from the loaf.. and still didn't stop the dough from sticking to the pan either. Silicone loaf (pans?) don't need baking paper, so it might be time to grab some more silicone ones.

    Dough by Richard Bertinet

    Richard Bertinet - Dough

    This is Richard Bertinet's (first?) book in his bread series. It covers the basics of getting a wide range of good home made breads in his somewhat uniquely laid back way. As a single volume, "Dough" stands on it's own, but the other books ("Crumb" and "Crust") extend on this one in different ways. I'll compare and contrast them below.

    Every recipe that I've tried from Richard's books, videos, and indirect publications/collaborations has worked every single time. From bread, to braided cinnamon knots, even sweet treats that were "pushing my skill limit" made me not only more confident, but look good doing it.

    I'd also be remiss if I didn't mention some of the huge benefits that the amazing photography throughout the book brings to bakers. If it's not mere inspiration to "give it a go", it's an amazing reference to see what breads should and do look like when done well. Honestly, I would go to see an art exhibition of just bread if this was the quality of the imagery. I'd personally find it much more relatable than many of the more airy-hand-waving themes I find many artworks allegedly represent.

    There's some amazing recipes too. I actually found the edible soup bowl a lot of fun to make, (and surprisingly popular with the younger members of the extended family). I also liked Richard's decadent recommendation to make Ciabatta with avocado oil which really did make the texture soft while adding a slight green tinge to my crumb.

    The awards are no joke!

    One of the more interesting facts about this book is that it is a multi-award winning book! Only it doesn't have the logos on the cover like the others. Like "Flour, Water, Salt, Yeast" (or FWSY) and "The Bread Baker's Apprentice", (or BBA) "Dough" is another winner of the James Beard Award, just back in 2008 (perhaps they didn't have the award logo at that point) and he hasn't had a revised edition since then? The revised edition of "The Bread Baker's Apprentice" won in 2004, has had an update. Meanwhile, FWSY won later in 2015. Curiously, this along with FWSY and BBA, this book is consistently seen across all major ranking lists and has been there for a long time. It may not be as consistently ranked above top 20 in all the big lists, but technically, this book has won as many prestigious awards as the other two combined.

    Just some food for thought!

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus:  Definitely more of a recipe book than a textbook, but still very informative. While it does discuss various doughs as a focus of baking and how to make the most of them. I feel it's a bread making analogy of where beginner bakers might be in their journey. In stark contrast to "Sourdough Framework", "Bread Science", and most other bread books, Richard contends that you don't need to know how to rebuild a carburettor in order to drive a car, just know what good driving looks like and emulate it. This is his approach in most of his bread books. You just need to know what the basic processes and end product looks like.

    All in all, it's a very pretty book that would be great as a coffee table adornment, a good example of food photography if you have camera mavens in the household, it's good as a gift, or as a reference.

    Total page count: 160

    No. of pages before recipes: 32

    Metric/imperial units? Metric

    Number of recipes: 52 total, 14 white dough recipes, 9 olive dough recipes, 11 brown dough recipes, 8 rye doughs and 9 sweet dough recipes.

    Photos for every recipe? Almost all of them, 1-2 don't. Lots of useful images throughout the book though.

    Price range (new 2nd ed): $25-$60 (Australian) for a paperback, although the $25 end is often part of a bundle. $45-$80 for a hardcover.

    Price range (used): First edition softcover about $15-35 (AUD) and hardcovers come in at $30-$50. Second edition, $25-$50 (softcover), $35-$60 (hardcover).

    Notable Features & FYI: "Dough" has been translated into 9 languages, page 16 has the best colour photo representation of just how cooked a loaf should be when made with white doughs (obviously, dark flours would be darker for each stage) and there's nine images, ranging from raw to perfectly baked, all the way to burnt. So you can compare where your bread bake is at.

    Dough - Pros and Cons:

    Pros:

    Firstly, would I be comfortable in recommending this book to a beginner? Absolutely. There's nothing here that would overwhelm anyone possessing rudimentary baking skills. All you need is to read the recipe carefully, get everything ready to go before start, measure everything out carefully, and follow the instructions. Intermediate bakers can also benefit from this book because this covers some material that's oddly missed in many of the other books listed here.

    Aside from detailed descriptions of how baked/toasted bread gets in numerous stages of the cook. "Dough" features some of the most diverse range of bread loaf shaping, starting wigh fougasse, epi, lemon rolls, bread shots, and dough puffs, along with the usual loaves, boules, torpedos, baguettes and rolls. I really like that you can take most of these recipes and really "go to town" by presenting it in fancy ways. Few if any books in this list do that, so it augments other books well.

    Cons:

    Now, if you're expecting the correct photos for the recipe to be placed conveniently "at hand", you'll be a little disappointed. There are several "two page spreads" showing a selection of finished breads. The problem is, that they're at the start of each section. The images are clearly labeled, so you can go "ooh that looks tasty"... and flip to it. However, you get to the recipe and there's b-roll pictures of Richard scraping dough out of a mixing bowl... when the finished product shot could have been in the most logical and convenient spot.

    As a stand-alone book, it's very good, but it can seem a little incomplete in a few places. It wasn't designed to be a "compendium of all things bread". As such it's a bit of a "gateway drug" to buying Richard's other books which I have reviewed below. That said, as a recipe book it's very good.

    Recipes I like in this book:

    I particularly like the red onion and smoke bacon bread and doughnuts for shameless comfort food. The cracker puffs are fantastic if you're hosting a party and out of biscuits, but they're only good "on the day" and I'd encourage complete consumption within a few hours for best experiences. The cider bread is also very good, but didn't make the "first time try for review purposes" seen in the recipes here.

    Conclusion:

    I have a very high success rate with this book, the recipes are diverse enough to keep me coming back, the instructions are clear, and for the most part, the book is clean and well-presented. Unless you're a particularly advanced bread baker, this book would offer something to everyone, and have a place in their bread baking libraries.

    Classic Baguette

    Ham's first attempt at Classic Baguette (Pic: Ren)

    In true form, Richard's simple classic baguette uses the first "white dough" recipe that several recipes extend from. While it's simple to make, the results from Richard's books are surprisingly reliable. I really like this recipe because it get's a finished product within 3 hours of starting.

    Obviously, to get such a fast turn-around, extra yeast is needed, and all longer-term proofing that is usually characteristic of prefermented/levained/sourdough breads is skipped. So you won't be getting those extra flavours such processes bring. That said, for a quick bread, I highly recommend baking the bread to a slightly darker golden colour, because if it's a particularly pale gold colour, I don't think it's properly cooked through and can get that slightly undercooked taste/texture.

    Honestly, this is a great bread for cooking for social gatherings or prompt use. The longevity isn't there. In that sense, it's truly French in style, because no Parisian would eat day old bread. That said, if you're planning to eat it the day after baking, I'd slice it and freeze it promptly after cooling down, but on the day, it's a very satisfying bread and the house smells just like a french boulangerie.

    This particular baguette was baked on a baking steel, and I added steam into the oven as I put the dough in for baking. It actually rose quite well, and the finished product had a softer crust that cracked under load, but it wasn't that snappy/crunchy noise I expected from a baguette though. The crumb was quite uniform and soft. Those slices (cut diagonally through the loaf) are roughly 20cm long, and about 9-10cm high (8" long, 4"ish high). The whole baguette was about 65-70cm (26-28") long, and 15cm (6") wide.

    White dough pillow crackers

    Continuing on from the baguette bake above, I've used some of Richard's "basic white dough" again to go in a different direction.... notably to make cracker puffs which Richard would normally make much larger, and fill with salad and such... I just shamelessly used them to make quick crackers for dips. That said, this dough has almost zero longevity, so you have to eat it on the day it's made.. the next day.. it's just not as good.

    Crust (2025 edition) by Richard Bertinet

    Richard Bertinet -
    Crust

    Crust focusses on breads/pastries that take longer to make. So it's basically the sourdough extension (with some long fermented variations of croissants and other pastries) to Richard's previous book "Dough".

    I really like that it starts to dabble in differing flours which can add a great deal of flavour to breads, and in this regard pairs well with "Flour Lab", "The Taste of Bread", and "The Nordic Baking Book". Naturally, it brings Richard Bertinet's casual style to sourdough baking, and as such augments the numerous other sourdough books in this list.

    I wouldn't say that buying/reading "Dough" is a pre-requisite for understanding "Crust", but it would help. That said, many other basic bread books would give you the foundation you'd want in order to work with this one too.

    ...Although, if you like Richard's style of writing, and very pretty books with excellent recipes, then I highly recommend getting the discounted two or three volume sets I've seen available.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Sourdough, levain, and longer-make bread variants... with some sweets in there too. This also looks into unusual flour types (or flour replacements/amendments) such as flours made from dried, powdered cabernet grape skins. WARNING: DO NOT USE THE GRAPE FLOUR SUPPLIER LINK ON PAGE 156, IT HAS BEEN HACKED AND THE SUPPLIER SITE'S ADOBE FLASH FRAMEWORK HAS BEEN UNSUPPORTED SINCE 2020! DO NOT TRUST THIS SITE WITH YOUR MONEY! BUY IT SOMEWHERE ELSE!

    Total page count: 159

    No. of pages before recipes: 53

    Metric/imperial units? Both

    Number of recipes: 33 (including variants of first bread, and croissants, but ignoring the recipes for sauces and other additions to the primary recipes).

    Photos for every recipe? Yes, but not all the variants within the recipe.

    Price range (new): First edition: e-book $15 (AUD) Soft cover $30-$50. Hard cover $30-$65 (AUD) Second edition (2025): Hard cover $35-$80 (AUD)

    Price range (used): Not overly different to new prices.. for the most part. At least, not at the time of writing.

    Notable Features & FYI: This is the 2025 (The second, just released edition, at the time of writing). It was officially released less than 2 weeks ago.

    Honestly, if you like a lot of step-by-step photos, and nice balance between pretty and useful... then you're sure to like "Crust". Another, very pretty book. Full of no-nonsense-but-simplified information and later, recipes. There's an interesting discussion on the "health of bread" in the back, as well as what to do with leftover breads... (I particularly like "Le Pudding" found on page 154).

    Crust: Pros and Cons

    Like almost every other book in this list, it has an introductory section. However, this one has a few things that, despite it being shorter than some of the others, involve tips that make life a lot easier.

    It actually lives up to it's name and has a section dedicated to "Achieving the crust". It's only a couple of pages long, but it really helps.

    Perhaps the biggest thing for me is the "What about the weather?" section. In this bit, it covers tweaks that significantly improve a recipe's reliability and adjust a recipe to cope with changing conditions. Once you figure out the proportion of those changes, you can apply that to any recipe of that type from any book. That has far-reaching benefits to me or any other serious baker.

    This book goes through each of the major steps of bread making, one section at a time, and helps to refine the entire bread making procedure. Like every baker I've met, I'm better at some parts of the process than others, and this has helped improve some of my weaker areas. It also helped me to "go easier" on some of my stronger sections which helped tame my inner over-enthusiastic tendencies. More isn't always the same as better.

    Outside of the basic introductory section, you'll find that it discusses autolyse in the "Slow" section which specialises in preferments/sourdough/levain breads that take longer.

    I also like the "Different" section which discusses bread recipes using different grains, grape flours, even chestnut flours. Which I have to say certainly are different to most of the other bread boks.

    Finally, I like the "Fact or Fiction" section which is actually quite an interesting read. It discusses how many people's issues with bread stem not just from buying the wrong type's of bread, but what we do with them. It also addresses some of the misconceptions that are so prevalent in the media.

    Now for the cons:

    I've already discussed the hacked site listed in the places to source ingredients. However, for a book on Crust... I'm a little... disappointed. Yes the crust section is helpful, but it's not what I would call in-depth enough for a book supposedly dedicated to the topic. I'd really have liked a more in-depth look at what makes a thin crispy crust vs a chewy one vs. a soft sponge-like one, and how to tweak from one to the other, and anything in between. Yes, there's recipes from each category, but I think Crust is just a name.. and there's just as much dough work, and crumb development in the recipes as Richard Bertinet's other bread books. If you're looking for presentation of the crust, ironically, "Crumb" (reviewed next) has as much if not more tips.

    After all that's said and done...

    This is still a book I've used and enjoyed reading, and it does have some really interesting ideas that aren't in other books.

    Ham's first attempt at the "Poolish Baguettes"

    Ham's first attempt at Poolish Baguettes

    The baguettes, that scream: "come hither, take a bite!" (photographed by Ren)

    Not bad for a first attempt. However, there's a couple of things that I should warn you about. Firstly, the recipe of the poolish preferment makes 870g... but the baguette recipe only requires 600g. I don't like this disjointed "save some preferment for another project"... mentality. I like it proportional from start to finish. Yet if you need more, and you can use it... who am I to judge?

    I have to ask: "But what if you don't want any more bread that day?... Or even, several days later?"

    In the end, I multiplied the rest of the baguette recipe to match the poolish, and those baguettes got big. It barely fit in my 7qt Kitchen Aid (almost 8L) bowl. I then had to split it between two bowls as it would overflow.

    When shaping, I intentionally made them shorter so they'd fit on my pizza stones. They range from 34 to 45cm long. However when you've got enough to make five baguettes that are chunky as well, space in the oven (particularly as it rises) becomes an issue. It got a little close, and those spots didn't brown as much, but it's still a perfectly serviceable baguette, soft on the inside, flakey on the outside,and really does go well with a slow cooked beef and salad!

    Like most baguettes, the shelf life isn't the greatest... Ummmm... I hope there's room in the freezer. This is just three of the baguettes, and that crate is huge, (but over 30cm/1ft long) so it's bigger than you might think. If you're using that as a reference.

    Crumb by Richard Bertinet

    Richard Bertinet - Crumb

    This kinda follows "Dough", and includes little bits of sourdough side of "Crust", but importantly goes into using various flour types (like "Flour Lab") for flavour and health benefits (like gluten free) as well as mixing a number of unusual ingredients ranging from seaweed, chocolate, cheese, green pea flours, and even how to make brioche ice cream. So it starts drifting into more pastry/desserts somewhere along the way.

    Honestly, I'm not convinced of the benefit of using squid ink to make black rolls... I've had commercial versions of it and aside from the colour, there wasn't much impact on the flavour, but I've liked some of the other ideas, and I'm excited to try the rest.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: If "Dough" was about the fundamentals of bread baking, and"Crust" focussed largely on improving flavour/colour further. "Crumb" is structure and texture centric, along with additional flavour enhancements, and further adaptations to appearance. In short, getting fancy without too much stress!

    Total page count: 224

    No. of pages before recipes: 60

    Metric/imperial units? Metric

    Number of recipes: 50 in total. 20 breads/rolls, 1 pizza, a sourdough cracker, some tarts, cinnamon scrolls (which are really good), crumpets, blue corn pancakes, and several meal options, each more decadent than the last.. basically recipes that involve cooking with bread, or dipping it in something like gazpacho.

    Photos for every recipe? Almost, there's a couple that don't... but they're very few. Lots of step-by-step "how to" series of images though!

    Price range (new): e-book: $20 (AUD).Hardcover: $50-$100 (AUD)

    Price range (used): Unfortunately, there are very few found at the time of writing, some more expensive than the new ones!

    Notable Features & FYI: This is another very pretty book. I genuinely like how he's broken these books into differing, but interrelated themes. Honestly, I don't think you need to read "Dough" or "Crust" to benefit from this book. Again, if you're even vaguely comfortable with sourdough then I think you'll be ok! I've made some of these recipes several times (occasionally on demand) and even the fancy cinnamon scrolls really aren't that hard at all to accomplish. Just make sure your butter is nice and soft and you won't go wrong! The Miche is delightful, although I sometimes tweak the recipe to make it a little more to my tastes, and the Brioche icecream is exactly as amazing, decadent and fattening as you'd expect it to be.... because.. I know that... now. It's also excellent with a hint of cinnamon and Irish cream. So much so, I bought Ren a case of Irish cream.

    Ham's first attempt at the

    Ham's first attempt at the "Leopard Bread" recipe:

    Most people (and bakeries) call this "Tiger Bread", but Richard calls it "Leopard Bread" instead. He thinks it's closer to a leopard's pattern.. but admits that each and every loaf is different. When you slice and toast it, the crumb browns from the crust edges inwards, and the external "spots" on the crust form slight stripes on the surface of the cut slice's crumb. Maybe that's what most people are talking about?

    Actually, this was my first attempt at making a bread like this and it worked, first time. The dough was incredibly forgiving. Yet it took longer to mix "until it comes clean off the bowl sides" than indicated. However, I almost doubled the size of the dough as instructed, then brushed on the paste as described. Yet I found that I had a lot left over. I found that the paste recipe quantities should be reduced by a third.... perhaps even halved in my humble opinion. Maybe I didn't lay it on thick enough? I don't think so, but this worked, and I'm happy with the result.

    What's in a name? My choice of recipe in this book works on several levels...

    This recipe has a very light crust, because it's based on the "Pain De Mie" recipe which translates to "Bread of the Crumb" (notably not of the crust)... and it truly lives up to the name. The added milk, butter in the dough and added sesame oil of the paste creates a very soft loaf that is reminiscent of a milk bread or brioche, although it's not quite as fatty as a brioche. That's not surprising, considering the added milk, butter, and even occasional oils used in those recipes too.

    Considering that the book is called "Crumb", How could I not choose "Bread of the Crumb" then add a little ironic flair on the crust? I'm living up to my wayward tendencies. (I'd hate to disappoint).

    After the bake...

    Whatever you choose to put on this bread, it needs a light touch. While you could drizzle honey, or spread a soft cream cheese on this bread... or rest sliced meats/salads.... be warned: you're not going to spread hard chunks of butter on this... it'll break the bread. Nor is it... particularly load bearing if sliced thinly and eaten fresh. That said, if you need a little extra "hardness" from this bread, toasting it helps... and it really makes a pleasant burger bun (well, sandwich in my case) because you're already squashing it down to take a bite.

    I can see why Pain De Mie is a staple for many french homes. It's versatile and has a pleasant flavour, without a lot of the "messing about" that more involved recipes need. It's softness makes it easier on children and the elderly alike, and I am not ashamed to admit that I had a second helping of toast for breakfast this morning. I don't do that very often.

    The recipe worked really well and I have no complaints about the book's instructions either. There is a bit of flipping between recipes for this one, and the guides on how to fold a dough are in the introductory section. That said, there's enough images to get a very good idea of what to do, and the results speak for themselves. I'm proud of this one!

    Gennaro's Italian Bakery by Gennaro Contaldo

    Gennaro Contaldo - Gennaro's Italian Bakery

    I picked this one up, second hand online and I honestly didn't have a huge amount of expectation. It was cheap, and I wanted to see a bread book that wasn't quite so French bread oriented.

    Gambling $24 dollars (delivered) paid off!

    So I did some research into this "Gennaro guy" (showing you how little I knew at the time) and in some ways, he's more famous than many of the other authors. Apparently, Gennaro's the guy who taught Jamie Oliver how to cook italian food. He's run TV shows, and famous award-winning restaurants.. we don't get his shows here in Australia. I might have seen him in a YouTube video at some point.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Explicitly and perhaps exclusively limited to Italian baking. It's dominated by bread (if you include the sweet breads with the savoury bread and pizza recipes), but adds numerous Italian baked goods to augment those breads too.

    Total page count: 234

    No. of pages before recipes: 20

    Metric/imperial units? Both.

    Number of recipes: 112 Total. 45 breads/pizzas, 11 pies/tortes, 12 sweet leavened breads, 11 sweet tart-related recipes. 12 biscuits, and 8 cakes.... and 13 additional recipes.

    Photos for every recipe? No. 72% do though... some a few pages away from the recipes.. and are NOT labelled. So don't be afraid to flip a few pages further to see if the pic is there.

    Price range (new): $30-$50 (AUD) for the hardcover.

    Price range (used): $20-40 (AUD) for the hardcover.

    Notable Features & FYI: This is a slightly "off the beaten track" book here in Australia. However, if you're looking to more Italian-inspired bakery as opposed to the often-French inspired books that dominate the bread making book world, then you've come to the right place.

    Gennaro's Italian Bakery: Pros and Cons:

    Cons: Not much theory or technique here! Also, non-Italian palates should skip ingredients they don't like.

    This is very much, a recipe book, first and foremost. Yes there's a tiny bit of theory before the recipes, but since the recipes start on page 20, and the introduction is on page 6... you have to expect very succinct introductions for each topic.

    There's two pages that discuss flours, a page about yeast, and about a page on Biga (a drier-than-poolish preferment, it usually has 50-60% hydration instead of a Poolish's typical 100% hydration). There's a few pages describing mixing, resting and shaping the dough process then we're "off to the races" as far as recipes are concerned.

    Perhaps the biggest con for me is that there's a lot of olive-infused this, or nut-encrusted that, and sometimes, there's strange mixes in there that as an Aussie, I'm probably not going to make. I get that it's authentic, but if you don't like olives or nuts.. then authenticity has it's limits. However, I've simply skipped or swapped out the ingredients I am not fond of, and this often works quite well.

    Pros: It really does live up to the title.... and, calzones!

    Firstly, if it's not baked, it's not in here. So this book skips pasta entirely, given that it's not baked. So it's clear about what it's about and you must keep your expectations in line with that.

    There's some breads, tarts, and pies that are genuinely not in the other books I've got (and again, I've looked... whatever that's worth).

    Honestly, the book is quite pretty, it's not gorgeous, but it's worth reading.

    While there are recipes that are not to my tastes, the Tuscan sweet bread (Pan Dolce Tuscano) was a welcome change when we're inundated with citrus. We'd drowned ourselves in marmalade, and added juice to everything in sight.. a little extra zest usage for something less overtly citrusy was greatly appreciated.

    The "focaccia con patate cipolle rosse e pancetta" (or Focaccia with potato, red onion and Italian bacon) is literally one of my most favourite comfort foods I've ever made. (I sometimes slip a little hot salami in, perhaps a Calabrese, or Soppressata for a little extra kick, and maybe a sprinkle of parmesan if I've got one open). If I listed all the recipes I liked... I'd waffle on. So let's just say I like the book, ok?

    Any book that covers both pizza and calzone like this one, get's a special mention. Most books focus on pizza. The doughs are simple, effective, and very tasty. Calzone is an often-overlooked variation on the pizza theme and I appreciate that it's included here.

    Who would this book suit?

    Any Italian lover (or Italophile, if you prefer) who likes baking their own breads, pizzas, cakes, biscuits, etc) would have no qualms in reading and enjoying this book. That said, if you have a particular interest in making calzones, then this is also a great book for that.

    If you're more of a "American" pizza lover, don't like olives/nuts, or any of the truly "mediterranean" flavours.. then you might want to look elsewhere. This book is not about "fusion" food styles, but true Italian recipes.

    AAARGH! I've made more than a few recipes...

    Hmmm, for this book's "demonstrated bake", I have to choose something I haven't made before... <cue drum roll>

    Treccia con ricotta e salvia

    Ham's first attempt at: "Treccia con ricotta e salvia" .

    Treccia con ricotta e salvia is roughly translated as "Braid with ricotta and sage". This is actually a really interesting recipe because the ricotta gives it a milk bread-esque feel, the extra saltiness from the ricotta also helps with the umami (savoury flavours), the oils that many fetas are stored in gives the crumb a very soft, almost enriched texture, and the honey used adds the identifiable honey smell and hints of sweetness to the bread. The sage was skipped in this bake because my poor sage plant is struggling in the summer heat wave. I'm not depriving it of it's few remaining leaves.

    So if you like slightly adding cream cheese and honey to your toast, and like the texture of milk bread... you'll definitely like this one. The braided format makes it ideal as a pull apart, that works well for sharing, picnics, and any situation where a bread knife isn't conveniently to hand. The braid really reminds me of Challah, a Jewish bread, but many breads around the world are braided.

    Make Ahead Bread book cover

    Donna Currie Make Ahead Bread

    No time to cook, let alone bake your own bread? Honestly, we've all been there.

    The beauty of this book is that it takes the process of making bread and breaks it up into nice, manageable stages. It will of course, still involve effort, but more a matter of 5-10 minutes here and there.

    This is a very approachable book. 12 pages of basic tools and concepts, and the rest is recipes, moving from loaf recipes, buns/rolls/sticks, flatbreads, pastries. The book then discusses what to do with leftover breads to save you even more time baking, and finishes up with some recipes for some spreads/butters that'll top the finished products, appendix, and some conversion tables in the back. At a total of 199 pages, this soft cover book has 100 recipes in it. That's a pretty good page-to-recipe ratio, but it does so by cutting down on pictures.

    Now my copy is a soft cover, and I have not found a hard copy. For $60 Australian, it's certainly not the cheapest book, and the price varies quite a lot. You can get an e-book version for as little as $16, which is definitely one of the cheaper e-books. However, there's quite a few being sold second hand on eBay for as little as $12... which is a steal!

    So as always shopping around can determine whether or not this book is worth the price or not.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Make ahead bread, basically making the dough when you can, then baking on demand.

    Total page count: 201

    No. of pages before recipes: 12 (this is largely a recipe book with a bare minimum of theory).

    Metric/imperial units? Imperial only with volume as backup. Urgh!

    Number of recipes: 117 total. 30 loaf breads (some sweet), 32 buns/rolls/breadsticks (again, some sweet), 16 flat breads/pizzas, 9 pastries, 14 "leftover breads", BONUS, 16 jams/spreads.

    Photos for every recipe? No. There are 34 pics for 117 recipes (barely 29% of recipes). That said, there are several recipes with images and the recipe variants would be extremely similar... If that helps. This isn't true of all the recipes though. None of the "Leftover bread" or "Spreads" have dedicated images.... just so you know.

    Price range (new): $30-$75 (AUD) softcover.

    Price range (used): $12-$25 (AUD) softcover.

    Notable Features & FYI: I wasn't kidding when I said that there are no metric measurements. So if you're in metric-loving lands, I recommend spending a rainy afternoon going through and noting the metric equivalents for each of the 117 recipes. Yes, that's going to be tedious.

    This book, while usable by beginners, would probably best suit bakers who are familiar with the overall bread baking process, and only need clear instructions to get the job done. For this reason, I'm putting it at slightly less beginner friendly and more for intermediate bakers.

    Now not every recipe is "pure bread" but from the recipes I've read (and remembered) the "non-bread" recipes include things that bread can be a component of, (bread pudding) or the other recipes pair well with bread.. like soup. Don't worry, there's quite a few flavoured/infused/enriched/sweet breads too!

    One of the interesting things about this book is the numerous ways to make flatbreads! There's literally "Flatbreads on the grill" recipes, there's "Frying pan flat breads", even how to bake naan on a metal baking sheet in the oven. So unless you're down to "sticks over a fire"... in which case, I'd simply add a hot flattish rock to the fire, and then pull it out to bake on... chances are, you can use at least one recipe with whatever you've got.

    Honestly, there's a huge range of recipes, many with various means to make them, and they do it by easing the time requirements to make the breads in question. That's got to help right?

    So for the less visual folks, those with a bit of bread making experience behind them. then this book is really quite a good book to get. If you're looking for detailed knowledge and instruction with lots of pretty pictures... this isn't for you.

    I have to say the "Whole wheat and parmesan pizza crust" is not only convenient for a cheese/bread making hobbyist for myself, it's absolutely divine with a less pungent 4 year aged Parmesan (I intentionally dropped the lipase, which often gives Parmesan that pungency), and it worked so well with a home grown tomato passata! If you buy your ingredients, I'm sure it'll still be an excellent recipe.

    Make Ahead Bread - Pros and Cons:

    This book prioritizes bread making speed and efficiency over extracting the best possible flavour from your ingredients. It makes no secret of this fact, and is the fundamental point of this book. However, this is one of those 80% of the gains for 20% of the effort... and that 80% is still very tasty! I honestly believe that the benefits do outweigh the drawbacks by a hefty margin. Other reviewers have criticised the book with lower scores because they've forgotten this fact, and I personally think that's unfair.

    The point of this book is to get people who would otherwise never have time to bake bread, be able to squeeze it in to their busy lives and get them baking. From there, we can worry about the "honing of the craft" later. Viewed in this light, Donna has done an exceptional job. Even I as a guy who uses preferments all the time, and will bake for half a day, appreciate the fact that last-minute situations can be solved using these techniques. This isn't an either/or thing, it's a "This can help in difficult situations, as well as everyday use... " thing.

    Of the recipes I've tried, I have noticed that the breads don't always rise as much as the more-involved recipes, but when I say "not as much" it's either a little bit less.... or quite a bit more. Maybe I have stronger yeast than Donna, maybe I left it in a warm spot.... in any case.. there's a bit of variability and I'm ok with that. If it gets me hot crusty dinner rolls, or freshly made burger buns for my next barbecue in spontaneous situations, then I'm happy. I don't want to sell this book short though.... The results I've had are often still more than enough to rival many the better examples of store bought bread, by the simple virtue that it's as fresh as it gets, and even a simple 2 minute tweak or added ingredient can take it from "very good" to "wow". That's a great "cost-to-benefit" ratio. Even if the original recipes seem a little "ho-hum" on first glance... or if you're of a much younger/younger persuasion... I guess that would be "meh" and "blah" respectively. :-) (See, I'm hip with oldies and newbies alike.... or not. Hehe). I urge you to give the recipes a try because they've pleasantly surprised us at most turns.

    Make Ahead Bread Pros:

    One of the things I like most about this book is it's efficiency wherever I turn. Want to start a sourdough starter without committing to rigid feeding schedules and tossing out half or even 80% of your starter on a regular basis? Then here's the instructions for adding ounces or fractions of an ounce each day where other books describe cups or fractions thereof. Whatever units used, this book starts small and maintains the starter with far less waste and "chucking out" starter on a daily basis. For metric lovers, that's 28g for an ounce... which is perfect for bakers who aren't baking every day.

    I tested their "making sourdough starter" process and it worked pretty well. In a weird way, starting small and adding a tiny amount each day to feed it is far less wasteful. Also, simply stating "just stir your starter whenever you're in the kitchen or happen to be nearby" makes me far more likely to do it, and it really made a difference. Sometimes I've taken weeks to get a starter going... and I was pleasantly surprised to start seeing bubbles on day 4, more bubbles by day 5, and I was pretty much ready to bake by day 6. The small feedings really do work with my once/twice a week bread baking routine.

    Make Ahead Bread Cons:

    When you read a "loaf pan" recipe and it says spray the pan with oil, cooking spray, or smear it with butter.. that is not a suggestion. Do it, do it lots, and do it comprehensively. These recipes stick so well at times, even silicone loaf trays are prone to sticking more than I'm used to. That said, the higher hydration loaves are worth it... because they taste much better.

    Of course, you know that I've said that it doesn't rise as much...

    Sunflower seed mini loaf... only without seeds and not so mini either.

    Ham's first attempt at "Sunflower seed mini loaves", from Donna Currie's "Make Ahead Bread"

    Only you could be forgiven for not knowing that, because I ran out of sunflower seeds and made the loaf a "normal size". Except, I was supposed to proof this overnight in the fridge... but it started to rise and overflow within an hour.

    Not sure what's going on there....

    So I rushed it through to the bake in order to stop my crisper from turning into a dough filled bog at the bottom of my fridge. Fortunately, since it was already in the loaf pan, banging it into the oven as soon as it had heated up wasn't hard. However, the sideways movement continued, even during the bake. Now this is a typical sized loaf pan, but it's hard to see that from above. However the slices are the typical dimensions... just with extended wings... as shown in the right-hand image.

    Freshly baked though, the bread is very tasty, the normal crust is crunchy and the wing tips are even more so.If you thought the slice looks like a mushroom, you're not the only one. :-)

    I've never had such a fast rise before, and I think I'll dial the amount of yeast back a bit next time.

    Dutch Oven Sourdough

    Dutch oven sourdough

    Ok, sometimes recipes are merely guidelines that your situation can't stick to, and some improvisation is needed. Whether you've used a dutch oven because your loaf pans were loaned out, or you simply have a simple cast iron pot over a fire when camping.... you can make a surprisingly good sourdough with the equipment you have. Here, I've lined a dutch oven with baking paper, poured my sour dough into it, and proofed it overnight, ready to bake. Now normally, I'd preheat the dutch oven, but I just cranked the oven to 260C (500F) for 30 mins to get some heat into the iron, and then baked it at 180C (356F) for 60 mins, then took it out of the pot and baked at 220C (428F) to evenly brown the crust for 20 mins.

    Now, I'm not going to lie, this crust is quite hard, because the cold iron that would normally be preheated took time to heat up. But it is delicious. As my first sourdough bread using Donna's sourdough starter, that long overnight proof in the fridge doesn't rise much (but it still hit the flat lid of my dutch oven during the bake) but brought out a notable sourdough flavour. It's not the most tart/tangy flavour I've had, but it's there and "up-front" and it would absolutely suit the preferences of folks who like a mild-er sourdough experience.

    Despite not being put in loaf pans as suggested by the sourdough loaf recipe, even though the pans would heat up much quicker than the cold dutch oven I used. Adding further complications, I also doubled the recipe and made it into a single, dutch oven-sized loaf, and a tiny mishap with the scales turning off in mid-pour, which had the unintended effect of tweaking the hydration level when explicitly told not to... I managed to bring it back to a "sticky dough" during mixing.. and it did really well. I think that's a testament to both the recipe's robustness (it was clearly well tested, thanks Donna!), and my experience in solving a few problems along the way. :-)

    New Artisan Bread in 5 Minutes a Day by Jeff Hertzberg & Zoe François

    Jeff Hertzberg & Zoë François -
    The New Artisan Bread in 5 Minutes a Day

    Much like "Make Ahead Bread" This book aims to make bread making as simple as possible, where it's possible to make one batch of dough, leave it in the fridge for days (perhaps a week or so) and just pour/slap a bit of that dough into a pan and bake as needed.

    Compared to Currie's "Make Ahead Bread", "New Artisan Bread in 5 Minutes a Day" is definitely more well-known... So much so, it inspired a series of these "5 mins a day" books (also called "Bread in 5" online). This is the original generalised book, but there's also specialist editions such as:

    • a gluten free book (reviewed below),
    • a pizza/flat bread book,
    • a "healthy bread" book,
    • a "holiday & celebration bread" book.. and if that wasn't enough...
    • a "best of the aforementioned books"... book.

    Popularity aside, there's definitely differences in the approach and bits in the previous book that aren't covered here. Just as this one has unique bits too.

    As always, every book has it's strengths, and weaknesses. :-)

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: A general bread and bakery book, specialising in recipes that can be made in bulk easily then baked as needed.

    Total page count: 381

    No. of pages before recipes: 53

    Metric/imperial units? Both with volume measurements as backup.

    Number of recipes: 115 total. 11 variations from the master recipe, 46 "peasant loaves", 23 flatbreads/pizzas, 8 gluten-free breads, & 27 enriched breads/pastries.

    Photos for every recipe? No, there's a selection in the "colour photo pages" but they are not necessarily near the recipe in question. That said, the photos are labelled with the page numbers of the appropriate recipe.

    Price range (new): $40-75 (Australian) for the hard cover.

    Price range (used): $45-$105 (be careful with shipping.. it really adds up here, but if you're in the US/Europe.. then things are much better. Australians are likely best served with buying new, and taking advantage of any sales as they arise. There's also an original edition called "Artisan Bread in 5 Minutes a Day" (Note the lack of "The New..." in the title, which can be as low as $5 second hand. It doesn't have the updates of this edition, but if you're on a budget, maybe it's worth looking into. Just keep those shipping costs in mind when you order it. It's not always the best deal.

    Notable Features & FYI: This book has a wide range recipes. From Wurzelbrot, to Limpa, "Tapenade bread" to "Vermont Cheddar Bread". In short, it's all over the map, including many of the popular well known breads around the world. So that's a huge plus.

    My greatest complaint is the publishing style....

    There are three clusters of glossy photo pages, at roughly 25%, 50%, and 75% through the book. However, while these photos are very beautiful... there's only 34 images (none of which are actually on a numbered page themselves, they're just "wedged in there". 34 represents a mere third of the recipes. Now the astute die-hard fans/readers will point out that there's a single image showing "the loaf breads" (6th image of the first cluster of photo pages) However, these are not labelled to identify which recipe corresponds to which loaf in the image. So in my view, they don't have an identifiable image.

    Personally, I detest this bizarre placement of photo pages together. I'm sure it makes the books cheaper to produce, but I find it hugely inconvenient. You have to look at the picture first, then use it's label to find the recipe. If you're looking at the recipe, you have to flip through each and every image in the book until you find it, and just hope one is there (the photo pages are not numbered). You see, I work from the recipe, not the pictures... so this is a pain in the neck. Honestly, I think in the 2020s and beyond.. a half page image in or next to the recipe isn't hard. If a picture is worth a thousand words, and you're books all about saving time.... skipping most of the recipe images... is ironic at best... crazy at worst. The problem seems to be across all the "...5 minutes a day" books.

    Overall, the range of recipes and price point make it a compelling choice on its own, regardless of the time-saving focus of the recipes. As the first (and most generalised) book in the "Bread in 5" series, busy hobbyist bread bakers will truly appreciate this book. Although for visual learners... I honestly think there must be more compelling options in the "make bread quickly" category... I just haven't found them... because they all given about a third of the recipes an actual picture.

    Want to see my first attempt at a recipe from this book? Be warned, I went BIG!

    European Peasant Bread - New Artisan Bread in 5 Mins A Day

    Behold, Ham's first attempt at the "European Peasant Bread"

    I have to say how forgiving these recipes really were, and they have to be if you're going to bake bread the way this book intends.

    This was made by skipping the rye flour and simply adding extra freshly ground whole wheat flour. In that regard it's actually a little less rustic than intended, but it tastes good! Even though I made one enormous loaf (38cm long, 26cm wide, and 18cm high... or 15" long, 7" high, and 10.5" wide) instead of the smaller loaves as intended, it proved (literally and figuratively) quite adaptable. I simply lowered the temperature to 220C (about 430F) for an hour to bake the dough all the way through, then baked it for 30 minutes at 240C (465F) to brown, turning it occasionally on the stone for even browning.

    Yeah... now I don't have a bread box big enough... the oven's a good substitute, right?! :~)

    Jeff Hertzberg & Zoë François - Gluten-Free Artisan Bread in 5 Minutes a Day

    Jeff Hertzberg & Zoë François - Gluten-Free Artisan Bread in 5 Minutes a Day

    No prizes for guessing that this is the specifically gluten-free edition of the previous book. Only you might not know just how true, that really is.

    Unfortunately, gluten free breads are generally more challenging than their wheaten counterparts because there's a whole range of flours being used, and each need the right approach to manage in the bread making process.

    You need to ensure that your ingredients are what you need (close enough is not good enough). Also, ensure your temperatures are what they say they are (don't take your oven's word for it), and just know that your odds of success go up when you've read the whole book, not just skipped to the recipe section.

    This book is very good, but time-saving, simplified processes do not necessarily mean easy... and certainly not foolproof.

    That said, you can get some surprising results if you put the work in with this book, and expect a bit of a learning curve along the way.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Make ahead/time saving bread baking, specialising in the gluten-free breads.

    Total page count: 291

    No. of pages before recipes: 63

    Metric/imperial units? Both for quantities, with US volume measurements as a backup. Unfortunately, all temperatures are in Fahrenheit. Ironic for a book aimed at saving time that's sold internationally.

    Number of recipes: 72 total. 10 variations from the master recipe, 26 "peasant loaves", 12 flatbreads/pizzas, & 22 enriched breads/pastries.

    Photos for every recipe? No, 36 colour images (roughly 50% of recipes represented). They've done the exact same thing as the original "The New Artisan Bread in 5 Minutes a Day"... and placed the images in three separate clusters of glossy photo pages at roughly 55%, 66%, and 85% of the way through the book. Again, these pages with the photos are not numbered or part of the page count. So you have to look at the pictures first, use their label to find the recipe... but the reverse is not possible. Please read my slight rant about this layout in the equivalent section of "The New Artisan Bread in 5 Minutes a Day" above.

    Price range (new): $50-$85 (Australian) for the hard cover.

    Price range (used): $35-$100 (Australian) for the hard cover. Please be careful with shipping.. it really adds up here, but if you're in the US/Europe.. then things are much better. Australians are likely best served with buying new, and taking advantage of any sales as they arise.

    Notable Features & FYI: If you've read "The New Artisan Bread in 5 Minutes a Day"... you might be forgiven for thinking you're reading that book.

    In "Gluten-Free Artisan Bread in 5 Minutes a Day" they've obviously culled the "Gluten free" chapter (since every recipe in this book is already gluten free) and basically used exactly the same layout, chapter titles, and even the recipes are named the same. The only distinction is that they're written with instructions and ingredients to make a gluten free alternatives.

    I can see how this might be dangerous if you own both books (as I do) and aren't paying attention. Which I've been known to do... Or if you've jotted the recipes down in your notes in your baking log/journal... and may have omitted the "Gluten Free" bit since the recipes in this book assume that without specifying it.

    At first glance, the 72 recipes (as opposed to the 115 of the original book) might seem quite the drop. I mean it is 38% fewer recipes. However, some recipes just aren't designed for gluten-free breads... so it's quite understandable from this perspective.

    72 recipes is still more than many of the books listed here, and given the extra dietary constraint, Jeff and Zoë have done a commendable job.

    That said, I'd like a 1:1 ratio of photos to recipes, and for the pictures to be placed with the recipe. Again, ditching the pictures that convey so much information in a book aimed at saving time... <cue melodramatic slap to the forehead here>

    So what is "Gluten Free Artisan Bread in 5 Minutes a Day" like to bake with?

    I should start out by saying that gluten-free bread is a very different experience to the gluten-rich bakes seen pretty much everywhere else on this page. If you're coming from an existing glutenous (not gluttonous) baking background, you're definitely going to be tempted to knead your dough. Restrain that urge.... there's no gluten to "beef up" through kneading.

    Like the non-gluten-free version of this book, this gluten-free book has a "master dough" recipe, that you can make quickly then store in the fridge until you're ready to bake. From that dough, many recipes listed in the book can be made (except those in chapter 6). Considering how "key" the master dough really is in this book, I really couldn't "skip it" this time. However, my first attempt did not go to plan.

    From the outset, this was much more like cake batter than an actual dough. The fact that Gluten Free Artisan Bread in 5 Mins a Day say to use a stand mixer paddle instead of the usual dough hook, is quite telling, but the full impact of it's meaning wasn't clear to me until the time it came to "shape" my dough. You see, as soon as I poured the dough from the mixer bowl after a 2 hour rest/proove (where it did rise noticeably)... it literally poured out like the batter that it had been. There was no structure, just a bubbly-unholy-mix between the liquid Plaster of Paris mix, and the sticky somewhat-meringue-like-goop before being whipped to stiff peaks... or even soft peaks for that matter.

    Forget any "shaping" capability, it was literally flowing off my cutting board/baking paper, slowly for sure, but way too fast for actual dough shaping. It was a nightmare to get off the suggested baking paper... I ended up losing about 15-20% of the overall mix because my dough scraper tore up the paper more than merely scraped the fluid dough off.

    Got batter instead of dough? Time to improvise the heck out of the recipe... just to recover something.

    So I tried two things:

    1. Scrape as much into my loaf pans as possible, allowing for some room for the baking rise.
    2. Use the remaining part still in the mixing bowl to make a flat bread.
    Gluten free flatbread and loaves

    Gluten-free "master dough" in two different forms:

    No, it's not an orange and poppy-seed cake. It's a bread loaf and a crude attempt at lebanese bread. Both of which can theoretically be made from the gluten free master dough.. but the dough didn't behave as described in the recipes.

    Firstly, you need to be aware that the dough will not rise anywhere near as much as your favourite gluten-based breads, so expect a denser bread. You can add egg whites for "extra" airiness... but on my first bake, I was freshly out of eggs.

    Secondly, there are many gluten-free flours out there, and for this bake, I've used a cheap Coles-branded "gluten free all-purpose flour" I think this was a mistake. This is basically rice flour, maize/tapioca starches and some thickeners... More expensive brands of gluten free mixes (aimed at bread) have both rice and maize flours, soy proteins, dextrose, salt, dehydrated egg whites (really?), guar gum and some stabilizers.... which probably improves the structure.

    If you want a brown crust, you have to add sugar to the mix for that to happen. Even adding that sugar does not impact taste much. Nonetheless, after slicing the loaves into thin slices for toast, I increased the toaster duration and it didn't brown the crumb at all. Think "Office paper white".... and you'd be right.

    Views on gluten-free breads from a regular bread household.

    Now, I'm glad coeliacs can find an option to eat breads. However, it's not the same as regular bread. Of the breads I've made, I've found that it's difficult to brown, reducing the Maillard reaction. As such, a plain dough will render a loaf with a reduced flavour. You can fix that a bit by adding herbs, seeds, and if you're not lactose intolerant as well, then adding milk/butter will increase the flavour. Otherwise, I'd honestly suggest replacing the sugar component with honey for a little extra flavour.

    Honestly, Ren is not a big fan of gluten free.. and while it doesn't bother me, the basic egg-free version of the master dough shown here is bland. After some thought, I think it's not something I'd make on a regular basis (given our established tolerance for gluten). Gluten free bread is more expensive to make, and it seems to need the better gluten-free ingredients.. or just more of them (if making your own GF bread mixes). However, if you can make it work for your dietary requirements, and flavour preferences then that's great. As always, this is just my first attempt at a recipe shown here, just to see if I ran into any issues.

    I'm honestly unsure if the recipe is amazing.. the instructions are clear and while there's no disjointed quantities, I didn't like the Fahrenheit-only temperature listing.

    I don't want to demonise the book, because using the ingredients that I had on hand may have been the cause of my issues. If your dough drips off a spoon, skip shaping and simply pour the batter from the mixing bowl into a loaf pan prior to proofing/proving it for two hours, and bake it in-situ to see how that goes. I strongly urge you to line your pan with parchment or use a silicone loaf pan because getting it out will become much easier.

    Don't skimp on the ingredients! If you can get a structure from your dough that is plausibly shapable, then you did better than I.

    Gluten free loaf, sliced showing extremely white crumb

    Slicing into the second loaf here... I thought I'd show you the very white crumb I was talking about. It's so white, I am struggling to manage the proper photographic exposure while not blowing out my highlights. Now, white crumbs aren't particularly new, but the weird thing is that toasting it (to normal levels in a toaster, then toasting it in the oven at 180C (about 355F) for an additional 15 minutes... well, the colour looks exactly the same but feels hot. Honestly, the temp (230C/450F) for the better part of an hour was needed just to brown the crust to this degree during the initial bake.

    I suppose this is not that surprising since the loaf is basically a rice bread with added bits. I'd also like to say that there's a rubbery-friction-like experience when cutting through the crust, even with an enormous "cake knife" that normally has little if any issues with wheaten breads.

    Now, I may not have added much flavour to the bread itself, but having gone without breakfast this morning after pulling an all-nighter.... I found that with bacon and egg on it, and some sauce, my flavour issues were solved.

    Wild Sourdough By Hand Book Cover

    Yoke Mardewi Wild Sourdough By Hand

    Sourdough is often perceived as an "advanced" bread type. While it is certainly a longer process, with the additional requirements of raising and keeping a starter culture alive, and aside from certain exceptions, and massively involved recipes, the basic sourdough is not really much more difficult than your average bread.

    This book goes a long way to showing the reader that, even if they're just starting out.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: A "less nerdy" intro into sourdough baking than "The Sourdough Framework" so I think it will appeal to a wider audience. It's an easier read, with lots of pictures, and nearly 10x the recipe count!

    Total page count: 232

    No. of pages before recipes: 76

    Metric/imperial units? Metric only

    Number of recipes: 30 total. 10 basic sourdoughs, 10 wheat-free sourdoughs, 5 savoury sourdoughs, & 5 celebratory sourdoughs.

    Photos for every recipe? Yes! Big honkin' double page spreads.. although there's blocks of text over bits of them sometimes... not over the loaf.

    Price range (new): $30 AUD for the softcover

    Price range (used): none found at the time of writing.

    Notable Features & FYI: Not available on Amazon (Although Yoke's other books can be) so you're best bet is Yoke's direct web site:

    https://wildsourdough.com.au

    Wild Sourdough By Hand - Pros and Cons

    It's written by someone who bakes at home, as part of her daily routine.

    Yoke Mardewi is a sourdough veteran based in Western Australia, and she travels around the country doing sourdough workshops... and obviously writes books too. I've actually had the pleasure of exchanging emails with her about bread making after buying her book direct from her. She was very helpful, and to the point... not surprising, she's a mother!

    What I really like about this book is it teaches you a variety of ways to make great sourdough on a budget.

    You don't need fancy $700+ (Australian, delivered) cast iron "Challenger" loaf pans, or fancy pizza stones (although that's great if you have them) she talks about buying stone tiles to use as baking stones, or simple plate steel from a metalworking supply shop for a baking base. The rest of the gear you can probably buy from a $2 shop.

    2026 Update for Australian bakers: I recently bought two baking steels from Vevor of all places, at $73 Australian dollars each, delivered. A comparable piece of mild steel from a local metal supplier was quoted at $170-$200 each, and you can forget delivery, that plate has to be picked up from the store. So, always do you research before you drop that cash! In that regard, this book is starting to show it's age.

    That said... most of the advice in the book is still relevant, years after publication. It's Yoke's "out of the box" and "beginner friendly" thinking that can save you a lot of money, all while elevating your baking capabilities. If you end up making a mistake, you can clean the cheap gear up, or simply replace it.

    Let's talk about the recipes:

    I really like how the recipes are completely "no nonsense" and this book has one of my highest "first time I've tried this recipe" success rate of any book here. The faster/easier loaves are definitely the more attractive recipes to Ren if she's cooking, but the sweet potato and cheddar sourdough loaf is her "go to" when she's all about the eating but not making... Meanwhile, I still prefer the more savoury, signature "Wild sourdough" and sourdough hot cross buns were pretty good.

    I think the recipe section is quite well arranged. There's some wheat free (but not necessarily gluten free) recipes, but also recipes that incorporate kamut, spelt, wholemeal as well as typical bread flours. Sometimes a hybrid mix of multiple types. This is a big help when it comes to blazing your own trail once you've made these a few times. Just one piece of advice though:

    No matter which recipe you're making, just make absolutely sure that your starter is in the frothy, active state before use. This is critical!

    Don't let the title fool you!

    While this is labelled "Book One - By Hand", it's actually not the first book Yoke has written. Also, despite the "by hand" label, you can absolutely use a stand mixer if you have one. Although, with that said, you don't get a literal "feel" for the dough if you do so. That tactile sense from the dough is sometimes very helpful. If you intend to use a mixer, Yoke's Book "Wild Sourdough for the Thermomix" might also suit. Although that's not the book I'm reviewing here. She also has e-books for those outside of Australia and even a sourdough app, which from what I understand, augments her e-books too.

    From this book, I've gained a lot of meaningful sourdough-related guidance, especially when talking about gluten free variations or ones using unusual flours/seeds as a base. I love classic flour sourdoughs, but mixing it up with spelt, and other ingredients adds a great deal of flexibility.

    The cons:

    This is a simplified book that is not going to give you the "science" or much detail on "why" things work the way they do. Sure you can experiment (and you're encouraged to do so) but you're not going to consciously adapt to changing situations, or fix things when they go awry without a great deal of experience. It's for this reason, I put "The Sourdough Framework" first. Which complements this book beautifully.

    So I shouldn't get this book?

    It's not inferior, at all... it's just "not free", and it's aimed at practical folks who are more likely to simply want a quick introduction to sourdough breads. That's a slightly different audience to "The Sourdough Framework's" tech-heads. Having said that, I think this book would become less useful to intermediate bakers once they've found their way... but still recommend periodically looking at these base recipes and/or ingredients to branch out from.

    Wild Sourdough is not free. (Nor am I implying that it should be). That said, it's still very affordable, and pays itself off by teaching you how to set yourself up without spending much money. If you bought the e-book for $16.90 (Australian) and saved $20 or more from the advice provided... which is easy to do, this book pays you to read it and act upon the information.

    To contrast this with "The Sourdough Framework"... and others.:

    Some of the links for The Bread Code (affiliated with The Sourdough Framework above) are for premium baking tools that are nice, but completely overkill for those starting out (or just doing it casually). Honestly, you just don't need all that to make a great sourdough. Please stick to the basics, and put your money where it's most useful.... buying ingredients so you can gain skills and experience, not gear. Perhaps most importantly, there's a sense of frivolity and family in "Wild Sourdough" instead of "The Sourdough Framework's" more... technical/historical delivery of the material. If you're looking for a wider range of recipes in a book, then this crushes Framework.

    Form vs Function...

    I don't want to devalue the contents of this book. It's a great book from a content point of view. The presentation is certainly not going to be for everyone's taste if you're looking for a gorgeous coffee table book with pretty rustic kitchen scenes or cloth-covered fine-dining aesthetics. (Which almost every modern cook book does to some degree, have you noticed that?)

    If you're looking for the pretty modern bread books. I feel "Wild Sourdough" isn't ideal. Honestly, it's closer to a colour coded school textbook from the 90s, with pages from each chapter given tones of bright greens, oranges, pinks, and deeper purple, and if they didn't have a double page spread image for each recipe, I'd have described it as "cluttered" or "unnecessarily busy". (That's just my view point.. your tastes will almost certainly vary from my own). None of this rustic/down-to-Earth bread making theme is matched by the overall layout of the book itself. So if you're looking for "classy cookbook gifts", I'd lean more to "Homemade Sourdough" (below), "Tartine" (below that), or a more generalised book with that specific "Food fashion" look.

    That said...

    For the scruffy sourdough battler's out there... this book is worth reading, and you'll absolutely make a fine sourdough from this book, that anyone would be privileged to eat. :-)

    Let's see how I go with a couple of first-attempt recipes, shall we?

    Pain De Mie Sourdough Milk Bread Boule

    Ham's first attempt at "Pain De Mie Sourdough" (Photo by Ren)

    Well you'll see that I've done Pain De Mie in a couple of other bakes, but this one is the sourdough variant. This was an unusually stiff dough for a pure sourdough milk bread. However, that stiffness also required an entire day (at colder Canberra kitchen temperatures) to do the first proof and get that 50% bigger dough I needed.

    That said, this dough was an absolute delight to shape, and proof some more, and I think the image shows that I was feeling confident enough to go a little fancier on the final dough slashing front.

    Now, given the very long proofing time and the slightly neglected sourdough starter.... this was definitely one of the most tangy sourdoughs I've made on this list, and despite the crumb being a little less soft than the other Pain De Mie bread(s) on this page, the crust was crisp, and crunchy and while it wasn't as snappy as baguette, it was on the way to that goal.

    Sourdough express whilte sandwich loaf

    Ham's First "Sourdough Express" - White Sandwich Loaves

    Ok, so these are the two loaves I made. This recipe was quite small, so I doubled it, and even then, the amount of dough wasn't huge. This is where I think Wild Sourdough encourages a regular baking of 1 loaf at a time to "get you into the habit and hone your skills". This is in stark contrast to the huge amounts suggested in the recipes of "The Taste of Bread" (reviewed below) where they're getting you used to baking commercial quantities of bread. Obviously, most books fall somewhere in the middle.... at least in terms of recipe yields. If nothing else, this teaches you to adapt your recipes to the quantities you need... or bake numerous batches from one ball of dough.

    I made only a handful of minor tweaks to the official recipe. The final proof was extended by a couple of extra hours to allow the starter microbes to double the volume as indicated. I added poppy seeds and incoporated them into the dough, I topped the loaves with sesame seeds, and I shortened the bake by about 4 minutes because I felt it was "browned enough".

    Technically, I went darker than the photo in the book suggested because I prefer that darker crust flavour, but I wasn't sure how much further I could push this recipe. So here we are.

    As a true sourdough, this had a bit more tang than many of the milder sourdoughs shown on this page. If Ren doesn't like it, she'll just add more honey on her morning toast. :-)

    Homemade Sourdough by Jane Mason et al

    Jane Mason, Ed Wood, et al -
    Homemade Sourdough

    Another book that specialises in sourdough breads. This one is aimed at being beginner friendly, but offers a different viewpoint to Yoke Mardewi's "Wild Sourdough by Hand" in a couple of important ways.

    Where Yoke was all about using whatever is cheap to get you set up, this one is definitely more "main stream" with the usual recommendations for bannetons, baking stones (and metal baking sheets if you'd prefer a cheaper option). It's not as gung-ho on the premium items like "The Sourdough Framework" is.

    I honestly like this book, but when it comes to non-flat bread, it seems that it just doesn't love me back. Nothing is wrong with the recipes per se, the bread is always tasty, but despite my sincerest efforts, weird events occur in my life whenever I bake raised bread from this book. Even when events settle down, and things proceed as planned, I keep getting weird, inconsistent results, even when several loaves are made with the exact same dough, baked all at once in the same oven, even on the same darn shelf. I've even independently verified temperatures, used proofers, even Ren's offered a second pair of eyes.

    There's something about this book that is trying to break my brain.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: General sourdough baking, mostly bread but with a few sweet breads up the back. Incidentally, it seems also focused on general psychological warfare with this particular wayward Ham.

    Total page count: 160

    No. of pages before recipes: 24

    Metric/imperial units? Metric (with volume measurements as backup)

    Number of recipes: 42 Total. 5 batter breads, 9 rye sourdoughs, 14 plain wheat sourdough, 8 flavoured sourdoughs, and 6 sweet breads.

    Photos for every recipe? Almost, but there are few doubled-up recipes without their opposite page photos.

    Price range (new): $23-$55 (AUD) for a hardcover.

    Price range (used): None found that weren't more expensive.

    Notable Features & FYI: This is a clean, very pretty bread book aimed at beginners. The sourdough theory section is basic but should absolutely work. Although in colder climates, it may take a bit longer than indicated to get a sourdough starter going from scratch. If you live in the tropics... that might be different too. :-)

    "Homemade Sourdough" certainly has a wider range of bread recipes than "The Sourdough Framework" or "Bread Science", so there's a much greater diversity to learn from this book as is. There's Shaobing (also known as "Beijing Sesame Buns"), Bagels, English Muffins, Kamut, Raisin Rye, as well as the sourdough varieties of the usual suspects like French Baguettes, Ciabatta, Pumpernickel, & "Everyday loaf".

    I particularly like the batter breads which are about as easy and forgiving as you can get, and vary in finished products from "flapjacks" to "fruit bread". That's pretty diverse!

    I'm not the biggest sweet tooth in the household (but let's be honest and say the cinnamon rolls are amazing, by the way... and work just as well with home made jam or any sweet pie filling you care to name..... if it's made with fresh cherry pie filling, made from freshly picked, luscious, almost-black home grown cherries... you're in for a real treat!) That said, Ren is a huge fan of the waffles... and it doesn't seem to matter which recipe she used. :-)

    Homemade Sourdough - Pros & Cons:

    Pros:

    I really like the layout of the book, it's clean, modern and laden with photographs right where you need them. No flipping through pages to find what the finished bread should look like, and I really appreciate that. The hard cover sits open without closing on me, which is also very handy when hands are covered in flour/dough.

    The troubleshooting section has actual photos of each example, so you know which problem you're facing. Not all books do that!

    If you're a Rye fan, then this is an excellent book for that. However it also includes the usual wheat breads, and the occasional hybrid mixture as well.

    I think the price-recipe value is there, and while it's definitely aimed at beginners, I like the extra details of creating a rye starter as well as the usual wheat version. That's not covered in many other books.

    Cons:

    Sometimes, the photos of the bread are so coated in flour that you can't really see the bread, that makes the photos somewhat less useful. Also, no cut slices! So it's hard to see what the crumb should look like. That said, most other books fail on this point too.

    This is not an advanced book by any means. It'll give you some recipes to try rye bread baking, which needs to be made differently from wheat breads, but beyond any troubleshooting suggestions, it's not going to help you to adapt to every situation. Think of this as more a "recipe book" than "bread science" lesson.

    That said, "Homemade Sourdough" dabbles in the gluten-free and heirloom "cousins" of wheat grains like Emmer and Kamut, and how Rye doesn't normally need as much kneading. However, this book does not go into much detail on those topics. So it alludes to some more advanced topics, but doesn't do it in any significant degree of depth.

    That's ok, it's aimed at beginners!

    Honestly, this has been the "playful problem child" book of this list.

    Flatbreads? No problem. Waffles? No issues. Risen breads.... Well, I like to phrase it as "a learning experience"...

    All the breads are tasty... but weird stuff happens whenever I try a new recipe from this book, and in the rare event I'm not otherwise disturbed by family drama, crazed neighbours, unexpected heat waves/cold snaps, last minute emergency work calls, and cats knocking my bannetons on the floor.. The finished loaves just seem to fight me on the consistency front.

    I'm taking some of the responsibility here...

    Now, in some ways, my frustrations are circumstances that occurred during my bakes, in unstable conditions. Sourdough simply takes longer time to get from start to finish. Yes, there's plenty of times that I'm not expected to do anything... but if unexpected situations happen on day three of a multi-day process... (heat wave, cold snap, weird spontaneous work trips to fix a hacked data centre). Every time I bake raised breads with previously-untried recipes from this bread book for this review page... something happens.

    Usually, when things don't turn out as planned, I've got a pretty good idea where I went wrong (and adapt the procedure for next time). However, there are other times that I just don't know why or how things have changed enough to cause significant differences in result. Same times, temperatures, batches of dough, baked at the same time in the same oven even on the same shelf! Yet different results!

    It's sad, because I do keep getting somewhat different results, even when I nail a lot of the variables down. No recipes from the other books seem to trouble me so. Even when everything is double, and even quadruple-checked by two people armed with scales, thermometers, proofers, etc.

    It's maddening, but the bread is always tasty! Sometimes in different ways too!

    So if you like an always-tasty adventure, surprise results, and perhaps tempting your baking fates, then this is the book for you! If you want precision, and you get it from this book, you're doing better than I am. I believe it's possible, I just haven't experienced it yet.

    I'm sorry Jane/Ed et al... if you're reading this, my copy has some mild PTSD attached, but also offers some of the tastiest bread to make up for it. I think other bakers will take this challenge on.

    Want to see how I went with an actual bake? (or three)

    San Francisco Sourdough - Three loaves from one recipe

    Three different 1Kg (2.2lb) loaves of "San Francisco Sourdough"... (Shot by Ren)

    It's just a shame that they were supposed to be identical. Honestly folks, this really baffled me. There is a sub-three-minute difference in bake time between the whitest loaf and the the darkest. Some dough slacked off when mixed, while the dough that ultimately made other loaves firmed up to near newly unwrapped pottery clay consistency before the bake, using exactly the same amount of time, the same ingredients, the same mixer settings and duration. Two of the loaves (and they're not the two you think) were in the same mixer batch. If I had three different sourdough starters, I would have believed this result, but again, same jar, same mix, same levels of activity.

    The "sourdough tanginess" varied a little bit, one loaf crust was crunchy and crisp, while others were slightly softer. I personally felt that the rise wasn't where I hoped it to be, but when your dough turns into clay, that's not terribly surprising. That said, it rose more than I expected for such a stiff dough.

    Ren found the crust quite hard to chew on our first loaf, I was less troubled by it... but I eat more thicker crust/boiled dough breads than she does. That said, it was quite difficult to slice up by hand. The softer loaves were more manageable.

    Slicing the San Francisco Loaves...

    San Francisco Sourdough - sliced bread.

    It's seriously tasty... just variable! (Photographed by Ham)

    Now I don't want to demonise this book, it's got great information, it's well presented, it goes into more detail re: exotic loaf shaping options than many books with twice it's page count, but I just like the humble boule.

    From a "crumb structure" perspective, the loaf was ok, but one of the others had enormous holes that made it look more like lace or a doilie. That's ok, because when you put cultured butter on a sourdough, then slap a salmon paté on top.. all those holes left enough tantalising food stuffs on the plate to whip our cats into a "feed me!" fervour. This one, lacking the holes and thus, tasty residue, was quite the disappointment for them. More for me though! :-)

    Sourdough Ciabatta, Ham's first attempt from Homemade Sourdough recipe

    Ham's first attempt at "Sourdough Ciabatta! (Photographed by Ren)

    This two day make involves feeding the already active sourdough starter with some of the main water+flour ingredients of the recipe. I then resorted to mixing the quite-dry mix literally by hand (a dough whisk isn't going to work with this sort of extremely stiff paste masquerading as a preferment.... Honestly at that stage, this is close to a pâte fermentée in hydration). A humble 8 hours later, adding the rest of the ingredients and mixing as the recipe suggests, then leaving it another 4 hours, throw in some shaping and yet another 1.5-2 hour proof (but it was closer to 4 for me)... then we're off to the oven.

    I fed my starter at 10am on the first day, made the preferment at 10pm that night, mixed the rest of the ingredients at 8am, shaped at 12pm, and baked 4pm (the last rise was a little slow) and I had baked goodness by 5pm. Cool down was done by 6:45pm... and then we had to make dinner. The kitchen was a mess.

    Honestly, the instructions were clear, although good luck finding picture 4 in the "how to"... I think only specific steps had images. However, there were no issues with the instructions, no disjointed amounts, everything lined up and worked surprisingly well.

    This time, I baked the ciabatta into full sized boules, (like the "poolish ciabatta" shown in the Crust review below, but quite unlike the flatter ciabatta baked in the "Bread Bible" review above). Making it a full height boule extended the bake time, but I think it came out very well, with a clear "ear" forming where the top was slashed. You can smell the sourdough tang of this bread from across the room, but it's mostly smell. I think it tastes good, looks good, and while it was involved, it is far from the longest and/or most difficult to make. In terms of sourdough effort to reward, I'd give it a solid 80-85% sure, it's not the best sourdough, but it's up there, and considerably easier to make than the ones that I'd give 90%+ for.

    Nice work, Jane, Ed, et al!

    Anyone care for a giant cookie?

    Ham's first attempt at a sourdough "Ploughman's Loaf"

    This is an interesting recipe! (Extremely tasty). Get a sourdough starter, feed it, give it 8 hours (I think I needed 2), then add stout beer, another feeding of flour, add coarsely chopped apples, chutney, and nuts. (Although I skipped the nuts because we ran out).

    Ok, so this recipe has a second single huge proofing time that was described as "between 2-4 hours after final dough mixing". Yeah... I think I needed 30mins to an hour. Maybe.

    Why?!

    I was caught out by a heatwave, which meant my well-fed 8 hour starter that was already, particularly active, over-proofed in a fraction of the time. So I was left with a dough closer to pancake batter with apple chunks in consistency.

    No matter how much I folded/kneaded, it just refused to firm up. I think too much gluten had been eaten at this point. Consequently, I should have poured this into a loaf pan, instead of using a stone as indicated. It basically became a really big, pizza-sized sourdough cookie that rose maybe 5cm/2" high while baking.

    I don't think the recipe is wrong... but it needs to be monitored more closely than I did. Still very tasty though. It works particularly well when buttered with cinnamon sugar (for the full sourdough applie pie experience) or for a more savoury option, it works well with a light cream cheese with some berries. I don't have any berries in this shot... I was hungry and the toaster took too long. :~)

    You can see the apple chunks, which the cream cheese has been strategically spread around. Yet it's very filling, even without the nuts.

    Honestly, I think this particular bake could have been done at a lower temp for longer, and that would have helped a bit to make it a bit more airy and consistently baked throughout the crumb without burning the crust.

    Tartine Bread by Chad Robertson et al

    Chad Robertson, Elisabeth Prueitt - Tartine Bread

    No bread review list would be complete without mentioning one of the most famous leavened (lighter/younger sourdough) bread books of them all. So here it is.

    Chad runs one of the most famous bakeries in San Francisco. Notably called "Tartine". He is renowned for his semi-sourdough breads, and now you can make a version of it it at home.

    This book does things a bit differently to the others. Specifically by dedicating 45 pages to the first "Country Bread" recipe. Don't panic! (roughly 19 pages of which is diagrams).

    Please note: I only counted the pages from the start of the chapter up to the "variations of the recipe". This includes the recipe preamble, the recipe itself, "The recipe in depth" section, and even the "test baker" section. Variations aren't key to the first version, so I've excluded them from my picture count for simplicity.

    The first recipe goes through the steps in exacting (or perhaps hand-holding) detail. Then you can go forth and do the other recipes (which are notably shorter in page count) using the experience and practices you got from the first recipe, using it as a reference.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Sourdough/Levain breads, and pastries taught by one of the most famous sourdough professionals in the world, but the recipes are designed with the home baker in mind.

    Total page count: 304

    No. of pages before recipes: 41.. although the first recipe has a ton of extra information, as it's the basis for many recipes in the book.

    Metric/imperial units? Metric only in the ingredients section...(surprising for a baker in San Francisco)... but Fahrenheit is used exclusively in the method/procedure section. That, I found quite frustrating.

    Number of recipes: 58 total. However, there are variations and semi-separated recipes for component foodstuffs (meat patties for hamburgers for example) so that number is on the conservative side. In the main chapters, there's 1 country bread dough (although there are 6 variations), 4 semolina/whole wheat breads, 9 baguettes/enriched breads, 42 recipes to use "days old breads"

    Photos for every recipe? All the ones that matter.

    Price range (new): ebook (kindle) $32 Australian. Hardcover $45-$65

    Price range (used): Few genuinely worth considering, as they're often more expensive.

    Notable Features & FYI: Tartine is actually the original book in the "Tartine Series". The other two books are: "Tartine: A Revised Edition, A Classic Revisited: 68 All New Recipes and 55 Updated Favourites", and finally, "Tartine No. 3: Modern, Ancient, Classic, Whole".

    Far be it from me to complain about long-winded and/or vague passages, but the titles are a mouthful. From here out, I'm calling them book 2 and 3 respectively.

    Honestly, I think I like the much shorter titles like "Tartine Bread" more. However, book 2 probably offers a better value, given that it has more recipes, and revised favourites. That said, I just had to include this book in the list.

    "Tartine Bread" is an amazing book, it's full of beautiful (albeit matte finished) photographs, and my hard cover is padded which feels odd in my hands. The only other book in my library that feels so upholstered is my "Temples of Barbecue"...(maybe it's an american foodie thing?) but I digress.

    The layout of "Tartine Bread" is reminiscent of Ken Forkish's "Flour Water Salt Yeast", with the back story/introduction called "Bread in Time", and then moves into the various chapters that each have different recipes. Honestly, this is like many of the less textbook/technical books.

    The overall book layout:

    Chapter 1 has the core recipe "the country bread dough" which is the keystone recipe which the book centres itself around. Chapter 2 covers the recipes for "Semolina and Whole-Wheat Breads". Chapter 3 focuses on "Baguettes and Enriched Breads", then the fourth and final chapter "Days-old bread" is what you can do with bread (new or old). It's more recipes that use bread up, than specifically make it, but there are a few more bread recipes in there as part of more complex concoctions.

    The recipe selection:

    Honestly, from a "purely bread" perspective, this is a very mainstream Western European bread book. Once you get past the core recipe. The most exotic bread recipe is Kugelhopf (a German brioche).. but you're not going to find much in the way of flatbreads outside of pizza, nothing of the nordic breads, and the Middle East/Africa/Central or South America... forget it. This book is about what Tartine makes and serves, so you have to keep that in mind.

    That said, once you leave the bread section and read the "Days old bread" chapter, things do get more interesting. There's a recipe for Banh Mi (although the bread recipe isn't explicitly outlined.. I'd just choose a baguette recipe from earlier in the book) and surprisingly, there's no paté in their Banh Mi recipe. Sacrilege! Although the "Baker's Foie" toward the end of the book in the condiment section would fix that.

    Side note: The "green aioli" found in the banh mi recipe goes exceptionally well on steak sandwiches/steak burgers, even roast chicken/potatoes... if you're feeling a little decadent and are in the mood for an Asian twist.

    To sum up...

    I think Tartine has a lot to offer for beginner bread makers, sourdough enthusiasts, and bread bakers who don't know what to do with any leftover breads. In this regard, it's fantastic. For those discovering general cookery, Tartine also makes a compelling addition to anyone's food library. If you're looking for exotic bread types outside what Tartine sells, then it probably best to find a more suitable book.

    Aside from the bread recipes, there's a wide range of general meal ideas that augment the breads well or offer entertaining variety to use them up. Recipes range from leavened waffles, meatball sandwiches and burgers, to porchetta, "bread salads", sauces and jams, and of course, puddings/desserts as well.

    My first attempt at Tartine's

    Ham's first attempt at Tartine's "Basic country bread"....

    I'm not going to lie, this sourdough recipe is quite involved because folding every 30 minutes for four hours, after making and maintaining starter, then several bulk fermentation and final proofing, even retarded/slow rise option to boot for maximum sourness...

    Since Ren greatly prefers her doughs to be flavourful more than sour, I aimed more for a "light" sourdough or merely "levained bread". It works well, but there's a few methodology steps that I'll frankly avoid in future and do things my way. I'm not normally much of "cover your doughs with a clean tea towel" (as instructed in this book) kind of guy.. I prefer to leave my dough in the mixing bowl and cover it with a flat plastic chopping boards. Less wrinkles, less potential for sticking, and far less loose flour to brush off the loaves.

    I actually made three loaves, two sized as specified in the recipe (shown whole) and one "big one". However, I had some trouble with the big dough's reluctance to let go of the proofing basket and it deflated considerably as I put it into my loaf pan. So the slice shows the width of the loaf before my troubles began, but the relatively deflated height is also shown, relative to the half-sized loaf. In any case, it tasted good though! It smells more sour than it tastes, but there's a complexity of flavours that means the buttered bread stands on it's own (good for soups), but also isn't so bland that it's merely a transport for the fillings on more flavour-packed sandwiches. I can taste the bread with some stronger flavours, but it still doesn't interfere with smoked salmon or milder cheese sandwiches either.

    Flour Lab by Adam Leonti & Katie Parla - book cover

    Adam Leonti & Katie Parla's Flour Lab

    If you're ready to grab the bread baking world by it's Mock Mill attachment, and grind your own flours for the ultimate in freshness, this book will definitely improve your bread game. If you like that idea, and want to learn more from a surprisingly pretty and non-technical/surprisingly enjoyable read then you've come to the right place. ;~)

    This book delves head-long into flour. An overview of wheat types (and other grains), the milling process, the equipment used to do that (including those available to the home baker), and of course, some recipes to integrate freshly milled flour into your bread making.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Incorporating freshly milled flours into home made bread/pastry cooking.... Generally using your own grain mill or milling attachment for a stand mixer.

    Total page count: 255

    No. of pages before recipes: 76

    Metric/imperial units? Metric only, no volume measurements at all.

    Number of recipes: 36 main recipes total, but including the "add ons" 63. The break down is:

    8 in "Making Bread" (add 1 for honey butter), 7 in "Making Pasta" (and 10 pasta fillings/sauces, and meal recipes), 9 in "Making Pizza" (add 16 topping recipes), 12 in "Pastry, Cookies & Cakes"

    Photos for every recipe? Yes for the main recipes, no for the add ons. Glossy, often full-page photos and lots dotted throughout the book to shop key steps.

    Price range (new): $20-$140 (Australian) for the hard cover. I don't recommend Amazon's $140 when Book Grocer in Australia sells it for just $20. Which is exactly the same price as the e-book.

    Price range (used): N/A (none found)

    Notable Features & FYI: This book is full of useful information in a practical, no nonsense guide. It's we'll illustrated, and the recipes easy to understand. That said, it's not without some issues.

    Flour Lab - Pros and Cons:

    Let's start with the white elephant-shaped con in the room.

    Warning: This is a "gateway" guide. Most people looking into buying this particular book will want several new things to equip them for the fresh flour mission, most notably:

    • A source of freshly milled flour at an absolute minimum... Or if milling flour at home...
    • Probably need some wheat berries (and/or other grains) to grind up. That needs contacts (at least here in Australia) and/or a willingness to pay a premium for exotic/heirloom varieties.
    • Naturally, a mill or milling attachment for a stand mixer to make this all happen.
    • A cool, dry place for storage. Failing that, more space in the freezer to store the fresh flour, even some unmilled grains, and enough air-tight containers to handle that.

    I'm not saying it can't be done affordably, but you need to go into this with open eyes. My mill attachment was bought on sale for $149 Australian (delivered) but the wheat berries added another $110 (for 20Kg or about 44lb). To order less berries would have tripled my shipping rate per kilo, making the transport fees over 80% of the price... so I didn't have much choice.

    Back to the book!

    I'm so glad the first recipe in the book starts with 1Kg of flour (that's a big loaf, even by my standard recipe which only needed 400g)... otherwise my 20Kg purchase might have been a "bit much".

    Let's talk pros:

    Now Flour Lab isn't unique in the grains-to-flour thing. However, while it's U.S. centred, and you can definitely look up their grain and flour references and use what you have. It's not trying to emulate other countries in either wheat varieties or milling techniques. It's letting regional recipes be true to the region they come from and maximising the results.

    Other books on the subject (Most notably The Taste of Bread by Raymond Calvel et al, also reviewed here) is perhaps a little more French-bread centric, and discusses that through a "this is how we do it in our country" perspective. It's also far less pretty as a book, it's a harder read, and covers more technical baking knowledge than Flour Labs. Both are aimed at extracting the best results from the ingredients, but the presentation, and let's face it, price puts Flour Lab as a more modern, more affordable, and easier-to-understand bread baking book.

    Conversely, comparing Flour Lab to The Miller's Daughter (review below) is a bit problematic because The Miller's Daughter is more about using unusual or heritage grains/grits/pulses and beyond in general cookery rather than specialising in bread itself. So while there's some overlap, the books serve two very different objectives. Both books can help you to improve your bread game though. So please keep that in mind.

    Flour Lab is very handy if you're interested in figuring out how different species of wheat and other grains impact the bake itself, or how the coarseness of your flour impacts hydration levels. This will help you to use fresh flours much more confidently. In this regard, it links to similar topics covered in the slightly more technical, Sourdough Framework discussed above.

    Of course, Flour Lab discusses how fresh flour enhances the flavour of the bread and the outlines the health benefits. For me this led to a variety of questions about:

    "Where do I get these precious wheat berries?"

    "Why is good wheat so expensive and hard to find?"

    Personally, what makes the book an interesting read for me, isn't just the recipes and tips, it is the "broader perspective".

    Flour Lab discusses the state of the flour industry as a whole (I like the one-word summation, "broken"... although I do feel that's a little unfair given how reductive one word is, despite the obvious problems with the industry). Yet Flour Lab does helpfully provide context including a slight jaunt into the rich history of wheat and other grains, their various impacts on societies across the globe.. and potential directions current wheat/agricultural/food science research is heading. Perhaps most intriguing is how farmers are responding and collaborating with artisanal bakers across the globe to address numerous industry and societal issues.

    That's all great.. but how does that help everyday home bread bakers?

    For me, it helped by providing ways to avoid problems I would definitely have had if I was "winging it", and helped me to tweak my online searches while looking for grains to mill. Ultimately, I was led to farmers who've partnered with bakers in Victoria.. not exactly local to me, but I'll take it. Australia, for it's many strengths, has a small population, and consequently, smaller conclaves of fresh flour communities. They exist, but if you live in a country like Australia, expect to reach out further than others in more populated countries.

    The other huge pro of this book is the full colour, glossy step-by-step photos on key steps. For anyone who has battled various hand-drawn images, and the fuzzy black and white photos of yore... rejoice! You're no longer trying to decypher (or "decipher" if you're a millenial/American) a doctor's chicken-scratches that could be interpretive dance manoeuvres, or squinting at some detail that may (or may not) be there in the image. Fold it like this, let the dough tell you when it doesn't want to stretch any more, and then shape it like that. Easy peasy!

    You can apply this information just as well to any recipe in all the other books or online videos too!

    The everyday cons (not the white elephant):

    Let's talk about ingredients for a moment...

    Many "Flour Lab" recipes assume you can find the appropriate grains to make your own exotic flours using U.S. varieties as suggested examples. ("Kansas Turkey" or "Blue Beard" are a couple of instances). Other ingredients such as potatoes (for potato gnocci) often suggest U.S. varieties too, like "Idaho" and "Yukon Gold", and while they may be readily available in the U.S., this certainly is not the case here in Australia and other countries. Honestly, if you're in doubt, skip the supermarket for a week and ask your fruit and veggie shop friends for their advice for local equivalents. While you're there, ask what the equivalents might be in different seasons, so you're ready "year round".

    I'm rustic, not pompous/Bourgeoisie!

    If you ask yourself, "What on Earth is Muscovado Sugar and why is it special?!"

    If your pantry is a little basic, you probably have white sugar, maybe a brown for porridge, and a castor sugar for cakes. If that describes your pantry, never fear, you're not alone!

    Unfortunately, in "Flour Lab", there's a lot of unusual ingredients, like "Muscovado sugar" which is just a deep brown sugar with a slightly stronger molasses-ish? flavour.... and you can totally use that, or plain sugar with a couple of teaspoons of molasses, or skip the molasses all together and use brown sugar.. or whatever sugar you have. Muscovado sugar is now widely available in Australian supermarkets,(that wasn't the case 20 years ago) but it is a little pricier. Use whatever you have.

    Back to the wheat....

    Just know that most of these wheat varieties are often described below the name with some phrase like:

    "a hard winter wheat", or a "durum", or a "spelt".... etc. Just get whatever you can in your area that meets the broader description. It does not have to be the precise species they list, ok?

    Now that I've tried some of the recipes, is milling your own flour worth it?

    It's difficult to describe what the first and simplest recipe does, let alone the more complex ones. But here goes....

    Think of a good bread flavour (no, not your commercial white bread in a plastic bag... a proper artisan loaf, fresh from the bakery)... then amplify the smell, the taste, and consequently, the overall flavour. You can smell the difference before you even start baking the dough. During baking freshly milled doughs lends a "baked bread aroma" that is even stronger than home-made breads with commercial flours. Later, when eating it.. the flavour is significantly more pronouced.... so bread becomes more than a mere transport for spreads and toppings, it has a flavour that makes you far more aware of it's presence.

    Now, for those with families (and particularly, children of all ages... some of you will know what I'm talking about) will find that there are plenty of people who will find it disconcerting that bread can have such a flavour, while others will be absolutely delighted. Die-hard white bread fans probably won't like such breads overnight. If that's the case, starting with 5% freshly milled flour to a 95% commercial flour mix, and ramping it up slowly in successive batches to a 20:80% or even 30:70% (fresh milled : commercial respectively) mix will help family members to adjust.

    However, for all those people paying $7-20 for bread loaves at the fancy bakeries.... particularly the ryes, the rustics, the grainy and/or sourdough breads will adore fresh milled flour breads. Doing it yourself will save you an absolute fortune..... If you do it regularly. Given the start-up costs, if you're a "I bake once in a blue moon" kind of person, just stick to commercial flours, and buy just enough to accomplish the bake, that way you're forced to use the freshest flour available to you.

    In conclusion:

    A useful, attractive, to-the-point, easy-to-understand hardcover book that not only made home milling seem more approachable, but immediately made a notable improvement to my bread knowledge and skills one I implemented the recipes. All this for just $20 Australian... it's totally worth it for bread mavens out there. I don't think it's ideal for beginners because it needs equipment that most would not have. However, once you're established in the hobby, and looking to get healthier or just want to make better bread in general, it's hard to criticise anything about the book itself.

    Two dough-covered thumbs up! :~)

    First freshly ground flour and loaf

    Ham's first freshly ground flour & resulting loaf

    If a picture's worth a thousand words, here's four in a comic-strip styled tale. This is the loaf that results from the first recipe of "Flour Lab". Honestly, I think I can tweak it a bit, but for a first try, I'm very happy. I shared this with you to say "hey this is how my first go went, because doing something that I've practiced hundreds of times before is not indicative of what a book might give you as a beginner.

    This loaf is 14cm (almost 6") high, about 30cm (1 foot) long, and about 25cm (10") wide. I wish I could share with you the smell and the taste... it's amazing. This loaf isn't just enhanced by the fresher ingredients, but by the particularly slow fermentation process. It was "slow rising" in the fridge for days before baking, (a relatively new technique for me). Slow rises need cooler temperatures, so that needed a complete rearrangement of our fridge if you're using 7 Qt (8L) Kitchen Aid stand mixer bowls. If your fridge is packed... you might want to think about a different container, a shorter rise.. or repurposing a drinks fridge for a few days. :~)

    Super Sourdough by James Morton

    Super Sourdough by James Morton

    James is a Scottish "enthusiastic bread-baking amateur that ended up on TV" and has written multiple books on bread making and other fermented food stuffs... amongst other things like being a medical doctor and trying his hand at professional beer brewing. The book reminisces on how he was originally inspired by Richard Bertinet's books (of "Dough", "Crumb" and "Crust" fame, reviewed above), and through part time bakery-ish jobs as he studied medicine.

    I think this is a very good book but I actually disagree with some of what James has said. From almost the very first page, James wrote (and I'm paraphrasing here) that he thinks that many sourdough books are technical in a way that discourages the masses from trying. Ok, sure, some are! However, there are many books on this list (and beyond), that aren't written by tech heads and are quite approachable. I don't think it's always "technicality" that makes a book hard to use, it might list ingredients that might not be locally available, it might not word things the way you might have otherwise understood. Readers differ in learning just as authors differ in their understanding/communication.

    I think James is absolutely correct in his approach. He's stating that he's just sharing the techniques that work for him and he's not implying that his way guarantees success in every situation, or that it will necessarily work for everyone. Similarly, he's refined, and even openly contradicted some of the statements of his previous books, as more information became available. I respect that level of honesty. However, I believe he has done everything he can to render an approachable book, one where his professional medical opinion on the health issues relating to bread, sourdough, intolerances, and the often over-hyped and poorly tested "allergy" assessment procedure... Well let's just say his views hold real weight and value to many bakers.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: This is a "How to make sourdough at home" book, but it isn't just bread that it makes with that dough. To compare it with other books...

    "Super Sourdough" isn't quite as technical as "The Sourdough Framework", or structured like a course like "Sourdough School". It's more in-depth than "Wild Sourdough" but isn't (in my experience) as... willfull/challenging as "Homemade Sourdough".

    Total page count: 256

    No. of pages before recipes: 113

    Metric/imperial units? Metric only (grams) or whole unit ingredient counts (such as "two eggs at room temperature"). The temperatures are in both Fahrenheit and Celsius.

    Number of recipes: Total 42, with a breakdown of:

    5 "Relaxed doughs", 6 "white breads for sharing", 6 "little breads", 7 "darker breads", 7 "bitty breads", 6 "enriched breads", 5 "leftover starter recipes"

    Photos for every recipe? No. A couple of shots show an incomplete (unbaked) product, but I'd say at least 38 of 42 do have photos of the finished product.

    Price range (new): $33-$54 (Australian) for the hardcover, $22 for a Kindle edition. No soft cover found.

    Price range (used): $27-$39 (AUD) for the hardcover. (most found on eBay)

    Notable Features & FYI: Honestly, I think James brings a detailed, but still readable approach to sourdough, as well as a far more... pragmatic and practical take on the usual medical questions that surround bread. 

    Super Sourdough: Pros and Cons


    The Pros:

    I like that he correctly states that there are numerous issues with identifying what any health issue that bread may (or may not) cause. I particularly like how he acknowledges that while there are numerous scientific studies on both sides of the "is bread healthy?" debate. Most of those studies are often flawed, aimed at processes for industrial bread production (which home bakers certainly aren't using), and even if the studies are done well (which most aren't) new studies can disprove their findings... at least partially, or even entirely.

    So he suggests something shockingly simple. If you're worried about something, get professional medical advice, and they'll come up with a bunch of strategies to eliminate one possible cause after another strategically. Do not trust the "allergy tests", often done by a teenager in a health food shop... the tests have numerous false positives, and don't actually tell you how to deal with the issue, even if it's correctly used. It may shock you that a few simple tests may find a completely different cause, and only occasionally require a temporary reduction in certain foods, rather than complete elimination. A temporary reduction is far less of a real hassle for you, and your loved ones around you. So why sacrifice something you mightn't have to?

    There's also an excellent section on common bread problems, including issues with starter, and various tips/remedies to try. As well as a lot of "good food science" without it becoming excessively technical.


    The Cons:

    Now, like I said, there are some things I actually disagree with. Firstly, James (out of self-confessed laziness) states that he keeps one starter, and if he needs to switch between a rye starter or wheat starter, he feeds the new grain type to the mix for a few days and "transitions" from one to another. You can of course, do that, but it's like suddenly swapping out the grasses of the Serengeti, to the grasses of the U.S. "prairies" and expecting the entire ecosystem to keep up, then switch back whenever the mood strikes you. Sure, there's herbivores in both places, but major changes are always a source of stress and less-than-stellar performance. I'd prefer to break a bit off my wheat starter and feed it rye in a separate jar for a few days before baking (at ambient) and use it up than mess with my primary starter and have to spend days transitioning back and forth.

    Secondly, James suggests that he can just cut a loaf on the cutting board, then sit it, cut crumb face down on the board in open air and it's fine for days.... Ok, that's sort of true... for him!

    Yes, sourdough lasts longer than other breads, but if you're a "once-a-week" baker, there's real benefit in keeping the bread in a not-quite airtight bread box (I use my dutch oven, slow cooker, or even my oven when it's not in use. The lack of convection over the bread keeps the bread fresher for longer. Also, I would not recommend James' open-air strategy if you're in a warmer and more humid climate. If you have pets (especially larger dogs or cats) you know leaving food out is a bad idea, right? If you're baking every day, and the bread is lucky to last until afternoon tea time, then again, prudence is warranted to avoid issues.

    Now there's some things I just think are a potential issue... without me disagreeing per se.

    Like many books, James speaks about things in his local area. From the types of flour he uses to the "Teddy" stand mixer he likes so much. That's all great and well if you live in the UK or Europe.. Not so great if you live in Australia. I see this a lot in UK/Euro based sourdough books (like Vanessa Kimbell's "Sourdough School", which also has a decent tretise on bread and health and also recommends UK/European flours).

    If you're a proud owner of James' earlier books, please note that several recipes from those books are re-hashed here. So this takes the total count of original recipes from a respectable 42 to an somewhat lower count. It also makes it harder to recommend the previous books if they have similar recipes and include information that James has corrected/ammended in this one.

    Similarly, if you've read Richard Bertinet's books you can truly feel Richard's influence on James' book. The "Epic Buns" is another take on Richard's braided cinnamon muffins, just in a scrolled/sliced form. I'm not saying it isn't good.... but compare the two and you'll see what I mean.

    Honestly, I was a bit disappointed that in a book that espouses it's easy-to-understand/approachable design, then failed to provide a photo of the finished product for each and every one of it's recipes. Sure, most of the recipes do, but some have shaped doughs pre bake on a peel, and several "filler images" throughout the book. I feel there needs to be a little less "art directing" and more "informative imagery". I know many other books lack photos too, but James "raised my expectations" then didn't quite fully deliver. Meanwhile, many (more modern) recipe books show great images and they're definitely not designed to be as in-depth as "Super Sourdough".. which further increases the irony.

    Conclusion:

    While James is clear that he's just sharing his personal knowledge, his bread techniques, and what works for him in his area, "Super Sourdough" is still very capable of giving a new baker the skills to make great bread.

    That said, you will have to tinker with your ingredients a little bit, and decide for yourself what does, and doesn't work for your situation. So for UK/Euro bakers, this is a great book. If you're in the middle of nowhere Australia, you're probably going to have to adapt, or import Euro flours. Honestly, I have not found a way to order UK flours online yet, so approximations will have to do

    So what is "Super Sourdough" like to bake from?

    Honestly, it's not bad, and of the recipes I've tried, most have turned out. The recipes that I've done more than once, have often benefited from minor tweaks, such as a longer proof, or a slight adjustment to the length of the bake (the difference between using a baking stone as indicated, and a baking steel I chose to use for the extra surface area does need monitoring and adaptation).

    I tend to spoil my starter, so it doesn't quite get that tang, but I do think the flavours are definitely there and works reasonably well with the recipes, whether I "stick to the plan" or "tinker a bit".... (within reason, of course).

    So let's have a look at a "first attempt bake", shall we?

    Demi baguettes à l'ancienne

    Demi Baguettes À L'ancienne.. (old-style sourdough mini baguettes)

    Now there are some great recipes in this book, but alas I've made them before. So I decided to finally take the rolls thing a bit more seriously. Honestly, I don't think I've attempted a sourdough baguette so making roll-sized sourdough baguettes seemed like a good idea.

    The recipe came together exactly as I expected... so when I made a second concurrent batch, I decided to have a little bit of fun and make a malt-infused batch... by adding 20g of malt. Even this small amount changed the dough, so it needed 30g extra flour to balance it and match the consistency. That said, the malted version was still a little less strong, and considerably more sticky. However, with a dough scraper and a will to clean it up, it wasn't sloppy, just looser.... yet somehow had trouble taking on new shapes... it just kept wanting to contract back into it's old shape. Using James' language, it was quite extensible, but relatively more elastic. 

    So I made some mini sourdough baguettes "as written" (like the one above), and two hybrid/marbled mixed mini baguettes (one is shown below) just for fun!

    Original, and

    Have a look at the marbled rolls for contrast...

    Here I've included the same mini sourdough baguette roll at the top, and the marbled, somewhat longer one below.

    Unfortunately, the marbled one here was the straighter slashed roll (of the marbled options), but that didn't go quite as well as the original roll above... so I have a longer/thinner roll than I originally intended.

    I also managed to crack the top of the marbled loaf as I was slicing it "in half" (it wasn't in practice because it slipped and it was more like 40:60 top/bottom respectively). The top of the marbled roll shows the characteristic blistering of retarded proofing (at least in the non-malted sections) and the malted sections does have it, but it's just harder to see. Time constraints limited my retarded second prove to about 10 hours instead of the 12-18 indicated in the recipe.

    Ok, the crumb could have been a little  more open, and the crust is thicker than I'd normally like in a baguette but I'm satisified with that for a first trial. You know, now I quite like sourdough baguettes! The malt does add an extra flavour that's reminiscent of Milo/almost chocolate-ish hint that's oddly savoury so it still works with various condiments, including tuna, which is quite unexpected.

    Lots of demi baguettes in a home made breadbag

    Before we finish this book up...

    Imagine that someone turns up to your small gathering with a bag laden with rolls like this... Would you say no? 

    Actually this bag was designed and sewn by Ren. This is far from Ren's most ambitious sewing work (I think that was the full Vienna-styled masquerade ball gown, complete with full Jester's outfit for me. However whether it's a convenient rubbish bin strapped to the back of a car seat, or pantry-dwelling potato/onion bag... they seem to get used in many places around the home here. Not the least of which is for transporting bread, and of course, as a photographic prop!

    Ok, this image was taken by Ren, Ren's bleeding-edge software blurred it somewhat during web-friendly export, so I used my prehistoric software to overcome the bizarre problem. So don't underestimate old versions of software, because you never know if an update, is actually an upgrade! With that said... I'm sure they'll fix it.
    Bread Science by Emily Buehler

    Emily Buehler - Bread Science

    If you want to know how folded proteins and gluten networks work in bread structures, the roles and effects of enzymes and chemical reactions happening during bread making this is probably a good start.

    Interestingly, I have the original, self-published edition which I have to say, doesn't have a cover this pretty. Emily wrote on her site that she decided to jazz it up with a professionally designed cover a few years back... instead of updating the whole book for a 15th anniversary edition. So mine is just the less colourful one.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus:The food science behind bread making. The interwoven roles of biology, physics and chemistry during fermentation/respiration, oxidation and baking. It discusses where flavours and colours come from, the diversity and potential pathways for flavour compound development. It also discusses the physical changes done during mixing, resting, kneading and of course baking too.

    Total page count: 254

    No. of pages before recipes: 203

    Metric/imperial units? Both (and volume measurements for "in a pinch" moments). Note: Temperature is only in Fahrenheit!

    Number of recipes: 4

    Photos for every recipe? No. Black and white photocopy-grade images, shrunk to 5cm x 3cm (2 square inches)… the rest of the images are largely hand drawn… like really-meticulously drawn class notes.

    Price range (new): New edition kindle: $10.64 (AUD), Softcover $40-$80 (AUD)

    Price range (used): Old edition softcover, $8-25

    Notable Features & FYI: All the bread science you'd need without paying the "Modernist Cuisine's" eye watering $900-$1500 for the five volume "Modernist Bread" set, or even the stripped down "Modernist Bread at Home" single volume, which still commands a $350 sum, and over $250 used!

    Ok, "Bread Science" isn't directly competing with such weighty tomes, but it is definitely an extension on "The Sourdough Framework", and with cheaper print editions, and more in-depth research.

    This book is almost entirely bread science, with over 80% of the entire book dedicated to theory and technical knowledge, and how to apply it in a general manner. That extends the theory of most of the books in this list. As such, it fits a particular niche in my library, and apparently, many other bread libraries as well.

    Two differing editions of bread science by Emily Buehler.

    A tale of two editions (so far)...

    I have the original (brown) edition of "Bread Science" which has served me well. If you're wondering what the difference between the old and new edition is, Emily states the following on her web site:

    "The Bread Science 15th Anniversary Edition arrived on September 1, 2021. It does not have loads of new material. It has a new (professional!) cover. I have tweaked a few points I’ve learned more about since 2006 and (for longer discussions) added footnotes directing readers to the updates page on this website: https://twobluebooks.com/updates/."

    Those of us with old editions (or can only get old editions) may find it's not so bad. The original edition is sometimes selling for less than the e-book price of the new one from second hand sellers like Abe Books, so given the updates linked above... maybe you can save a few dollars and give a still-great book a home. :-)

    Bread Science - Pros and Cons:

    The biggest con of this book would (at first glance) seem to be the rather low recipe count. However, Emily has built the entire book so that you don't need to rely on recipes. So it's a "con" that's self-rectifying.

    The second con of this book, is that it really is.... quite dry in places. It took me a couple of goes to make it all the way through the book. It's not that it's hard, it's just left me thinking: 

    "I am going to need some time to think/digest/consider the stuff I just read for a while". 

    The third con is the Fahrenheit-only temperature listings. So get used to converting them.

    The fourth and final con....

    Unfortunately, if you don't have a scientific background, this book can be overwhelming. I mean, proteins, enzymes, bacteria, oxidation, etc.... Might scare some people off. However, I strongly urge you to persevere because at the end of the day, simply learning that longer/slower/cooler fermentation and "baking crusts dark" often result in better flavour is really enough to get you substantial gains for little knowledge. That said, knowing why your bread is good is handy for reproducing the results and/or planning future "tweaks" to your current process if there are any issues.

    Where are the pros, Ham?

    Honestly, it's a book I keep coming back to because I do forget bits, but it's never hard to look a key concept and refresh the knowledge again, even if the book is a bit dry in places... so it works well as a reference and it should be acknowledged for that. 

    Ultimately, if science and understanding why things are behaving as they are and what to do about it, is your goal, then there are few books at this price point that cover the information you seek so well. The next step up can cost hundreds more dollars... usually in the form of text books, professional grade guides, and scientific publications. 

    I wouldn't say that this is the first book you should read when starting to make bread, but for any serious baker, or those considering a professional career, then this is something you absolutely should read.

    So what's it like to bake a recipe from "Bread Science?".

    Honestly, I had a hard time with this book, because I hadn't left any recipes unmade when I started this "First attempt" stuff. I've owned this book for nearly 14 years at the time of writing. If there's only a handful of recipes, then it's not hard to complete the "Buehler challenge".

    From memory, none of the recipes have caused any major dramas. Although, I hate it when all the temperatures are in Fahrenheit. I hope Emily has added metric conversions to the recipe in the newer version... but I suspect she hasn't.

    So I had to literally take a recipe base (to link it to these recipes) and then tweak it as Emily encourages the reader to do. So, I decided to marble the sourdough recipe with a beetroot powder-infused portion of the dough, and add some seeds for good measure.

    Ham's first attempt at Sourdough Rolls enhanced with Beetroot (Pic: Ren)

    Ham's first attempt at Sourdough Rolls (made with starter) enhanced/improvised with marbled beetroot dough  (Pic: Ren)

    Officially, this is using the "Sourdough with Starter" recipe. However, Emily's main goal with this book is to get you to the point that you don't need a recipe anymore. At the time of writing, I'm more of a "use a recipe as a base, then tweak it as needed" stage in my bread journey, but my adaptations are slowly getting higher success rates.

    The white part of this bread is the original recipe, and it works quite well. The brown part of the bread is exactly the same mix only with the addition of beetroot powder. When the dough was mixed, the brown bits were an almost flourescent pink/purple colour. You can still see the darker purple tinges wherever the beetroot dough was close to (and forming) the crust. I have no idea why the crumb went brown though while the shallower parts stayed red.... 

    Marbled Sourdough with beetroot rolls

    Continuing the roll theme.... Pic: Ren

    Firstly, this roll was made with the leftovers from my marbled loaf pan version of this bread. Unfortunately, sometimes it's hard to ensure that new recipes do in fact, fit the pan I bake with. So sometimes I have to cut back to ensure that it doesn't overflow, or build it up to compensate for any sluggishly rising doughs.

    Anyway, this particular bread was either a very small batard-shaped loaf, or a very large dinner roll where it would not be hard to place an entire T-bone steak inside. Now I'm hungry....

    Actually, this image has a warmer tone to it than expected. The image immediately above was a closer match to reality. However, it does show the outer crust, and while the sesame seeds and pepitas do hide the blistered texture I'd expect with a slow-risen sourdough, it is there if you look carefully enough.

    So how does it taste?

    The sourdough tang is present and reasonably "forward" amongst the other flavours. Meanwhile there's a hint of beetroot from the brown-formerly-known-as-pink dough. I find it's quite interesting and pleasant, even if I lost the beetroot hue.

    Adding a small handful of sesame seeds into the white dough, along with the top added a toasted sesame flavour that pairs pretty well with the beetroot while adding texture. The use of whole wheat also brought a rustic flavour and texture to the mix.

    I don't think it'll shock anyone that a baguette recipe from a technical book on bread mechanics has an authentic French bread flavour. When the bread was freshly cooled from coming out of the oven, it had a crispy crust, but as we took photos and such, it slowly became softer and chewier by that afternoon. There's a reason that the French buy bread daily. Although, by day two, the crust had softened to the point where it would suit people who find it hard to bite into things, and the sourdough tang had become even more noticeable. This is common with sourdoughs.. the tang can get stronger over time. Honestly, I don't see a lot of sourdough baguettes here in Australia and I have to say that I enjoy it. So it's tasty, it looks interesting, and being a sourdough it should be a little easier to digest (if such things worry you) and will last longer than other bread types if we can stop ourselves from eating it.... given that it's a sourdough afterall.

    This one, I consider a hefty success. Speaking of French baguettes.... the next book is literally "As French as it gets!".

    Marbled beetroot sourdough loaf... at least, what's left.

    The marbled beetroot sourdough loaf Pic: Ham!

    Since the other rolls were made the leftover dough from making this loaf, I felt it important to show you what that looks like. Alas, we'd already started slicing into it before we managed to shoot this, so I had to act quickly in order to avoid missing my opportunity.

    Unfortunately, the middle "hump" (as shown here) had some of the least marbling in the entire loaf, but I think it works as an illustration.

    Now, to you budding food photographers out there, which shot of this bread do you like the most?

    Loaves taste... different?!

    It seems odd, and I'm not entirely sure what's going on. My theory is that cooking the loaf in a silicone loaf pan shielded the lower parts of the loaf from some of the heat.

    While I did bake it uncovered afterwards to get a more even browning, (except where the patches of beetroot-infused dough broke through), it didn't have a have quite the crust development as baking a roll in a preheated cast iron loaf pan. So it's softer all around and slightly (it might be my imagination) tangier. Although it's har to say,the sesame seeds on top really do add a potent toasted flavour and smell that might confuse the palate. It's very pleasant though. :-)

    Raymond Calvel's

    Raymond Calvel's The Taste of Bread (2013 edition)

    This is a very popular book for a reason. However, it is somewhat technical, it doesn't have beautiful glossy photos of more modern books (so it's showing it's age), and it is literally translated from French.. so there's some linguistic quirks here & there.

    Love french bread?


    Often, when you're talking about finding a recipe for a true french bread, it's often the usual basic recipes that don't live up to the hype because you'll only get French baker's secret family recpies when you pry it from their cold dead fingers. Ok that might be an exaggeration, but the simplified home bread baking books aren't going to hone your craft to the level of the best boulangeries of Paris, using their commercial techniques and locally milled flours.

    If you're looking for authentic French bread, this book is perhaps one of the best books to remedy this outside of visiting a French culinary institute, or marrying into a baker's family.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: What makes a good bread. Specific to French bakery (mostly bread)

    Total page count: 207

    No. of pages before recipes: 90 (lots more technical data at the beginning of each recipe chapter, and for each style of recipe).

    Metric/imperial units? Both

    Number of recipes: 37 bread types (not including variants), 24 sweet breads/brioche/croissant etc.

    Photos for every recipe? No, some black and white images but few recipes have any images.

    Price range (new): $143 for an ebook?! Are you high Amazon?! $150-$240 (Australian) for the soft cover, and hard cover...

    Price range (used): $380-$445 in hardcover USED! (I've never seen a hardcover one though, and I'm not sure it's translated into English or in French). Used soft covers seem to be very few and far between. If they are locatable, they're sometimes more expensive than the new ones.

    Notable Features & FYI: Literally written by the man who coined the term "autolyse". Raymond insipired a whole generation of French bakers and was a key influence in restoring the quality of French baking... that had eroded due to "profit-driven" modern industrial baking methods. This downward trend in French bakeries occurred between World War 2 and the late 70s, when he started his research into "what makes a good bread?". He used modern science and applied that to rediscovering traditional baking methods and ingredients, all while incorporating modern techniques intelligently into the finished recipes. This is a book that I read periodically. You can't expect to remember most of what it teaches you in one hit, and I learn something different each time. While it centres on French baking, many of the techniques will work for other styles of bread and pastries too.

    Taste of Bread - Pros and Cons:

    The Pros:

    The authors really know their stuff. Raymond and his "crew" has given you the tools to make a range of authentic French-styled breads, and improve your other varieties as well.

    When Raymond wrote this with his co-authors, he was one of France's foremost professors working on the question:

    "What makes good bread?"

    Through his work, he is often attributed to inspiring a whole generation of french bread bakers. It's a shame he died in 2005.. at the ripe age of 92.

    However, you do not have to learn French to read this book, it was translated into English into what is the most fundamentally expensive bread baking book I own.

    Technically, my 207 page edition is a softcover, and at well over $150 USD ($255 Australian, delivered) it's a very expensive book that I frankly debated for months before buying. In short, it was cheaper than doing the 5 week "Boulangerie" course at the Sydney campus of "Le Cordon Bleu" which would have cost me $8000 after including course fees, accommodation, living expenses and course-related expenses). Unfortunately, this book doesn't give me the shiny certificate of completion or access to live instruction along the way. Not that it was ever meant to.

    However, The Taste of Bread covers a range of in-depth topics from a uniquely french viewpoint. It's somewhat technical in nature because it covers topics from the effects of the wheat type and milling processes, the characteristics of "bread flour" (as opposed to "All purpose" varieties), dough composition, the role of oxidation during mixing, leavening and fermentation, the effect of dough division and shaping, as well as the basic (and industrial) equipment used in bread baking, and finally the storage of bread.

    I'd say it extends on both Sourdough Framework, and Flour Lab (reviewed here too) in terms of technical detail. Flour Lab and Sourdough Framework are aimed at hobbyists... while The Taste of Bread is probably amongst the text books of several french culinary institutes... and carries the higher price tag to prove it. :~(

    That said,"The Taste of Bread" dials the science back a bit from "Bread Science" but extends on the more advanced equipment side and practical procedures. Not surprising, it's aimed at teaching aspiring professional bakers. Honestly, it does have a more commercial, efficient, industrial orientation, whereas other bread science books are more about the artisanal tinkering and problem solving in more of a home setting.

    Most of the content is fundamentals and with smatterings of bread science here and there. Yet combined, this is getting fairly technical. It's not that the beginner couldn't understand it, but it's just that there's a lot of stuff you don't necessarily need to know if you're running from established recipes.

    However, if you want to extract every scrap of flavour from your breads, and want the softest crumb or flakiest crust while paving your own path, then this book will be extremely helpful.

    If french bread is your goal, this is essential reading.

    Cons:

    While this was published in 2013, roughly 8 years after Raymond's death and translated into english, it's not without some linguistic quirks like sentences that could be clearer, and others phrased in oddly-roundabout ways using unnecessarily fancy wording.

    Furthermore, this is not going to have the pretty pictures of more modern/stylish/coffee table books. Most recipes do not have any images of any kind.

    It's quite a dense read, with little to break up the text. So expect it to take some time if reading from start to finish.

    It has recipes (good ones at that) but I find that if you have a more powerful stand mixer, the times need to be somewhat reduced to avoid "over kneading/mixing", depending on the mixing speed of course.

    If "french" bread is less important, and simply good bread is your goal... that $150 USD price tag for a soft-cover... will not appeal.

    To put that price in perspective, that's roughly... five times more expensive than many of my other books on this list. You have to consider that investment carefully. You could buy a Kitchen Aid grain milling attachment, ($149), Flour Lab ($20 at a discount book seller), and still have $86 Australian dollars to buy 20Kg of hard winter wheat berries... Doable if you pick up from the store. You can probably buy some nice seeds to add on top!

    That is the choice between advanced theory and getting a jump-start in practical home grain milling. Both can render tasty results, just in entirely different ways. I don't think there's a right or wrong answer, just what's right for you. But this is still a great book too!

    Conclusion:

    With all that said, if you:

    • are considering becoming an apprentice/professional baker,
    • are a "bread nerd" in the making, (or a long standing one looking to expand toward french bread baking)
    • have a bread maven/francophile in the household, or...
    • just want to be knowledgeable enough/empowered to chart your own course in your bread making journey by strategic recipe adaptations...

    ...then this is an essential read. For everyone else.. a cheaper more practical book is likely a better choice.

    A basket full of baguettes (that were supposed to be rolls)

    Ham's first attempt at "Milk rolls".... Yes, I know they're baguettes!

    Let me just start by saying that this is officially, a textbook for aspiring professional bakers.

    Officially, this is from the recipe for milk bread rolls. However, when your recipe includes two full kilograms of flour, sixty grams of yeast, malt extract, basically a whole stick of butter (because it's French) and the recipe replaces all the water with milk... I quickly found that I don't have enough oven space to bake that many individual rolls. So now Ren is mocking me about my "Ham sized rolls". Ok, I could feed half the neighbourhood.. but the ones I've met seem to be gluten intolerant or "avoiding carbs".

    Now, it's not shown above, but right up the back of this 60cm/2ft long basket, underneath the baguettes is a roll shaped bun. It's a bun in the truest sense of the word... if your bun was sized so the burger patty for this one needs to be 20cm/8" wide.

    This dough was particularly easy to shape, and it stood happily on it's own. So I used my new baking steels for bread, and they worked really well.

    Now, obviously with this much butter and milk the crust is soft, but not thick at all, and it has the pleasant, slightly more buttery texture and taste of a "slightly leaner brioche" with a sweet, but no identifiable honey taste/smell. Lately, I've been making a lot of sourdough and Nordic/extremely seedy breads, so this is a welcome reprieve from all that.

    The recipe is extremely laid back (particularly the "straight dough" rather than using the preferement option) and yes I sacrified a little flavour for expedience.. but in fairness... I found my cat Clarence trapped in a sewer pipe and spent last night and morning looking for him. He's home safe now, and even in my stressed and distracted state (it takes a while to relax), I can try a new recipe with these results. I don't normally "big note myself", but I'm actually surprised I managed this, and I think it's a testament the quality of this bread book and the recipe in question as well as my perserverence.

    Did I mention being distracted...

    Oh, that's a lot of bread... I could show restraint and freeze the pre-sliced loaves.. or I can just moderate my moderation, and get fat while enjoying a ton of good bread.

    Want to place your bets on which one happens? :~)

    Bakery School - From Le Cordon Bleu

    Le Cordon Bleu - Bakery School

    If Raymond Culvel inspired a generation of bakers to make "good French bread", the courses taught at various French culinary institutes like Ecole Ducasse, Paul Bocuse, Ferrandi, and Le Cordon Bleu, (amongst others) are likely the means by which such knowledge is distributed.

    This is Le Cordon Bleu's basic err... text? on general bakery (breads, pastries, cakes, etc). They have a more bread focussed one on "boulengerie" too.. but I can't seem to get my hands on one.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: French/European breads, (130 odd pages), French/European pastries and cakes (110 pages), 15 pages of "snacks" (sandwiches, pizza, quiches & muffins). Decent intro/theory too!

    Total page count: 319

    No. of pages before recipes: 59

    Metric/imperial units? Metric

    Number of recipes: 80

    Photos for every recipe? Yes, but sometimes two or more recipes are depicted in the one image (unlabeled unfortunately), sometimes arranged in pleasing patterns, not necessarily with instructive details in mind. Lots of step-by-step series of images in method areas though.

    Price range (new): $55-$120 (AUD)

    Price range (used): $50-$100 (AUD)

    Notable Features & FYI: This is truly a beginner-friendly text book. While it doesn't have the author's backstory, or anecdotes about where the grains come from, or reminiscences of "the good old days", it combines the goals of traditional bread baking with modern methods. It's a very detailed, but practical (no fluff) book. It's not as advanced as the "Advanced Bread and Pastry" or "The Taste of Bread", or even "Bread Science", but it still has a respectable intro/theory section that is more than enough to get going.

    I really like the sheer number of step-by-step photos and the images of the finished products, but sometimes, those finished product images are combined with the finished photos of other recipes in images sometimes 2, or even seven pages away. That I don't like so much, considering they're not labelled. So unless is obvious, I can't say for certain which of five baguettes corresponds with which recipe.

    Le Cordon Bleu: Bakery - Pros and Cons:

    Pros:

    This is a much more visual text book, first and foremost. It's more modern than "The Taste of Bread", and as such, has lots of useful and pretty pictures. Honestly, that's something I'd been missing in the previous two reviews above.

    That said, "Le Cordon Bleu: Bakery" is aimed at people doing the shorter (possibly hobbyist grade) courses or doing the earlier stages of Le Cordon Bleu's full professional bakery qualifications. In that regard, it's very good if you keep this in mind, and are at that stage in your bread making.... even if you don't do the course itself.

    This is a "gateway textbook" to the more advanced texts. It works well and doesn't have that entirely clinical/professional tone that more advanced books seem to have. It also skips over most of the geopollitical, food industry, "lets go back to our roots" themes. It's about teaching you to make bread. That's it.

    I think it would definitely help to build confidence for those unsure of whether a more serious text book is for them. It's also cheaper than many of the others. So that's a serious consideration.

    The Cons:

    However, while it works really well for people just starting out or at the hobbyist grade, as a book... it does fall short (to varying degrees and differing ways) of the progressively more comprehensive texts like:

    • "Professional Bread Baking" by Hans Welker, from the Culinary Institute of America (not reviewed here yet, but I read it several years ago..)
    • "Professional Baking" by Wayne Gisslen (reviewed below)
    • "Advanced Bread and Pastry" by Michel Suas (reviewed next)

    So don't fall into the trap that all text books equal, or are either too hard, or too expensive, there's a text book aimed at almost any level. However each level has drawbacks and this one is no different.

    It's not going to teach you everything, but it is going to teach you more than most of the popular hobbyist-grade books.

    The main thing that separates a text from a recipe book, is that texts include the food science aimed at giving you the knowledge and skills to get the desired end result. Similarly, a text book differs from an academic/theoretical food science paper/publication in that it includes the recipes to demonstrate the science and give you a chance to try it for yourself. So they bridge the gap between advanced food science research, and the recipes you'd find in a book, magazine or online. Ultimately, text books summarise and publish scientific stuff in an applied/approachable way, (which is a lot of work by itself) while giving you the recipes to appreciate that information first hand. (even more work) and it's for this reason, text books are often more expensive.

    Conclusion:

    Ultimately, I think "Le Cordon Bleu - Bakery" does a really good job at bridging that gap.... and in some ways, this goes further into the science than the ever-popular "Bread Baker's Apprentice", "Flour, Water, Salt Yeast", and Tartine. Even though they're well explained and work work well in home kitchens.

    Yes, "Bread Science", "Sourdough Framework", and indeed many other books do dabble in teaching you key food science knowledge... probably fairly comparably to this particular text... but they don't have the balance with the recipes, and are somewhat more... theoretical and less vocationally aimed. That said, this is perhaps one of the least theoretical texts out there, and the step-by-step instructions obviously lower the overall recipe count... so it's a compromise. Other, more advanced books won't hold your hand quite so much.... but provide more techniques, information and recipes to practice with. Naturally, they'll take you further into advanced baking.. but they will need greater confidence and skills to use effectively.

    So what's "Le Cordon Bleu - Bakery" like to actually bake with?

    Baguettes, sliced to shape a head of wheat.

    Baked, sliced, unusually presented, and photographed by Ham.

    ...but is it art?

    No piece of pseudo art would be complete with some thought-provoking and/or pretentious title. There were a few options...

    • What is the best thing since sliced bread?
    • Origins in bakery
    • A head for bread
    • Bake the cycle

    Which do you like?

    This is the "same day, non-poolish, non-preferment baguette" from Le Cordon Bleu's - "Bakery School".

    In short, this is about as basic as a baguette can possibly get. Of course, that didn't stop me from tweaking it a little by adding some poppy seeds into the mix.

    Honestly, I was extraordinarily pressed for time (we were completely out of bread) so I rushed this one through between other baking projects... which cut the proofing time down a bit.

    Alas, even though there are a lot of fine instructions in the book, one quirky omission was the size of the intended baguettes. I made mine thinner and longer so that the bake time would be shorter. But this had complications like.. I didn't own a pan long enough to accommodate it, and I really didn't have time to proof it more.

    It tastes good, and would be better if I had stuck with the program. However, there's real value in seeing thing when they go "off the rails" a little. Ok, it didn't rise as much (obviously), but it wasn't overly dense.. it just wasn't as open in the crumb as I'd like. The crust was crunchy, and worked exceptionally well with hommus and halloumi! (Although it disappeared so quickly I didn't get a shot of that).

    Anyway, I think that for a basic recipe, it was about as good as you can get in that short of a time frame, between other projects.

    I also enjoyed playing with my food and of course, the camera too!

    Want to see how I improved on the second try?

    Le Cordon Bleu - Baguette with fermented dough

    Ham's second bake but first attempt at this recipe - "Baguette with fermented dough"

    Please forgive me, I didn't have much time and shot this with an old iPhone. The colour is a bit off. This recipe draws on one of the preferment recipes found around pages 32-35 (from memory), and theoretically makes three small baguettes. However, I chose to make one longer one, and this is just under 75cm (nearly 30") long which is longest I can make one across the diagonal of my wall oven....

    ... except this recipe only uses 100g of the 500g (20%) of the preferment... so now I have a slightly over-proofed preferment. So please keep this in mind!

    This recipe works very well and even with my constant need to change a recipe, it's looking (and tasting) pretty darn good.... even if I do say so myself!

    Advanced Bread & Pastry by Michael Suas

    Michael Suas - Advanced Bread & Pastry

    Have you gotten pretty comfortable with baking in general? Are you ready to take it a bit further? If so, then you're in the right place. :~)

    This isn't just some slightly more technical tome. This will teach you how to navigate some of the more challenging tasks done in baking... whether that's breads or pastries.

    This is a true baking textbook for bakers aiming at going pro through an apprenticeship. Naturally it goes through both bread, viennoiserie (a hybrid between bread and pastries) and of course, full-blown pastries and other sweet things at that end too.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: An actual text book on "bakery"/"viennoiserie", "pastry", & cakes.

    Total page count: 1041

    No. of pages before recipes: 186

    Metric/imperial units? BOTH

    Number of recipes: Almost 300

    Photos for every recipe? No.

    Price range (new): $195-240 (AUD)

    Price range (used): $120-270 (AUD)

    Notable Features & FYI: This suits serious baking enthusiasts, baking apprentices, and professionals.

    The recipe break down is incredibly hard to identify as there's a lot of cross-referencing in the five full pages of separate recipe index. There's definitely over 30 recipes for bread, easily over 100 of cakes and pastries, including detailed separate recipes for fillings, icings, and accompaniments.

    There's the highest number of graphs I've seen in a bread book to date, and much more applied science in the 170+ pages of theory.

    Ham's Wheaten Honey Pan Loaf

    Ham's first attempt at "Wheaten Honey Pan Loaf" (Photographed by Ren)

    Now, this book is very different from most of the other books listed here. Firstly, you're not going to be able to bake anything without understanding baker's percentages, and compulsory/exclusive use of weight measurements (no cups, teaspoons, etc here). So if you don't have a set of kitchen scales, then you absolutely need to go buy some at this level of baking!

    Honestly, if you're a complete baking beginner, you simply cannot pick this up, read a recipe and expect it to work every time. This book expects you to have read the theory section or are at least very comfortable with various baking procedures without being told in each and every recipe.

    I'm not going to lie, it get's pretty in-depth/technical.

    There's some discussion about how fast your stand mixer works (in revolutions per minute or RPM) and factors that into each recipe (with you making the appropriate adjustments using the formula from the theory section) it's helpful in ensuring that you don't over-knead/mix the dough... particularly the softer, looser, slacker doughs where every bit of gluten counts. There are additional procedures used in this recipe that aren't mentioned anywhere in most of the other books, because this text really is living up to the advanced title. While I'd read about the dual hydration (adding the water in two separate stages which renders a softer texture) in the theory section, this was my first recipe to try it. I think that it works, but perhaps not as much as adding in the oil that this recipe requires, and it definitely makes the dough more challenging to deal with until it firms up a bit.

    That's not to say that this book is perfect though.

    You see if you add all the ingredient weights up (according to the recipe "as is") it comes out with 4.5Kg of dough. It says, that the yield for this recipe is five, 900g loaves. Which it absolutely does. However, in the method section, I'm supposed to divide my dough into five 450g balls.... which is half what I have to work with. I'd understand it if you're adding multiple balls into the loaf pan for that "multiple hump" loaf top.. but that's not what's going on here. I'd divide it into five 900g balls and then figure out which shaping technique suits your loaf pan, dutch oven, or even baking steel/stone. However, I will say that this particular recipe lends itself to pans with walls more than stones... which is exactly as the recipe suggests.

    Back to the recipe...

    The use of oil instead of butter, gives it a softer but less buttery flavour (obviously) and despite the use of quite a bit of honey, for the sheer quantity of dough, it's more subtle than some of the other honey breads I've baked. However, it really does live up to that rustic wheaten style of loaf with a hint of honey-based sweetness, rather than the milky/buttery softer breads like brioche and milk breads such as pain de mie. The use of a good seed mix on top, baked for additional flavour, adds a delightful texture.... although it does leave a horrendous amount of seedy crumbs everywhere whenever this Ham tries to slice and eat this bread.

    The Nordic Baking Book by Magnus Nilsson

    Magnus Nilsson - The Nordic Baking Book

    If you think France, Germany, Austria, or Italy have the most diverse range of bread, you might be surprised that this is not the case.

    Magnus has really put a lot of work into this book, across several countries and a multitude of islands. He's delved into the history of the region, how the Norse climate actually expanded the variety of grains and seeds used to make bread, and discussed how the historically low population densities, isolationism (during winter and geographically) increased bread diversity across the "Nordic" region.

    This is as much investigative journalism, as culinary history, cultural analysis over time and space, and general baking book. So this is very different from most of the others on this list.

    Ready to understand "The importance of Fika" and bake Svartbröd as though you've got a Viking horde looting your kitchen?

    (You know, I bet you didn't expect to read that sentence when you woke up. Hehehe.)

    Lets go!

    P.S. Svartbröd is black rye bread. It sounded less off-putting to Wörtbread, ok?

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: General baking book specialising in the wide variety of baked goods that are made across northern Europe, Iceland & Greenland.

    Total page count: 575

    No. of pages before recipes: 99

    Metric/imperial units? Both

    Number of recipes: 481 total. 32 wheat breads, 17 rye breads, 28 flat breads, 13 rusks/crackers, 10 sandwiches/filled pasties, 1 nordic pizza dough, 25 pancakes/waffles, 28 porridge & grain soups, 37 sweet levened pastries, 6 sweet kringles (pretzel), 11 doughnuts/fried pastries, 62 short pastries and cookies, 22 muffins/individual pastries, 10 sweets & chocolates, 46 soft cakes, 34 layered cakes/tortes, 7 crumbles/pies, 27 desserts, 12 jams/jellies/cordials, 18 sweet soups/compotes, and 35 basic recipes (that usually augment the other recipes). Phew! That took a while! I bet few reviewers went to this much trouble!

    Photos for every recipe? No.

    Price range (new): $48-$145 (Australian, hardcover).

    Price range (used): $46-$70 (Australian, hardcover)

    Notable Features & FYI: You really can't expect many pictures with this one. With an extensive history/theory section accounting for 17% of the page count, that puts 481 recipes on just 476 pages. Some recipes are so involved or require enough ingredients to warrant multiple pages, and at other times, there's as many as 4 recipes per page. Forget step-by-step images here. There's not enough real estate for that. This book assumes that you are familiar with the process, your ingredients, your equipment and can adapt as needed. That said, most (certainly not all) of my first attempts have come out with only minor tweaks.

    It's for this reason, that I want to put it in the intermediate section. You're not going to have your hand held through these recipes. They're not hard, just not always glaringly obvious either. I've found it helpful to look at similar online videos/recipes, then applied those observations and techniques to these recipes.

    Treskornsbröd

    Ham's first attempt at Treskornsbröd (Danish three grains bread)

    I'm sorry it took so long to get to this bake. I went nuts doing the norse bread thing a while back, and I overdid it to the point that I didn't want to eat it or even see it for a while. By a while, I mean... years.

    According to the book Danish/Sweedish "Three Grains Bread" is a staple found in many people's homes. While some is home made, it's also made in huge quantities commercially in Northern Europe. So many people just buy it. So it's basically the seedier equivalent of a loaf of French "Pain de Mie", or American "Amish Milk Bread", or British "Cottage Loaf" (which is also milk-infused). Of course, while it's roughly similar to these other breads, I can't deny that each bread has it's own distinct flavour. Who knows, maybe mine turned out a little different to others because of the specific three grains I chose.

    Honestly, it's a relatively fast, easy bread to make. I wasn't entirely sure how dark to bake it, and there was the surprisingly large amount of yeast specified in the recipe. I knew it was going to grow... the problem was, that my loaf pan is just 1cm narrower, and while that doesn't sound like much, it has the most impact on overall loaf pan volume... so I have what I consider, to be bread derigibles (airships)... being somewhat less mushroomy than my "Make Ahead Bread" bake... which just kinda oozed due to a similar huge yeast quantity... but this one actually behaved like it should.

    The finished product...

    I'd like to say that when they suggest that this is a soft loaf, it's a very soft loaf. However, this is more because of a relative cutting into a still-cooling bread so it isn't perfectly cooked in the centre. That said, soaking the seeds and boiling them softened the seeds themselves. Subsequently melting in a little butter as it cooled down, and adding milk on top just ensured an incredibly soft crumb. So much so, that I barely noticed the seeded texture that I expected. However, this is probably at least partly because I chose pepitas, sesame seeds and black poppy seeds as my "three grain mix". Two out of the three are very small. If I had chosen larger/harder grains such as actual grains of rye or wheat, I'm sure that would a somewhat different story.

    Now the crust (at least on baking day) is crisp and sturdy... but please note that it is the only thing holding the cut slices together. Hard butter tore through this crumb like a plough does to soil.

    Honestly, this is a delicious and very filling bread. However, it requires a light touch and probably needs a runnier jam/warmed honey for a suitable condiment.

    Bread Exchange by Malin Elmlid

    Malin Elmlid - Bread Exchange

    This is a delightful book about Marlin's bread adventures (including international travel while bartering bread along the way).

    Standing back from the bread science, the range of recipes, the ingredients and the techniques involved for a moment...

    This book gets to the core concepts of sharing food with others, and of course, eating with other people. It speaks of getting along, and helping one another. Now, we all have our reasons for making bread and bread-adjacent stuff but for me personally, I just want the important people in my life to enjoy something I made, and of course learn along the way both from the bread making, and from those I share it with.

    I like this book because it really adds a multicultural, and scenic twist to a bread-centred endeavour along the way. I have other books like this that dedicate themselves to the cuisine from a particular region or country, but this one links several regions, with several cuisines, and many of the recipes found in the book have some sort of bread offering or bread-compatible recipe to add.

    In a weird way, it's almost like a bread pairing guide, like those found for charcuterie or cheese platters for your wine/beer/cocktail-infused soirees.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Part bread book, part travel book, part lifestyle book that hops from one country to another, and culinary experiences (many based on breads and pastries of the area) and ends up in San Francisco with a recipe for Rugbrod (Tartine Danish-style rye bread... see "Tartine" review on this page).

    Total page count: 239

    No. of pages before recipes: 35

    Metric/imperial units? Metric, with occasional imperial units thrown in.

    Number of recipes: 46 total. 10 breads/pastries/cakes/waffles/pancakes. but many not bread related, there's soups, even cocktails, a burger, home made condiments, and even museli.

    Photos for every recipe? Err. lots of photos about the travel/journey where she's making bread.. but which bread amongst the sea of very pretty images of places and culture... but not a whole lot of images directly linked to the bread recipes themselves.

    Price range (new): E-book $20 (AUD) Hard cover $45-70

    Price range (used): $35-70 (AUD) for a hardcover

    Notable Features & FYI: Honestly, this book stands alone in the "hey I bartered my way across the world making bread for people". It's a fun read which gives a much-needed reprieve from looking at the rest of the world through the lens of "the news" which of course is a seemingly non-stop torrent of depressing information with glimpses of almost-normalish everyday life thrown in occasionally.

    How good is this book, from a recipe standpoint? Let's see how I went.

    Malin's

    The "Bread Exchange Sourdough Bread" (Black edition)

    Do you like the calico presentation on the left, or the warmer wooden tones on the right? Ren took these images but we both keep changing our minds about which image looks better.

    Elmlid's rye sourdough starter can be a challenge...

    Generally, I like to try using a starter made with the instructions from each book. Elmlid's "rye starter" took quite a bit of work, patience, experimentation, adaptation, frustration, exasperation, the occasional cajoling, and a significant refresh (bordering on restart) on multiple occasions. But I got there! You have no idea how long I've been fighting this (think weeks) where my sourdough bakes for this page came to a complete and grinding halt.

    I think it was the coarseness of my home-ground rye flour.. (it settled in the bottom of my starter, and water sat on top).

    But I digress.... Once the starter is good, the recipes get much easier.

    The bread....

    This take's "Elmlid's Simple Sourdough" and adds sage, booze and notably, food grade charcoal/ash. Now, I'm not going to lie, this is a rather unusual bread, even for me. However, my sage plant died, my booze was limited to wine (not exactly the spirits Elmlid suggested).. but I did have charcoal/ash. So here we are.

    What I like about this recipe is that it works, right off the page. However, there's a lot of sporadic folding. I think I did it every 30-45 mins for 4 hours, and I learned the absolute joy of kneading ash-rich dough each and every time.. and the need to wash my blackened hands immediately after each time. I still have ash under and around my nails.

    Now, no sourdough would be complete without the usual "slow rise" so adding an additional six hours after all that folding/resting (I've got work to do tomorrow, so overnight was out of the question)... this was a "short" all-day sourdough.... although a better result would probably be achievable through proofing overnight at the very least.

    Anyway, during the bake I was wondering:

    "Will I be able to tell the difference between a dark bake and burned given it's so black?" It's not easy, but I stuck with the script and even shortened the 250C/482F bake by nearly 10 minutes. (Checking paid off).

    How did it turn out?

    As expected, when I didn't do the slow rise overnight that tangy sourdough flavour was definitely more muted than it would have been. It wasn't gone just... reduced. Honestly, I thought my banneton may have added too much flour to the outside of my bread, but when I looked at the photo of the recipe in the book, it was actually pretty close. The crumb is thin and flaky but also somewhat pliable... the crumb is soft, and the marbled grey/black bread is definitely a conversation starter for any special occasions or social gatherings.

    Honestly, I think the sage and the booze, along with a longer proof time would take it to the next level, and I can see how the bread is one of Elmlid's signature breads... but I think you need to be selective about which booze you put in. I don't think crème de menthe, would work, but a lot of the others put in cakes/puddings probably would work. Matter of personal preferences I guess. You do you!

    A black sourdough slice, up close.

    I really like the marbled grey of the crumb with this loaf.

    I didn't feel that I got the details of the crumb right in the images above, so here's a single slice, shown up close and (mostly) in focus. So this was actually shot by yours truly... using Ren's shiniest camera.

    Why?!

    Photographically, this is where dynamic range (the difference between the brightest bits and the darkest parts of the scene a camera can capture in a single image without losing details) really helps. The white of the floured crust was nearly impossibly white in the light (hence putting the white crust on the shaded side) and the darker shades of the crumb rapidly goes to a featureless black without very careful management.

    Nailing both ends of that spectrum, indoors, using natural window light on a cloudy day was actually easier than balancing it on a brighter/sunnier day, and I had to forgo the flash, because it kept tinging the colour balance in slightly unnatural ways. So a very stead hand, vertical downward shot onto a bench reasonably close to a window got that natural look I was hoping for.

    It wasn't easy though!

    "Hat's off" to the photographers who make so many beautiful images in challenging, often-messy situations like this to show off beautiful foodie creations. :-)

    Crusts - By Barbara Caracciolo

    Barbara Caracciolo - Crusts: The Ultimate Baker's Book

    In some cases, this "general" book adds a lot of theory to more specialised books... about their respective and more focused topics. You can do this when your page count is triple the average.

    What you can't do with a mere tripling of page counts, is do all that, while adding 3x-10x the recipes (depending on the book compared) and a bio of every bakery/pizza shop/boulangerie in multiple countries along the way... without skipping on details somewhere. That somewhere, is the lack of pictures for the method. Sure, each chapter might have some guides, but not the recipe-specific step-by-step images you've seen in other texts. So "Crusts" is a detailed theory book, and then high-density recipe book, but the hand holding methods are somewhat absent. So don't expect every recipe to have pictures, but if you can handle that, a 7-15 recipe count for every dollar spent is fantastic value.

    This is the first (2018) edition, which was updated to a "revised edition" in 2023... which has a raspberry/strawberry pie on the front instead of this plain pie crust image here.

    "Crusts" is not limited to bread, it does both bread and pizza, along with pastries, pies and beyond, and there's some seriously nice recipes in there.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: An in-depth guide to bread with one of the largest recipe counts I've seen. The recipes are split into loaves, flatbread/unleavened breads, specialty breads/sides, pizza/calzones, pies, and finishes with sweet breads and tarts.

    Total page count: 841

    No. of pages before recipes: 64 (although this recipe is somewhat illustrative, rather than part of the recipe section)

    Metric/imperial units? Imperial only with volume measurements for backup. Sorry metric lovers, 300+ recipes will need conversion... or merely switch your digital scale to imperial and work from that.

    Number of recipes: 319 total. 83 loaves, 19 flat/unleavened breads, 66 specialty breads/sides, 48 pizzas/calzones (check out the sweet fillings in the dessert pizza), 61 pies (mostly the sweet kind), and 42 sweet breads/tarts.

    Photos for every recipe? There are a lot of recipes with full-page or partial page images. However, there are just as many without any imageswhatsoever. 121/319 38% (or conversely, 62% with images).

    Price range (new): $31-78 (Australian) for the hardcover.

    Price range (used): None cheaper (delivered) for less than the new ones.

    Notable Features & FYI: One one hand, this is a high-density recipe book. So if you're looking for one of those, then you're in luck. On the other side, the theory sections are some of the most in-depth I've seen so far, in any book. It may not go into "Bread Science" levels of proteins, but it does discuss a lot of factors that most other books fail to do.

    Pros:

    You get a lot of value here. Both in recipes and information.

    Barbara has gone "all out" in many ways where she's included recipes like Injera which is an African bread rarely seen in other books.

    Not only does it discuss water as an ingredient, but various factors of water like "water hardness", the pH, along with the more usual water temperature... a lot of books just don't cover all that.

    I particularly like the section "Encyclopedia of Grains and Pulses" which, along with descriptions of various wheats, oats, ryes, barleys, rices, corns, buckwheats, millets, quinoa, sorghum, numerous seeds, but even tubers, beans, legumes and coconuts. There's oftean a drawn diagram and brief synopsis about each variant of each type too.

    Don't skip the biographies!

    Throughout the recipe section there's a lot professional baker biographies. It also discusses their respective bakeries, pizzerias, boulangeries and baking schools across the world and it's really interesting to see how they got started, why they bake, and their particular interpretations of recipes. It's not a travel book but it is one of the most interesting range of recipes from across the globe, all in one handy book. Want to compare a Detroit pizza to a New York one, and a true Italian one from Naples... or perhaps even an Australian one? You can do that!

    Cons:

    Honestly, I have never liked bold claims like "The Ultimate....." or "The best..." or "The most...." anything. Because it's easy to get unfounded expectations... and even if such claims might have been true at the time of writing. Things change.. but books don't!

    Now, I don't want to devalue Barbara's work here. It's an excellent book to be sure. However, every book has limitations.

    To me the limitations are that this isn't going to suit everyone despite it's encyclopedic nature.

    I mentioned the Injera recipes above, it's is great that the recipes were included.... although none of those recipes have actual pictures. :-(

    If certain pictures had to be culled, I persionally think we could have skipped the pictures of some of the baguettes or uncovered pizza bases or unfilled pie crusts (we've all seen baguettes, pizza and pie bases) and focused on the ones most readers would not know what they look like. Perhaps this is what the second edition fixed... but I don't know.

    The one thing I felt this book didn't have, is a savoury pie crust. You know for meat pies, shepherd's pie, that sort of thing. There are many sweet crusts, in the book though. Unfortunately, I've long sought a short crust that has little if any sweetness to it, but for some reason, they end up with a weird sweetness that doesn't match the the slow roasted lamb, chicken & leek, or pepper steak filling. That said, despite this trivial disappointment, I've gotten a lot of great results from this book.

    Conclusion:

    This is an excellent book for bakers who have a little bit of experience already. You can use it as a beginner, but you're probably not going to have the hand-holding instructions that some other books offer. I particularly like the sheer number of recipes for the money, and it is ultimately, a very pretty book. It's not the glossy coffee table books that you might expect, but it's very good and I think it'd be a great addition to any baker's library.

    Poolish Ciabatta from Crusts

    Here's my first bake of Crust's "Poolish Ciabatta".

    Normally ciabatta is made in the shape of a "shoe" (flattish elongated loaf) but I made it with my usual loaf pan.. which I suppose makes it more like.... clown shoes?! This loaf is 20cm high, a 36cm long,and 24cm wide, weighing nearly 1.2Kg.

    Actually, I forgot to multiply the water for this make and it basically turned to dough into a brick. When I added the missing water as I should have, I had to break up the clumps into smaller clumps, then break those clumps into even smaller bits... you get the idea. To fix this, I lowered the temp, proofed it for far longer, then to deal with the much larger loaf size, I cooked it at 220C for twice as long, then baked it uncovered at the higher temp to a nice golden brown, rather than darker brown I'd normally opt for. This gives me a bit of "head room" to toast it further for breakfast or making brushcetta without burning anything.

    Ok, it's not going to have the flavour of a full sourdough ciabatta, with fresh milled flour, but it's very good and even with my stuff-up, tastes great!

    Bread The Ultimate Cookbook

    Bread: The Ultimate Cookbook

    Bread is in the same "Ultimate Cookbook" series as Crusts (immediately above, not "Crust" by Richard Bertinet, which is also in this list). Immediately, you're going to notice some similarities. The "Encyclopedia of Grains and Pulses" is identical. Much of the recommended kitchenware is also... funnily enough, identical... although some of the pie making stuff has been removed. Also, expect less pies and pastries in the recipe section... and a lot more breads and pizzas. Which is not suprising.

    There are a lot of recipes in this 800 page book. Most of them with images, but a decent portion without. However, there's some bread recipes in here, that I have not read about in any other book. So if you want a sheer diversity in your bread recipe options, this book has you covered. That said, you can expect a lot of overlap with the more conventional bread types found in other books.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: General bread making, including loaves, rolls/buns, flat breads, pizzas, focaccias, even some muffins/scones.

    Total page count: 799

    No. of pages before recipes: 72

    Metric/imperial units? Ingredients are both, but temperatures, only in Fahrenheit

    Number of recipes: 307 in total. 102 Loaf recipes, 42 Rolls/buns/bagels, 7 muffins. 11 pizza dough recipes, 47 pizza topping combination recipes. 4 focaccia dough recipes and 46 focaccia topping ideas. The focaccia blends with the pizza series somewhat (doesn't change the count though). 16 additional flat breads after that. 25 sweet and/or quick breads, then 14 additional "miscellaneous" recipes like sauces, spreads, icings, and syrups.

    Photos for every recipe? Most, but not all.

    Price range (new): .$25-70 (AUD) typical hard cover. $24-35 (AUD) e-Book

    Price range (used): Same as new pretty much, depending on source and condition. Postage often pushes the price above new with free delivery though.

    Notable Features & FYI: This book actually shares some of the content with the previous book. The "Encyclopedia of Grains and Pulses" is identical, there's some shared recipes between the books as well. Even a couple of the featured bakers/bakeries and pizzerias are featured in both, sometimes using identical photographs..  There's some new stuff in there too. Some of them, are in the recipe section and they are delicious. 

    From a purely bread/pizza/focaccia perspective, there's some truly exotic recipes that are only seen in the "Nordic Baking Book" like Tunnbröd, some odd ball pizzas like "Argentinian thick crust pizza". I don't see Arepas much either, at least, not here in Australian and main stream international bread books.

    The recipe quantities are in both imperial (and bracketed metric measurements afterwards), but the Fahrenheit-only temperatures is quite irritating to me.  I have the 2023, 800 page edition, rather than the 2025 one which seems to have culled 40 odd pages to 760 (at least, according to Amazon).

    There's no author, so I suspect the publishers have just taken elements from the other books in this series and smashed them together, which would account for the shameless rehashing of material. I am a little disappointed, this isn't the only book reviewed on this site that has used significant amounts of other book's material, and marketed it as a whole new book. This phenomenon seems to be growing in frequency... particularly with books released after 2020.

    Curiously, where "Crusts" had the biographies and featured bakeries/pizzerias inside the recipe section (usually near the recipes they're known for). "Bread" separated the biographies, and put them up the back in a dedicated section for the last 130 odd pages. Some new folks are introduced, but others are basically copy/pasted from Crusts.

    Who does this book suit?

    Honestly? I think that if you have either the Crusts or Bread "Ultimate Cookbooks".. it's not worth getting another. It also makes me less likely to buy other books in the series, because I have to wonder how much rehashed material will I be buying... even if it's ostensibly a very different subject. I'd definitely be looking for an author's name before I buy, that's for sure.

    Having said all that...

    If you're looking for high recipe-count-to-price value, you can't go wrong with this book. Particularly if you're more about breads/pizza, and less about sweet pies/tarts. If you want "general baking" then Crusts will be better suited.

    In many ways this is like an extended version of Ken Forkish's "Flour, Water, Salt, Yeast" (FWSY) which also happens to focus on bread and pizza. However, Ken's recipes are far more detailed. So I think FWSY is more beginner friendly.. and this one is definitely better described as:

    "Here's the recipe, good luck!"

    So I think this one is aimed at self-reliant beginners and intermediate bakers. Advanced bakers would also get a great library of recipes to base a bake on, and adjust to tastes and situations to forge their own path. So I don't think you'd actually grow out of this book, no matter what your baking level might be.

    So what is this book like to actually cook with?

    Cottage loaf image

    Ham's first attempt at "The Cottage Loaf"

    Now, one of the things I've discovered on this particular recipe, is that the butter and honey ingredients, despite being listed, were not mentioned in the method section at all! I ultimately added the honey and butter along with the flour... since there seemed no better time to add them in the entire process.

    I ultimately decided not to make the weird bread equivalent of a snowman as discussed in the instructions (a large boule or ball) with a smaller one on top) because that won't go into my toaster. So I used my silicone loaf pans for this one. However, I did follow the instructions to score (cut) the top... I feel for this particular loaf, that was a mistake because it encouraged sideways creep and not so much of a risen top. In fact, it deflated it.

    The light crunchy crust with the sweetness of the honey, along with the buttery "richness" gives the bread a pale yellow tint, but it works surprisingly well on it's own, with sweet topping, and I've even tried it with a salty topping like Vegemite (I'm am an Aussie afterall). So salted meats should pose no issue either.

    Curiously, this is an ostensibly British bread that was extremely common a few decades ago, but it has largely disappeared from commercial bakeries there. Honestly, that's a shame, it's a nice bread, easy to make, and is right up there with Pan De Mie, which is still popular in France.

    Techniques For Wood-Fired Ovens by A. Cort Sinnes

    Techniques For Wood-Fired Ovens by A. Cort Sinnes

    This book is a little unusual in that it's aimed at wood-fired ovens instead of a particular food type. It honestly has one foot in the barbecue scene, and one foot in the baking category.

    Since this has a couple of bread types and a few pizza recipes in the mix, it does have a place here.

    A small hardcover, with lots of pictures, it makes a good little present for the lidded/oven style barbecue enthusiast, pizza nutters, and of course, those who'd appreciate a little bread baking thrown in for good measure.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Wood fired oven food stuffs, that includes pizzas, calzones, pretzels, and bread... then goes into the barbecue side of roasts, steaks and other babecue treats.

    Total page count: 128

    No. of pages before recipes: 23 (although the theory section is exclusively about using a wood fired oven).

    Metric/imperial units? Largely metric (with volume amounts as backup). Temperatures in both Fahrenheit and Celsius.

    Number of recipes: 5 bread/pizza/calzone recipes, 20 more meals fit for a barbecue/oven.

    Photos for every recipe? Yes! (and extras along the method way at times)

    Price range (new): $12-$22 (AUD) typical hard cover.

    Price range (used): $8.64-$34 (not including postage).

    Notable Features & FYI:

    It's a small book of just 25 recipes, each aimed at teaching a wood fired oven user a new skill set... or to show what an outdoor oven could do. Given the 128 page count and 25 recipes, it means each recipe gets 4 pages each! 

    As a bread making book, there are 3 different pizza/calzone recipes, a pretzel recipe and a bread recipe to finish the section. However, that's on par with some other bread books in this list, hence it's place here. 

    There are three other sections, "fish and poultry", "meats", and "sides and veggies". So it's actually quite well rounded. Perhaps most notable, is that they're all meals that people in my household would willingly eat. That's a lot more rare than you might imagine. I'm less enthused with the quail because they're just not worth the trouble/expense in my view, but the recipe would easily transfer over to other poultry pretty easily. So I don't call that a loss. Interestingly, most of the non-bread recipes pair well with the "basic loaf bread"... which I've made in to a series of odd-ball sized bread rolls...

    Basic loaf bread, but made into rolls instead

    Ham's first attempt at "Basic Loaf Bread" (Pic: Ren)

    When they say basic, that means no preferments at all, no sourdough, or even a vaguely "levained for flavour" step whatsoever. However, that said, it highly resembles most simpler/denser baguettes in terms of recipe, texture and flavour.

    Unfortunately, the weather was not conducive to use the Kamado (my form of wood fired oven) so I simply did this in the conventional wall oven in our kitchen.

    I enjoyed it, and the recipe had no issues whatsoever!

    Yes, I finally made some rolls, even if Ren erroneously thinks they're "big".... ;~p

    Knead Peace -by Andrew Green

    Knead Peace - by Andrew Green

    Make no mistake, this is just a collection of recipes provided by a number of professionals, chefs, bakers, and editors across multiple countries.

    While this book is the unfortunate byproduct of the conflict in the Ukraine, this is actually quite a nice little book for both bread making and baked treats. In fact, the first section of the book is bread recipes and the latter parts, sweeter breads/cakes/tarts/pastries/cookies..... you get the idea.

    Now, I'm not going to allow the political/charity side of this book sway my review here. Any criticisms or compliments are purely from a bread baking perspective, nothing more.

    The recipes look interesting, and some of the combinations of ingredients aren't exactly commonly used here in Australia, (except the ANZAC biscuits of course) and the photos are very well done. That said, I'd have personally liked more recipes to have photos, so I know what the finished products look like. While the people behind the recipes are interesting, and yes there's the political side to this book... there are a number of "filler" shots that are neither helpful to the baker, nor making any particular coherent political statements. I guess it makes it more pretty than plain ol' text at least :-)

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: General baking recipe book, not limited to bread, but includes cakes, tarts, biscuits, etc too!

    Total page count: 192

    No. of pages before recipes: 11. Normally, this is an indicator of a theory section. However, since this is a compendium of various baking recipes from multiple sources, this isn't really as helpful as it might be for other books in this list.

    Metric/imperial units? Mostly metric weights with the occasional volume such as tsp/tbs/cup thrown in. Temperatures are in both imperial/metric. However, some recipes (pages 72 and 84 come to mind) have a small error. The Celsius and Fahrenheit are written like this:

    "160C (325C)"

    Yes, that second "C" should be an "F"! (in the book, this was just an example of the typo) So make sure you're reading the correct numbers!

    Number of recipes: Total 65 recipes: 17 bread recipes, 8 "savory bakes", 9 "sweet doughs", 17 "cakes", 8 "cookies/biscuits", 6 "pies & tarts" (which are sweet pies and desserts, not meat pies which are more savoury in nature).

    Photos for every recipe? 21 recipes are completely without images. So 67.7% do have images. That said, of the recipes with images, many have small images that are indicative but not detailed. Meanwhile others get full page images. There's no rhyme or reason to it, so make of it what you will.

    Price range (new): .$11-65 (AUD) typical hard cover. $18.20-$26.30 (AUD) e-Book

    Price range (used): N/A (none found)

    Notable Features & FYI:

    Any rural-dwelling Australian could tell you about the collaborative recipe books made by the "Country Women's Association". There have literally been whole volumes of them made over the last 100+ years or so, sold to fund numerous initiatives. This book works in the same way, only a bunch of professional/celebrity bakers have donated their recipes/images and Andrew Green has created this book so that some of the proceeds can go to non-military causes aimed at helping the people of war-torn Ukraine.

    That said, this book's "recipe contributors" is a veritable "who's who" of the bread baking world. Richard Bertinet (of Dough/Crust/Crumb, reviewed above), Kevin Hart who was head baker at Tartine (reviewed above) who went on to write his own books and run his own bakery. He's quite famous for his book "Kevin Hart: Bread" (one I haven't reviewed, but read parts of some years ago). Ben Lippett, a celebrity chef in the UK, Dee Rettali (of Fortitude Bakery, and "Baking with Fortitude" authorhood fame).

    If they aren't a celebrity chef, popular YouTuber, or the editor of the book, they teach in culinary institutes, run a renowned bakery, and/or written a respected book in the field....probably after learning the craft in another renowned bakery or two. You get the idea.

    Ham's first attempt at "Olive bread rolls".... Let's see how this one goes:

    Olive bread rolls (in loaf form)

    Ham's first attempt at "olive oil bread rolls" ...albeit in loaf form... (Pics: Ren)

    You'd think, that a dough so enriched with olive oil, that it wouldn't stick to a non-stick surface like a silicone loaf pan. But you'd be wrong. (See the torn off side in the bottom-right image). Like any enriched dough, this is very, very soft. However, the olive flavour, while present isn't overwhelming at all, and it does go remarkably well with mild sopressa, which given that it's a Mediterranean bread type and salami type, is completely unsurprising. If you like a good oil-coated ciabatta, focaccia, or olives on your pizza, this is a very nice choice.

    Making it could not be easier, although life got a lot easier when I coated my hands in a little extra olive oil. Shaping the loaf was easy, but I recommend doing so in a large and lightly oiled mixing bowl.

    Honestly, this recipe is meant to be made into bread rolls, and I think it's well suited to that, the loaf pan wasn't the ideal choice. Just use some baking paper underneath to prevent sticking. The egg wash makes a significant difference to the crust, so it's worth doing, and gives an impressively glossy coat (when combined with the oil already in the dough). I baked it a bit darker than ideal because the loaf pan slowed the bake in the lower parts a bit.

    Alll in all, a good recipe, that will work as advertised.

    Professional Baking (7th Edition) by Wayne Gisslen

    Professional Baking (7th Edition) by Wayne Gisslen

    This is one of the most common text books used for teaching students professional baking in Australia.

    When Aussie students start a baking apprenticeship, with the training through local TAFEs (technical colleges), at least half of those campuses have this text book (or newer versions) in their reading lists.

    Even though the latest 8th edition was released back in 2021, this 2017 vintage, 804 page, 7th edition was my very fortunate $6 find at a local book fair. Because the 8th edition sells for over $220 Australian, and has a whopping 12 extra pages over this 7th edition. Not a bad purchase, huh!

    Never underestimate an older-edition text book. Ok, it would be an issue if you're doing the course, (the ability to follow along with the class) but for hobbyists, a 97.3% reduction in price (admittedly second hand), for over 98.4% of the content... It's a no brainer!

    That said, Amazon charges more for this older edition than the new one... Why? I couldn't tell you.

    That said, bread making is only part of this book, so it's much like "Advanced Bread & Pastry", this is a general, albeit professional level baking book.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Official textbook for professional baking courses, including boulangerie (mostly bread focus), viennoiserie (hybrid bread/pastries), and pâtisserie (mostly pastries/cakes). In short, it's a wholesale "baking" textbook. 

    Total page count: 791 (804 with padding at either end)

    No. of pages before recipes: 125 (not all of it specifically related to bread but is excellent and in-depth nonetheless.

    Metric/imperial units? Both, with some volume measurements as a backup. Temperature is in both Celsius and Fahrenheit.

    Number of recipes: Please know that I'm just counting the actual bread recipes here.

    Bread Only: 117 bread recipes! (but that's just a tiny fraction of this book).

    31 "Straight dough" bread recipes, 24 prefermented/sponges/sourdough recipes, 34 "rich yeast doughs" (and variants involving diffferent fillings), 28 "quick breads" (I've excluded biscuits and cakes, tarts, and most pastry stuff).

    Could you use the pastry recipes in bread making?

    Of course you could. Although, the day someone decorates a bread loaf the way most extreme cake decorations go, I have to ask:

    Is it really bread anymore?

    So how many recipes are actually in this book? Ok, you talked me into it (or my happy online proof readers did on your behalf).

    Lots. There's over 70 different sauces/fillings for your delectable sweet treat of choice. There are sections bigger than most books here, on just the pies and tarts. So let's do a bit of a rough calculation here:

    Warning: Maths ahead (don't worry, I've done it for you)

    Since the recipe index spans 9.1 pages, each page has 3 columns of entries, and each column up to 65 lines. That puts the total at 1600+ However, many of these recipes are for making the fillings, the bases, and the toppings for a variety of desserts that will ultimately go into the master recipes of cakes, pastries, etc. Breads seldom need all this.

    Photos for every recipe? No. Some do, but with huge amounts of theory, and insane numbers of recipes, there simply isn't the space to give every recipe a photo.

    Price range (new): $210-$255 (AUD) typical hard cover.

    Price range (used): $6-$220 (not including postage).

    Notable Features & FYI: After some considerable thought, I feel that "Professional Baking, 7th Edition" is aimed more at people just starting their training. So it actually suits the beginner in many ways. Once you've done this one, feel free to advance to "Advanced Bread and Pastry", because that's a bit more technical/scientific and this is more practical/vocational. That said, it is one of the textbooks for the Australian Certificate II/Certificate III Bakery courses.

    There's nothing hard in this book, but it's a text book and it covers a lot of ground. Yes, there's some science in here, but only in so far that it helps you bake a better product. There's far fewer graphs in this book than "Advanced Bread and Pastry", and more recipes. It is, afterall, teaching bakers how to bake a professional-grade repertoire of delicious and well presented foods after all.

    Are you a cheese maker that's starting your bread making journey (or vice versa)? Fermented foods share a hefty degree of common ground...

    If you're coming to this from the cheese making side, there's a lot of similarity between this book and some of the more advanced industrial cheese making books, such as "Dairy Science and Technology", most notably because the dairy product makers have to consider the manufacture, storage, transportation and use of their products. Since the professional baker uses many dairy products as ingredients and has overlapping interests/concerns, much of the same food safety, preparation, and presentation have to be considered.

    Of course, if you're a baker dabbling in the cheese making side, this has some overlap too.

    Baking with this book... it's an interesting experience

    Here's the first recipe Ren chose for me to make.... (I think she chose it because it involves malt syrup).

    Alt Text

    Why include this recipe? Don't you just take pics of the finished bread?

    This is not normal, (even for this book), but have a look at the method section. It literally has no instructions inside this recipe, so I feel that it was ok to share without breaching copyright. I'm merely sharing an odd-ball recipe whose method section runs entirely off references in other sections of the book.

    (To the authors/publishers and their respective legal teams, I'm trying to promote the strengths of this bread so please bear with me).

    The sponge method was exactly as any poolish would work, and the section was exceptionally detailed. It's something I know well. However, the recipe assumes you're time poor and want a finished poolish stat! (or in 2 hours). I made mine according to the recipe, but I definitely should have adjusted it according to the table on page 158 (only 157 was mentioned) and so I gave the poolish either too much yeast, or ran it too long. You have to be careful, this isn't a recipe book, it's a text book that assumes you're familiar with all the content up to that point.

    That table, well it's now noted down because adjusting the yeast quanitity to your time line and temperature, that's a handy ability to have.

    What about the tables on page 122?

    The detailed section on mixing methods, actually starts on page 118 and finishes with the main tables that summarize most of that information. It's a bit like "choose your own adventure" and it even tells you what compromises each style of mixing involves.

    Now, my stand mixer is not a professional model in the strictest sense. I don't think mine is anywhere near the size/power a culinary institute or professional bakery would use. So the speed of my mixer seemed to be a bit different, and needs a different amount of time for each stage of mixing. So that's going to need a bit of experimentation to "dial in".

    Ham's first attempt at French Bread (Sponge) or

    Ham's first attempt at French Bread (Sponge) or "Poolish French Bread"

    Ok, I see this as a homage to baguette... Picasso style. This is not one of my most photogenic bakes, but that's not to say that it isn't a functional piece of bread... admittedly needing some of that flour brushed off.

    This was a highly experimental bake, that's for sure. So we're in the depths of winter, and we'd had some nice days, but the house got a bit cooler than anticipated. So I had to extend the bulk fermentation and proof accordingly. However, I'd already added a higher-than-needed amount of yeast to my Poolish and ran it longer than anticipated when I was tending to some unexpected events.

    The best laid plans...and all that.

    Furthermore, I ran the stand mixer according to their specs, but I think I actually overworked the dough (even on the slowest setting). I don't think their stand mixer and mine operate at the same speeds.

    Ultimately, I had a very wet, very sticky and difficult to handle dough. Sure it expanded, but it expanded outward rather than upward. My attempts to slice the bread with a lame failed due to the lack of structure. So when I baked it, it cracked rather than expanded from any seams I had cut into the dough.

    Also, I tend to prefer my crusts baked a bit darker than the golden hue depicted. I'm sure it would have been great for rolls, but I made larger doughs and I want to ensure it baked all the way through. When it was golden, I didn't get that hollow sound when tapping the base, so I cooked it some more.

    Sliced

    A tight crumb, and the flavour wasn't quite as strong as I was hoping...

    So this didn't quite go to plan. However, it wasn't a complete failure either. Honestly, I hadn't fully familiarized myself with the whole process and other household events prevented my usual prep procedure from completing.

    After making the process part of the way, I was forced to delay the next steps. Ultimately this didn't help and the dough became very difficult to handle. I think the problem stemmed from three issues:

    1. I think I over-mixed the dough.
    2. Yeast was too much for such a long proof.
    3. Temperature variation was cool, but perhaps not cool enough to retard to fermentation process an appropriate amount.

    This taught me that the text book recipes are more of a "do this precisely, in controlled environments"...which I just didn't. Partly because I didn't have the means to keep this much dough proofed for long periods of time, and my fridge space was limited. I'm sure it would have worked in a pro bakery. It's for this reason I will probably delay making more recipes from this book until winter is behind us or I have the means to do more comprehensive environmental control. We have trades folk working on our extension, the doors are often wide open as people trudge back and forth.. so yeah.. not ideal circumstances. I'm not pointing fingers, I chose to make bread like this... and I'm not blaming the recipe, or the book.

    Advanced Bread Baking at Home by Daniele Brenci

    Advanced Bread Baking at Home by Daniele Brenci

    This is a somewhat advanced bread/sourdough/pizza/pastry book. That said, it's reasonably beginner friendly to those who have some baking experience.

    The recipe range does incorporate a few tweaks and addendums that go "beyond basics" on a regular basis.... even so, it's a book centred on sourdough with a slightly more Italian bread and pizza centric focus. Why? Because the author is Italian of course.

    Difficulty-wise, it's on par with "Flour Water Salt Yeast" and "Bread Baker's Apprentice", but the recipe layout isn't what I'd call ideal. When it says "purple sweet potato"... no species are recommended. That made it harder for this Aussie.

    The other notable bit about this book is the discussions on classic and ancient grains, then the structure is summarized by some specialty bread recipes, enriched breads, rye/pan loaves, pizza/foccacia, and finishes up with some pastries.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Breads, pizzas, and pastries. Some emphasis on the use of ancient/heirloom/unusual grains and flours, milling flour at home, and some "Tips and techniques" along the way to make improvements over more basic breads, but we're not going that far off the beginner reservation.

    Total page count: 176 (although some sites list 192.... I don't know why).

    No. of pages before recipes: 39 of introductory theory, equipment, grains/flours, general techniques etc.

    Metric/imperial units? Largely metric (with volume amounts as backup). Temperatures in both Fahrenheit and Celsius.

    Number of recipes: 10 breads involving ancient/classic grains, 7 specialty breads, 6 enriched breads, 6 rye breads/pan loaves, 8 pizza/focaccia recipes (with some sundries in there like tomato sauces, and of course, the pizza/focaccia doughs, and 6 pastries. Total recipe count is about 45.

    Photos for every recipe? Yes! (and extras along the method way at times)

    Price range (new): $32-$49.81 (AUD) typical hard cover. $19.36 for e-book.

    Price range (used):$16-31 (AUD) typical hard cover

    Notable Features & FYI: Daniele used to have a web site called https://breadcrumb.recipes however, that site seems to have died. That said, he does (at the time of writing in 2026) have a working Instagram account/site/blog thing found at:

    https://www.instagram.com/_breadcrumb/?hl=en

    This is one of the many bread books written during the Covid pandemic in 2020. However, Daniele is a professional chef, and honestly, it shows in the fact that it gets to the point, and is fundamentally, more of a recipe book than text book.

    However, what drew me to this book was the fact that the breads are so photogenic. As soon as I saw the marbled purple sweet potato sourdough, I knew three things:

    1. Ren's obsession with sweet potato would push me into making it sooner, rather than later.
    2. Purple is Ren's favourite colour, increasing my pressure to make it.
    3. Ren's desire to photograph pretty food images certainly doesn't hurt this site at all..

    Of course, getting a purple sweet potato, not one with a purple skin, but a purple flesh, was not going to be easy. Simply going to the supermarket was not going to work here.

    So I made a special trip to the local fruit market specifically for this ingredient. Whether it has purple flesh... we don't know so stay tuned for that event!

    I'm going to put a less risky recipe first, while talking about what I consider the best strength of this book.

    There are plenty of bread books that discuss how one variety of wheat (or other grain) grows differently to another. Einkorn means "one grain", which is an heirloom (ancient) version of modern wheat. However, it actually covers both a wild wheat species and the domesticated version. I've read this in several books. However, what is the difference between Einkorn, Emmer, Kamut (or Khorasan), Spelt, and/or Rye...when making bread?

    Now Rye's effect on dough and the resulting bread is covered quite clearly in several books, but Khorasan Vs. Emmer Vs. Einkorn... not so much. Now I want to be clear, direct comparisons aren't made, but if you read through each of the recipes that specialise in a variety of grain, you'll get a very good idea of how they each work and the differences between them.

    What I really like about "Advanced Bread Baking at Home", is that it tells me that different grains need different handling. You can't simply swap one grain out for another and expect the bread to behave similarly or even taste the same. That's a strength, not a weakness. It doesn't overwhelm you with details, just that you mix a bit of an heirloom variety of flour in a suitable proportion with everyday "bread flour" and it willl provide several advantages while mitigating the drawbacks. In fact, here's a small excerpt of the discussion of Khorasan:

    “Compared to other wheat, khorasan develops a dough with a unique smooth texture and transforms the final bake by developing an intense nutty and buttery flavor. This unique grain is able to elevate your bread even when used in small percentages and is a fun one to work with. The high protein content in khorasan wheat allows the dough to absorb a high percentage of water. In this recipe, I wanted to highlight the deep flavor and texture that this grain develops. With that in mind, I used a total of 50% khorasan flour, which gives the bread a golden crust as well as a unique dark brown and extremely moist and chewy crumb.”

    One paragraph, which is packed with good information, and suggests further use/adaptation once you've made the recipe.

    I really like that in the ancient grain recipe section, each recipe is tailored to a specific heritage grain, and this is hugely helpful in showing what the differences between each grain are like, and how to use them. If you're looking for that particular guidance, then I'm hard-pressed to think of a better book than this one without it going into a lot of details.

    Conclusion:

    Now this isn't about using home-milled flour (although you could absolutely do that), but it is certainly more aimed at using various flours along with some more involved techniques to elevate the bread beyond the mere basics.

    That said, I'd definitely encourage a firm adherence to the recipes until you've gotten used to how they work, and then tweak to suit your preferences. If you suffer from compulsive deviation from the recipe on the first attempts... this book is not for you.

    Similarly, if you don't live in Europe, there's definitely some recipes that I frankly believe are next to impossible to do without access to the right ingredients.... as I found out. So keep this in mind. Most recipes are fairly achievable, but there are some that won't be so convenient/accessible.

    Overall I really like what this book brings to my bread library, and it's one of the first books I go to when I want to re-familiarise myself with a particular grain without the trouble of milling it myself.

    Alt Text

    Ham's first go at Khorasan & Wheat Sourdough Bread

    After days and weeks of searching for a suitable purple sweet potato, the odds of finding one here.... Well, it frankly wasn't looking too good here in the depths of Australian winter. We simply don't grow much in the way of purple spuds. Showing a recipe with a low probability of success isn't exactly fair to this book if it's the only recipe I demonstrate here. So Khorasan was chosen as the backup.

    Khorasan is actually relatively easy to get, but it won't be found in supermarkets here in Australia. I had to order some from my old friends at Basic Ingredients. They were much cheaper than some of the health-food shops here, even with shipping.

    This uses a sourdough starter to kick off a preferment (although I'm fairly confident you could just use more existing starter as an already-established preferment if you're short on time. However, a slower approach is rewarded with superior flavours.

    Khorasan (also known as Kamut) is very different to wheat, and to me, the most notable distinction is the nutty aroma. The book was definitely correct on that one, but there's a difference between simply reading about it and that first serious whiff of that nutty goodness.

    How was the make 'n' bake?

    This recipe rewards strict adherence to the instructions. Now you know I'm not the best when it comes to resisting the urge to adapt/tinker. This one isn't one I'd make any heavy-handed changes to. When they say mix for 6-8 minutes, I did 6, but with a view to adding another minute or two to work the salt in... even if I did it at a higher speed (not much higher though) in my cooler-than-average kitchen environment.

    That said, I made two pairs of loaves, one set in the bannetons I have, and the others were proofed in my mixer bowls (because I ran out of bannetons). The banneton ones (shown here) came out a bit taller, and cleaner (I had to liberally flour the mixing bowls to prevent sticking). However, other than having more flour and a bit of deflation, the mixer bowl loaves came out only about 10% smaller than the banneton boules.

    Baking this bread... is one of those things that I strongly encourage you to follow to the letter. Daniele really has configured the three tiered baking process down to the minute for this particular shaped/sized loaf. You mess with that much and you will find that it won't properly bake. Either by leaving the inside undercooked, or the outside burned... unless you're masterful at adapting time/temps "on the fly".

    If you stick the instructions, this bake really does work well and will teach you quite a lot about using Khorasan/Kamut in future bakes.

    Purple sweet potato sourdough

    Purple Sweet Potato Sourdough (It didn't go well)

    There was no question. As soon as I saw this recipe, I knew Ren would want me to try it. Buying a purple sweet potato in Australia is much harder than in other parts of the world. According to the Australian Sweet Potato industry, over 90% of all sweet spuds are a golden variety with orange flesh. 8% are the "red skinned with white flesh", leaving less than 2% for the all white varieties (extremely rare here) and the white skinned with purple flesh to fight for the rest.

    Ironically, here in Australia, purple-skinned sweet potatoes often have white or cream coloured flesh. Conversely, there's white skinned sweet potatoes that have purple flesh. (often described as "WSPF" because White Skin Purple Flesh is too long).

    Another name for it is "Eclipse" because the flesh has a densely purple ring inside (like a full solar eclipse I guess), that goes rapidly white toward the skin, and drifts into lighter shades of purple toward the middle.

    The deepest purple bits were much harder even after extending the steaming time. The lighter bits went soft with no issue. So I overcooked it and still have hard chunky purple bits in my bread dough.

    Personally, I recommend steaming the potatoes, then blending it to a smooth paste before adding it into the dough. However, I suspect the chunks might be interesting.

    Oddly, I made both the white dough and purple dough separated (as instructed) using the same ingredients, and the purple one stiffened up into a dough quite nicely, while the pure dough one.. stayed a very slack/runny dough-bordering-on-batter.

    Same temperatures, both stuck in the fridge at the same temperature... I don't know what's going on there.

    However, I basically consider this bread a failure. I tried to make it with the ingredients that were available, but they weren't suitable for the task. The true Italian purple sweet potatoes, specifically "Viola di Napoli" or "Tonda di Napoli" are most likely the species you need for this recipe. From my online research, the "Murasaki" or "Japanese" purple sweet potato is closer to the variety that failed here. Admittedly, I have no direct experience, nor any experts in the "Convolvulacea" (sweet spud family) field to contact....

    All I know is that normal spuds are not in the same family at all, being part of the "Solanaceae" family which features spuds, tomatoes, aubergines, and capsicums (peppers). I'm a normal spud nutter, whereas Ren is more sweet spud oriented. What can you learn from this useless fact? Answer: Ren is wrong. ;~) Why yes, I will take the side of trouble with my unnecessary anecdotes. It keeps the relationship interesting!

    Big Book of Bread - King Arthur Flour

    Big Book of Bread by The King Arthur Flour Baking Company

    This is a very popular bread book for many American hobbyists, and I can see why. Obviously, King Arthur Flour is an American flour supplier, but the recipes would work with comparable flours found across the globe.

    The theory section is particularly well laid out, discussing each bread making step in order, outlining what each step does, and why anyone would do it, and some of the "general guidelines" that might trip the unwitting baker up if they have an exceptional ingredient or circumstance. That's something few books on this page do well. Additionally, "The Big Book of Bread" has a lot of illustrations in the theory section so even the 98-odd pages of theory is much easier to read than expected. I found myself on page 78 before I had realised that I'd read so far.

    The range of recipes (125+ of them) is pretty diverse, but I have to ask "Why can't they give us a precise number?".

    This is a work in progres, so please check back soon! I just need to eat the bread I've already made, then I'll bake something from this one and I'll get back to you.


    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: A reasonably diverse range of breads, aimed at making newbie bread bakers, but it certainly wouldn't be wasted on more experienced home bread makers either.

    Total page count: 464 (physical copy) 399 (Kindle)

    No. of pages before recipes: 98 (on my e-book edition)

    Metric/imperial units? Metric weights (grams), but imperial volumes (cups, tablespoons/teaspoons) for backup. Oddly, temperatures are only in Fahrenheit. Meanwhile, lengths and diameters of pans are entirely in inches. Make of this... what you will.

    Number of recipes: Ummm, I count 124 in my ebook version, not the "125+" claimed on the cover. I've gone through the book three times and I keep getting the same count. Maybe they've included some recipe variations in there... a couple of recipes do have them. There's a recipe on how to make home made ghee in the Naan section, and the cracker version of the Gateâu Voyage Bread that's actually been converted into crackers instead.... The "loaded baked potato bread" and ciabatta also has both loaf and roll variations. The Baguettes have a yeast and levain version, maybe that's the difference.

    Let me break that down....

    21 flatbreads, 23 pan breads, 21 hearth breads, 21 "buns, bagels & rolls", 15 fancy breads (which includes a cake or two?) 23 "things you can make with bread".

    Photos for every recipe? The candied citrus peel doesn't, but the rest do. Not all of them are full page images on the opposite page as some might expect. (Although that's the overwhelming majority of them). For the "Swirl Breads", four separate versions are depiced in one image, in the middle of the swirl bread recipes. A similar layout is in the Pan De Cristal section. The Challah and Brioche sections are a bit different again. The dough recipe doesn't have a picture, but the variation you make with it, do.

    Price range (new): ebook $25-31.66 (AUD), hard cover $38.95-$71.58 (AUD), spiral bound $65.97 on Amazon.

    Price range (used): $34.90-$54.70 (delivered, but this greatly depends on location and condition of the book)

    Notable Features & FYI: Few people reviewing a book, will start with the back of the book. However, sometimes working backwards is a huge help.

    After all the recipes in the book, is a rather useful "Flour Primer". Normally, such discussions/topics would be somewhere late-ish in the introductory theory section. I don't know why they put it "up the back".

    appendices, but they are quite notable in that you can choose a recipe for your given situation:

    Appendix A arranges all the bread recipes by time taken to make. The categories are 1-3 hours, 3-5 hours, 5-6 hours, two-day breads, and three day breads.

    Appendix B arranges the recipe by the degree of leavening or whether they're yeast-based.

    In the recipes, there's handy descriptions of recipe-specific procedures.... like braiding a 4 strand Challah, or how to customise your concha cookie topping, or even step-by-step photos on how to shape rose flower-like doughs for "Olive and Feta Poğaça" (I still have no ideal how to pronounce that last word). There's literally gems of tips and techniques throughout the recipe section, and I have to say that I like it. The section on "Understanding Rye" under the "Tourte Au Seigle" recipe, has key information about why lowering the pH (adding acidity) to the rye dough helps to prevent Amylase enzymes from leaving your bread with a gummy unpleasant texture. I've dealt with Rye in some differing ways (like using a hybrid wheat/rye mix) so that's a new tool at my disposal.

    I like the "storing bread" advice in the loaf pan section of the recipe area. It's practical, and definitely will save people both time and money by avoiding spoilage. As someone who's been baking a while, I won't say it's saying anything new to me... but it'd definitely help new bakers.

    In select parts of recipe area, as well as the sections preceding the recipe (the theory section) there are QR codes that link to videos should the description/imagery not be enough. Other books in this list like the Sourdough Framework, and "The Perfect Loaf" (when I add that one) have YouTube channels that augment their books in similar ways to this one, but it's nice to have the option. This is a huge boon to new bakers.

    Take the blurb/description of this book with a "grain of salt"....

    I've read a lot of books, and one of the things that immediately makes me suspicious, skeptical, if not outright distrusting are bold sweeping claims involving words like "best" or "most". I always ask "best in what way?" and "is it really the most?". Because if the claims are in any way false, the credibility of the publisher/marketer/author (perhaps all three, and by association my faith in the book) takes a major hit. That said, if it were proven as fact in some reasonable way... I'd be impressed.

    I found this statement on several sites selling this book (Including Amazon, and several Australian sellers)

    "At the heart of The King Arthur Baking Company Big Book of Bread is the most expansive and inclusive [recipe] list of any bread-baking book..."

    Is it diverse? Sure! Is it an impressive list of breads? Absolutely! Would I bake most of these recipes willingly? Why not? (because I probably have already).

    However, "... most expansive and inclusive recipe list of any bread book?......" I can name several bread books (from this page alone) with more recipes. I can also name scores of bread recipes (even whole countries with cuisines and bread contributions of their own) from the Middle-East, Asia, Australia and many others that aren't "included" in this list. I'm sure it's inclusive from an American perspective, but there's lots of room for improvement. However, doing this would make the book intimidating, not to mention more expensive... and it's better to run a few good recipes than try to cover all the oddball varieties and do a bad job.

    I don't besmirch this book at all, just any unfounded claims that might falsely raise expectations.

    Is the range of recipes a good general overview of popular breads from major bread centres across the globe? No question, but it's far from the most... anything really. If I were forced to state what it's best used for, I would say it's one of the most well thought-out ranges of recipes that would appeal to a western-style palate, with just enough breads from India/Turkey/Bolivia, etc to "dip your toe in". Don't get me wrong, that has a lot of appeal... and it's a great book. The most expansive and/or inclusive.... it's a very bold claim that I just don't think holds up to scrutiny.

    Conclusion:

    So ignore the blurb, and you'll be absolutely fine with this book. In fact, I really have no problem recommending it. It even has a very nice recipe-to-price ratio, and every recipe of consequence has a photo showing what it looks like. Very few books do this at this price point and number of recipes. It's also extremely nice to have step-by-step photos, then add videos and practical addendums with the thought and care the people behind this book have clearly put in. It's just really odd that they don't have Celsius temperatures, or imperial weights, or metric lengths/diameters... If they did that this book would be nigh-on perfect at what it does... it's just.... there's a few repetitive, and counter-intuitive quirks here and there.

    All in all, this book does deserve the high praise it gets world wide. Beginner or established bread bakers would benefit from this book.

    Ham's first attempt at one of the recipes...

    Ham's first attempt at Babka

    Ham's first attempt at Babka... (Photo: Ren)

    Babka (according to this book) originates from the Jewish communities of Poland/Western Ukraine. Somewhat "richer and sweeter than Challah, but less rich than Brioche". Traditionally, it was a simpler bread but it's evolved in recent years to be fancier, richer, and more decadent. Hence it's position as the first "fancy bread" in the book.

    It has been a little while since I made a fruit toast for Ren, so I changed the filling somewhat... so much so, that I think it could give Brioche a "run for it's money" in the richness stakes.

    I didn't have the ingredients on hand to make the chocolate version, or the nuts of some of the other versions. So I took Richard Bertinet's cinnamon, butter, and brown sugar filling for his knotted cinnamon rolls, and added minced dried fruit (cranberries, sultanas, raisins, dried orange peel) to it. I then blended it in a blender to save dicing and evenly mix the filling.

    That's a lot of sugar, cinnamon, and dried fruit, all of which combine nicely to make a particularly sweet "fruit mince pie-ish" filling. The down side was that it's extremely easy for the filling to overflow from the expanding dough to overcook on the top. So I had to cover the tops in foil halfway through the bake...

    But wait, there's more!

    I took the syrup recipe from the Baklava Babka recipe involving honey, lemon juice and vanilla paste, made it and drowned (well, repeatedly basted) the loaf in syrup after baking.

    So perhaps this loaf should be titled:

    Ham's Cinnamon Sugar Fruit Mince Baklava-Babka... Bordering On Brioche

    Let's be absolutely clear here, it's a coronary with a side of diabetes in loaf form, but to a sweet toothed individual like Ren, it is gooooood!

    Now, if you like fruit mince pies with cinnamon overtones, but don't like the usual tart/pie pastry.. this might be for you. The swirls of this Babka make it easy to use both in sliced form, and as a pull-apart tea cake/loaf.

    Honestly, I'm having a hard time selling it as bread, when it's this sweet and enriched.

    Any problems with the recipe/process?

    The recipe was very clear, and the procedure, aside from some unintentional squashing of my twisted dough getting it into the pan, the bake went very well for a first try, but I wish the temperatures were in metric as well as Fahrenheit.

    When they say "lightly floured surface", make it a consistent light layer, otherwise you will get some sticking. It's not impossible to fix, just something to keep an eye on and anticipate.

    The biggest problem? Trying not to over-indulge!

    Tea time with Ham's Babka

    A fancy bread truly needs a special event! (or not)

    Our event was... I successfully made some fancy bread. It's a bit meta/cyclical reasoning I suppose, but I'm pretty confident Ren doesn't see it as a problem. If it involves sweet treats and teas, the only thing it needs now is some fluffy animals to make it complete. The cats may oblige/indulge her. With dainty cups in the background, I don't have to tell you that Ren took the pic. <insert chuckle here>

    Honestly, it's easy to fall into a bread making rut, and it's moments like these that make me think:

    "Hey, I made that!".. and actually feel some sense of pride. Remember, I'm just a hobbyist that's had failures along the way to keep me humble... and perhaps self-critical. It's sometimes hard to see how far I've come... all these breads have come weeks, if not months and years apart... so the transition is subtle if you're living it. I hope you, dear reader appreaciates the progress you're making in your bread making journey.

    The Sourdough Baking Book by Miro Van Vreckem

    The Sourdough Baking Book by Miro Van Vreckem

    This book isn't as "Nordic bread" as I originally thought, and the recipe section is, "all over the map". From Ethiopian/Eritrean Injera, Turkish Simit, Italian Pannettone, Irish Birly and Belgian Kramiek, to Mexican Tortilla, Spanish Tapas bread, and of course, the more Norse Oerbloempje (that's Dutch for "primrose") , as well as the usual French and other western bread types.

    Honestly, you can tell he's diverging from the seedy/rustic Norse-styled breads. These are breads I'd actually make on a routine basis. Don't get me wrong, Norse stuff is fine and exceptionally healthy.. but I just don't want to eat it all the time.

    Miro is a Flemmish baker who founded "Elt Bakeri" in Norway. Which apparently was named "one of the best in the country in 2023" (although the claim has no reference whatsoever). Interestingly, Miro's book has photos taken by his father, Thierry who is an artist and photographer. Frankly, I wouldn't ever hold the employment of a photographer in the family to illustrate my bread baking goodness against him. ;~P

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: It's fundamentally a sourdough book, but it dabbles with pizza, cakes, puddings, brownies, muffins and cookies. Most of which use sourdough in some way or another.

    Total page count: 191 (193 if you include the full page photo of Miro looking like a flannel-wearing Norwegian lumberjack and the conversion table inside the back cover.. although the page count stops at 191).

    No. of pages before recipes: 46

    Metric/imperial units? Pure metric, all by weight. Imperial units and those without kitchen scales will be at a significant disadvantage with this book. A scale capable of being switched over to metric would solve any issue.

    Number of recipes: There's a total of 60 recipes. The break-down is as follows:

    11 basic breads, 9 "traditional" breads, 15 "sweet sourdoughs", 16 "International recipes" ( pizza, baguettes, ciabatta, tortilla, "Guinness bread", injera, etc), and 9 "deluxe breads".

    Photos for every recipe? Yes, full page colour photos (very pretty book overall)

    Price range (new): $59-83 AUD (hard cover delivered) No soft cover or e-book variant found.

    Price range (used): N/A (not found)

    Notable Features & FYI: Actually, I really like the overall layout of this book. The 46 pages of intro and bread theory is thoughtfully laid out, easy to read, quick to reference (you'd be surprised how often that's not the case), and to the point.

    If you're a passive reader (reads from start to finish) then you can read the entire intro section in an hour or two. Yet if you're an active reader (reads headings, scans first/last sentences of paragraphs, and like honing in on key names/facts/graphs/figures/tables and photographed procedures/ideas as needed... then you can halve that if not go even faster.

    Text size is good, the headings well spaced, and the images are actually very good, and often on opposite pages to the recipes. No unnecessary flipping, a firm "every recipe needs a photo" policy is clear, and the book is well presented enough to be a gift, coffee table book, or even encourage people to give a recipe a try, just by showing the pretty pictures in the book alone.

    The Sourdough Baking Book - Pros & Cons:

    This is a relatively new book (as of mid 2026) and as such hasn't got the attention that I honestly think it deserves, yet.

    That said... I think the strengths of this book are threefold:

    1. The recipes aren't just well rounded and diverse, the ones that I've tried are very forgiving and on the easier side to handle... even with a high-ish hydration sourdough mixed with honey. That said, a dripping wet hand, and suitably floured surfaces for handling/shaping are an absolute must.
    2. It's a selection of recipes that isn't insanely numerous, but I just don't think you'd miss much at all with this range.... if you like sourdough. That's not really negotiable with this book... obviously.
    3. No referencing other pages, interpreting tables/graphs, everything is at hand and clear.

    The weaknesses of this book come down to the following points:

    1. No yield indications for each recipe. I'm particularly concerned about the sourdough pizza dough, where the preferment alone is 600g (most full-sized loaves I make use of only 300g... the final dough weight is over four kilograms... which I'm then to divide into 270g balls comes out to just under fifteen pizzas. Most hobbyists would only need that much for major events or big social gatherings. It took two 7 quart (6.9L) mixing bowls to make this, and that's from Kitchen Aid's "professional" line of stand mixers. If you're using an "Artisan" series mixer, you'll need at least three bowls to cover it... It seems Miro approached it from the professional world, and forgot that most hobbyists aren't making pizza's in such large quantities. I haven't tried every recipe, but yeah, check the recipe before making it. 
    2. Ignoring the previous point, it's easy to underestimate this book as somewhat Bourgeosie or impractical just from appearances alone, given the artistic flair used in the layout of the book. Ok, the filters used on the cover image are a little heavy handed, but the images inside do the job very well, and the recipes are very good.
    3. No e-book or soft cover is available at the time of writing. So if you already have a book shelf, straining under the weight of your books, there aren't more compact/light-weight options.
    4. It's definitely not the cheapest book, but the recipes inside are numerous and diverse enough to offset that somewhat.

    Ham's malt-modified

    Ham's first attempt at a sourdough honey loaf... now with added malt!

    I really do like this book. The dough for this (and pizza dough recipe) was exactly as indicated, it firmed up as shown in the introductory kneading/folding/shaping sections, and it was an absolute joy to use. I've even had to adapt a little (more than just adding malt) because I actually ran out of my usual "bread flour" so I appended what I had with about 300g of Emmer flour.

    Adding the Emmer meant that the loaves didn't quite stretch as much as normal bread in the rise, but it did add a vaguely nutty flavour on top of the honey and somewhat tangy sourdough flavour.

    It's actually extremely pleasant, with a subtle sweetness and unmistakable honey flavour. However this has an almost sweet and sour or sweet and tangy contrast that would absolutely go well with a fresh cream cheese, quark, chabichou... and I think sandwich with a relish/chutney, a plain ham or chicken breast with some mayonnaise... because who doesn't like honey chicken or honey glazed ham? Perhaps turkey?... if that's your preference.

    Let's talk about that malt...

    I added 50g of powdered malt to this bread because I love a warm milk, malt and honey drink from my childhood. What I didn't expect was just how dark the bread would go. This brown goes all the way through the loaf. So much so, that it's hard to distinguish the crumb from the crust. Technically, yes, it's not part of this recipe but I really love having a bread that's not quite as sweet as a chocolate cake, but still gives that luscious malt/Milo-esque aroma, comforting carbs, all in a reasonably versatile foodstuff.

    Ham's sliced honey sourdough loaf

    Let's look inside the loaf...

    Wow it's amazing how much this loaf looks like chocolate cake to the... err... hopeful? eye. Fear not dear reader, it is a little sweet, it's a little tangy, it's.. particularly good with poached eggs! (Because that's what I had for breakfast).

    Naturally, the use of Emmer flour did tighten the crumb to a much more chocolate cake appearance. So it didn't rise as much as it would have with a more typical "bread flour". However, make no mistake, this loaf is still 15cm/6" high.

    The crust is quite soft, and springy... it doesn't crack... which makes it an excellent sandwich bread. Overall, I'm very happy with how this turned out. Not bad for a slightly (ok, significantly) modded first try!

    The Sourdough Baking Book - Sourdough Pizza

    Ham's first attempt of this book's sourdough pizza dough (Pic: Ren)

    Well, I made the dough as indicated.... all the dough. However, I used freshly ground wholemeal flour because I didn't have that much bread flour ok? Can I say that I have enough pizza to feed a horde of academics who'll descend upon free food like ants on a smashed jar of honey?

    Well anyway, after cooking two batches of dough on two successive days of barbecuing... let's just say I've tested this recipe extensively, and you really do get rewarded by extending the cold fermentation to the third day as instructed.

    That said..

    It's a good sourdough, and it works, it's noticeably tart with that sourdough tang. However, you do need to be selective in which topping you put on it. With bold flavours like barbecue sauce, smoked beef, and stronger cheeses, the sourdough adds depth and flavour, but plays a "support" role. If you went with a simpler prosciutto + basil, or magarita pizza then that sourdough plays a major role. So whether you should or would want to go through the three day process is really dependent on your end game.

    It's a true sourdough, and you can get some amazing results that are hard to get through faster means. Although, for quick meals.. where I'd be happy with 80% of the result....this isn't the solution and I'd probably cheat by using beer to get a sourdough effect in a fraction of the time.

    So really, this recipe is asking the reader:

    1. "How organized are you?"
    2. "Can you commit to such large quantities throughout the entire process?" (It takes more equipment, space and time than you'd think)
    3. What are you going to put onto this pizza that won't overshadow all the benefits of your hard work?

    It's a great recipe and it works... I just have to keep tinkering with my barbecuing technique. I tried the baking steel for the first time in the barbecue which does behave quite differently... (Translation, the steel got to 375 Celsius (707F) instead of the intended 275C/527F due to the radiant energy combining with the usual convective heat of an overn.

    It tastes great, even if it's not as visually toasted as it would ideally look like, but it is cooked. Six seconds on the steel made sure of that... then the rest was baked on a cooling rack on top of it to stop burning.

    Fresh milled flour bread book by Ti Guiffi

    Fresh-Milled Flour Bread Book by Tim Guiffi

    Tim, a stay-at-home dad, runs a bakery out of his private home about 10Km (6 mi) west of central Chicago... and learned the craft from social media and a lot of experimentation. To say that he's the more professional version of a home bread baker is literally the case. So his book is written by a home baker, for home bakers. 

    Like "Flour Lab", and several other books (to varying degrees) this book focuses on using home grain mills to up one's bread game to the next level.

    However, unlike the other books, this book speaks of the various grains with a passion, dare I say, poetry that other evangelistic flour books simply... don't. Case in point:

    “If bread making is an art, then grains make up the artist’s palette. The flavors, colors and textures are so varied, and the combinations are endless. You can take some typical whole wheat, say Red Fife, mill it up nice and fine and make a bold, nutty loaf of bread. But swap out some of that flour for freshly-milled rye and you’ll end up with a completely different loaf of bread. The loaf will vary in color, texture and flavor just by changing a little bit of the flour.”

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Using differing grains to make bread, while encouraging but not limited to, milling grains at home. So if you don't own an overpriced Mockmill (or something similar), you can buy premade specialist flours and that'd work pretty well... Provided you can find suppliers of course.

    Total page count: 144 pages.

    No. of pages before recipes: 12 pages of intro.

    Metric/imperial units? Metric weights (grams) and both Metric & Imperial temperatures are included. Rare for a U.S. authored book.

    Number of recipes: 43 actual dough-based recipes, over 50 if you include all the variations, toppings etc.

    10 in "Grain Forward", 7 in "Wonders of Corn", 11 in "Fresh flour and friends", 8 in "Flat breads, Pizza & More" (not including topping variations) and finally, 7 in "Lofty goals" (ignoring croissant variations).

    Photos for every recipe? Yes! Even QR codes for videos on how to do preshping, shaping, basic folding, coating doughs, and other key techniques, specific to that recipe in question.

    Price range (new): $37-$45 Australian for a soft cover (no hard cover variants found)

    E-book - $16-$25.50

    Price range (used): N/A (none found)

    Notable Features & FYI: Like the other flour books, there's definitely some level of.... encouragement? To go out and buy a grain mill. However, the ones he uses start with the Mockmill 100, priced at $730 Australian at the time of writing, and the bigger Mockmill 200, is priced at over $1500 Australian. Those are huge investments for a one-trick pony appliance. You can in fact buy (at least, here in Australia), the biggest KitchenAid KSM70 StandMixer for $1049 complete with dough hook, whisk, paddle scraper and bowl. Then add the MockMill Stand Mixer Attachment for $399... and you still have enough left over to buy 20Kg of fresh wheat berries.... so most home bakers are much better off with this versatile setup over a $1500 piece of specialist equipment. However, it will be slower to mill grain than the Mockmill 100/200... but quieter too.

    Fresh-Milled Flour, Bread Book Pros & Cons

    Like all good bread books specialising in using exotic flours or at least, unusual mixes of more common flours, this book certainly offers a sense of experimentation, and tinkering... perhaps more than most other books here. So this is definitely more for the free-spirited baker, than those who want battle-tested, perhaps bomb-proof recipes.

    The Pros:

    It really got me thinking about how each type of flour had particular characteristics. In fact, it was during my first read-through of this book that Ren ran out of almond meal for one of her dessert bakes. Now we could have used any flour, cake flour/bread flour/or other nut flour... but Ren isn't actually the biggest fan of nuts, (and we didn't have another nut-based meal) so I handed her our container of Emmer flour that I'd milled, citing it's "lightly nutty flavour without the nut base", and it worked really well.

    Now there are of course, classic bread recipes. However, the "Grain foward" actually teach you something about a specific grain type. Once you're familiar with the grains themselves, the more advanced recipes are actually interesting, incorporating not only previously-unheard-of flour mixes, but combining that with fruits, seeds, soaks, and more. Few, if any, books I've read (and you know I've read a few by now) cover recipes anything like this.

    Also, while milling fresh flour will help any baker bring out the flavour in their breads, Tim's frequent recommendation to sift flours will help to control the texture to a much higher degree. It honestly surprised me how much a simple sift impacted particle size, hydration, and even dough extensibility. Sifting need not waste your flour either, becuase Tim recommends coating the bottom of your doughs with the removed bran, which prevents burning, and works somewhat similarly to coarse semolina. Honestly, I think I've used my sieves and sifters more since reading this book than the year preceding it. It's just another tool in my arsenal now.

    The Cons:

    Truthfully, I'm glad this books encourages experimentation because I'm honestly hard-pressed to get some of the grain species suggested in Tim's recipes. The first recipe suggests using "Glenn wheat berries"... and as an Aussie, I can't get them, they're just nowhere to be found here.

    Looking at images of American "Glenn Wheat" (specifically the brand "Janie's Mill"), it suggests that it's a "hard red spring wheat". Still not the easiest thing to find here in Australia, but the odds have gone up now that I know what category of wheat I'm looking for.

    The rest of the ingredients in this first recipe are more generic like rye, and "hard white spring wheat". This, I have a chance of obtaining, even if it's not perfectly matched. Tim talks about his swapping bread for grains at local markets in or near Chicago.... and while I loved Chicago when I visited it, it's a bit problematic to travel 15,000Km (just under 9400mi each way) for a sack of wheat berries (or several). I'm sorry, but I don't think there's a bread in this world that anyone can make that I'd travel that far and spend that much cash on.

    Conclusion:

    Honestly, I think you can get most of the benefits of the recipes, even when buying premade flour of various types to make these breads. So if you're on a tight budget, you can still see real bread improvements without the need for a personal grain mill. That said, things do go "up a notch" from there if you do have a mill and use the freshly milled flours.

    I personally bought my stand mixer attachment at a fraction of the cost of the Mockmill offerings, and I'm really enjoying it. Admittedly, I don't get flours quite as fine as what Tim generally aims for, but if I'm mixing it with commercial bread flour already.. the texture difference is there, but greatly reduced. With the Kitchen Aid milling attachment for my stand mixer, I find it's better to grind the flour quite coarsely the first time, then do a second fine grind. If I go too fine on the first pass, the second pass presses the flour together and clogs the mill. That might not happen with the Mockmill attachment, but I don't have one to verify that claim.

    For those in the U.S. (even better near Chicago) you're going to have a much easier time obtaining the flours Tim suggests. Australians and those in other countries might have to do the best they can with what's available. However, if you're in a country like that, you know your situation. This book doesn't cause the problem. Tim can only share what he knows, and he knows the grains that are available in his area.

    I think that this book has taught me the most about various specific wheat varieties and I certaintly do not hold Tim's lack of formal baking education against him. In fact, as a hobbyist, I find it inspiring that he's accomplished so much and come so far.

    If you want to mill your own grains, and learn what each species of grain can do, I'm honestly going to put this book first in my recommendation list for that. If you accept that you might not be able to get the grains in your country and will have to adapt. This is a useful skill unto itself. That said, if you're in the U.S., then it's even easier to recommend the book to you.

    Picture coming soon!

    Ham's first go at "Rustic Field Blend Loaf" (Photo: Ren)

    You know it's funny, I really wanted to do one of the "Grain Forward" recipes because they'd be a great way to showcase a particular grain and perhaps learn something new. However, I just happened to find myself "between shops" and had the remainders of several grain types. So when I saw this recipe, explicitly designed to use up whatever grains Tim had laying about, well, the choice was made. :-)

    Not many books have any sort of recipe for this situation, and it's a situation that will happen repeatedly as you bake your breads.

    Honestly, I had to adapt a couple of things to the particular flours (notably whole wheat einkorn & emmer for the "mixed grain" component) along with my fresh milled/sifted whole wheat that I'd milled the day before.

    Beware divided ingredient quantities!

    One of the things I don't like about this book is that some recipes list the ingredients with the suffix "divided".

    Honestly, I just want to read the ingredients, add them as needed, I'd rather not have to trawl through the method section to find out, that a whole 8g of my 425g of water needs to be held back... (adding water in stages is called the "Bassinage" method, which results in a more open crumb). 8g is not much in this particular recipe, but the divided quanitites aren't always so trivial. So please keep this in mind! Honestly, it's something I could easily forget about and in that way, I feel the recipe has unnecesessary hurdles that can trip the baker up. You have to read the method for key ingredient amounts before mixing!

    That said, mixing the ingredients (once you've accounted for divided ingredients) is easy. The dough shaped, rose a little, and I may have delayed the folds a little due to cooler kitchen conditions, but there were no issues. I then did an overnight proof in the fridge as instructed and baked the following day....

    Unfortunately, I feel the cooking times were a bit long and came out less dark brown and closer to black. So I'd strongly recommend cutting the uncovered cook time by 5-7 minutes, and check the progress. Adjust as necessary.

    Rustic field blend loaves

    Why didn't I put this picture first as normal?

    As I experiment with new recipes from various books, Ren also experiments with her photography. In this case, Ren used a rather wide angle lens, and combined with the odd lighting/shape of my loaf (and relatively flattish loaf height) meant that the bread looks all kinds of distorted and even flatter than usual. So I put Ren's sliced picture first to show that this is indeed a three dimensional loaf instead of some weird AI generated slop.

    As with my bakes, some are better than others, and now that we've sliced up the bread, it's a bit hard to re-take the full loaves.

    Good Effing Dough by Kane Bergman

    Good F*cking Dough by Kane Bergman

    Ok, so this one probably isn't the ideal gift for your devoutly religious mother in-law, children, or people with delicate sensitivities. However, it's undeniable that most people know someone who'd actually appreciate this approach to bread baking.

    Despite the language and the numerous innuendos. There's also a lot of no nonsense (or no B.S. if you prefer) approaches to baking that gets straight to the point, and if you can handle the language.... it's actually an enjoyable read.

    I was honestly surprised to find it in a local library, but I was more surprised that so many copies were booked up for months in advance. Having been desensitised to crude language over many years (through no fault of my own, I try not to use it myself) and finding the book on sale, it didn't scare me off. I looked at the recipes and knew it would represent a small-but-not-quite-universally-appreciated gap in the bread book world.

    Make no mistake, the recipes are good. It's in the title, and I believe the good needs at least as much representation as the profanity.. because it's actually more important.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: No nonsense and brutally to-the-point bread/dessert baking (as well as recipes for pasta, meals, light snacks, and how to make commonly-used ingredients at home). It's only for those who can tolerate swearing and crass descriptions. However, the food at the other end of all these depictions I'd rather not associate with foodstuffs, is very good.

    Total page count: 160

    No. of pages before recipes: 14

    Metric/imperial units? All ingredients are in grams, temperature is in both Celsius and Fahrenheit

    Number of recipes: Total: 60 recipes. The break down is this:

    16 bread recipes, 8 pizza dough/banh mi/burger/pretzel/other dough stuff. 8 international breads (bagels, bao buns, Lahm bi ajeem, etc), 8 "pound town" specialty recipes, there's also miscellaneous pasta and how to make common ingredients.

    Finally, there's the 8 "sweet treat" recipes (from lamingtons and fairy bread, through pancakes and hot cross buns, to "The Simpson's Doughnuts" and "Panty dropping cinnamon rolls".

    Note: (I have not tested the panty dropping bit, but that's most likely because I don't wear them).

    Photos for every recipe? Yes, each recipe has a full-page photo.

    Price range (new): $34-$52 Australian (softcover, new) e-book $16.99 (Kindle) or $22-$25 (epub)

    Price range (used): N/A (none found at prices that compete with new... yes, I know!)

    Notable Features & FYI: I've already discussed it, but it bears repeating. This book has a lot of language in it that is not fit for church/families/work places....

    Honestly, it's definitely more of a recipe book than a treatise on techniques or bread science. However, there's a no-nonsense approach that seems to be akin to Richard Bertinet's "you don't need to know how to rebuild a carburettor in order to drive a car" philosophy. I believe the results speak for themselves (see below).

    I really like the "Ten Baking Commandments", and the "Kneading Cheat Sheet". These two things constitute the majority of the theory in this book. So if you're looking for a fast intro and you really are "A complete amateur", (which is the name of a chapter), this book has you covered.

    While the bread recipes are very good, their simplicity gains you reliability and presentability in exchange for sacrificing a little bit of the flavour from your ingredients. However, it is undeniable that the results I got were very impressive and it will help build confidence for those with very little experience. So in that regard, the legendary sourdough is legendarily simple.

    Looking beyond bread... the Banh Mi, French toast, pasta, and burgers are absolutely something we'd use in our household and I imagine many homes woud do so too. I'm sure Ren will show great interest in the sweets section, but I will have to stagger all these books so I don't die of a coronary. :~)

    Anyway, I don't think this book is for everyone, but it is undeniably useful, diverse (in it's own bread related-ish way) and too the point. 

    Let's see how I go with an actual bake...

    First attempt at

    Ham's first attempt at "Kane's Legendary Sourdough" (Pic: Ham)

    What could possible be more appropriate (ironically perhaps for this book), than something that is clearly labelled as one of his best recipes? Because frankly, I wasn't looking for the "One way ticket to pound town", which was another option.

    Honestly, despite two different doughs made slightly different ways, and very different textures, the real strength of this recipe is the final 12-18 hour retarded, fridge-based proof that you know will get those sourdough flavours going. It also helps to manage multiple batches of baking without causing problems or fear of over proofing. Actually, the big boule shown uncut here, actually had a significantly more open crumb... so much so I was joking that it might have been a bit closer to lace in a few slices closer to the edge. That's not exactly ideal if you have butter or honey dripping through. The rest of the boule was near ideal though.

    The flavour is good for a largely unadorned bread. There's no honey, or spices, charcoal, malt, soaked seeds, or any sort of topping. It's literally just a mix of wholemeal and bread flour, a well curated starter, some salt, and a lot of patience. This is technically, a three day process. However, the rustic wholemeal and sourdough flavour is definitely there, but it's a tightly-controlled tang that builds slightly after chewing. I'm sure that will appeal to some people. What's more, is that (in my experience) some of the ugliest loaves in this page have some of the best flavours. However, look at this boule, and this will tick all the expected boxes without the rough appearances, as shown here.

    So I can say from experience that the recipe lives up to the book's title. It is a good dough.

    Ren's first attempt at "Not so cinnamon scrolls" (Pic: Ren)

    You know how I said Ren likes baking sweets? 

    Ren decided to use our home-grown and home-made blackberry jam instead of cinnamon to make these scrolls. (See! I'm not the only one who tinkers here).

    This is the only section where the cream-cheese icing wasn't hiding the scrolls below. It really is a relatively forgiving, quite delicious, soft and understandably sticky dessert. 

    Beyond Bread & Butter - Three Mills Bakery

    Beyond Bread & Butter - Jarod Deaton & Callum Johnston

    "This book is Three Mills Bakery's ode to making great bread, along with finding creative and sometimes extreme ways to use it. That said, while you can find it lurking on shelves in book shops here in Canberra, you're not going to find a copy on Amazon or any of the big book chains anytime soon.

    Honestly, this is (to me) one of the prettiest bread books I've ever seen. The photographer, Adam McGrath has done an amazing job that makes this book "all fancy schmancy". The book uses modern aesthetics without much clutter or fuss. That said, this almost A3-sized hardcover book could considerably smaller because the margins around the text are huge, and the pictures feature a lot of negative space/background at times.

    While you could be mistaken that this is a general recipe book, or a coffee table book on food photography, there's ten separate sourdough recipes and some have 3 or so variations in them. Then it becomes a "how to use bread up" recipe book... and my personal favourite name for a recipe is "Crabby Sourdough".

    No other book offers a crabby sourdough (that I know of) while teaching you to make smoked dips, cultured butter, sourdough stuffed roasts, and if you think that's getting "out there", how about this:

    Fried crocodile nuggets/schnitzel coated in herbed and spiced sourdough breadcrumbs, served with a home-made nori infused mayonnaise.

    Try finding that in any restaurant! You won't find this stuff in "FWSY" or "The Bread Baker's Apprentice".

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Sourdough making, and very much, using in both conventional and really unconventional ways.

    Total page count: 240

    No. of pages before recipes: 51

    Metric/imperial units? Metric only. Weight measurements, or actual count (For example: 2 egg whites)

    Number of recipes: 10 sourdough bread recipes (although the baguettes have three variations).

    There's an additional 67 recipes for how to use bread in a wide variety of meals, or make the sauces/ammendments that will help build recipes.

    Photos for every recipe? Yes! Beautiful full page images.

    Price range (new): $65-$114 Australian for the hard cover. No soft cover option found.

    Price range (used): N/A (none found)

    Notable Features & FYI:

    More to come, this is a work in progress.

    Ancient Grain Sourdough

    My first attempt at "Ancient Grain Sourdough" (Pic: Ren)

    This book is beautiful, and one of the hardest parts is deciding what to make. They all look amazing. However, I've recently stocked up on various grains and seeds so this recipe suited me.

    Now I have to warn you, that if you're anything like me, you make your soaked seven grain mix, then work on your starter+water+honey mix, then when you're told to "add the rest of the ingredients", you add the bread+rye+wholemeal flours, the salt, and forget to add that seven grain mix. Of course, then I was worried about when I'd add the separate three grain mix (which is used for coating later... Although, when it's done is not explicitly mentioned anywhere). Now, depending on your seed mix (it suggested equal parts pumpkin/sunflower/sesame seed mix... but I was fresh out of pumpkin seeds... so I went 50/50. Honestly I'd recommend keeping the larger seeds at the 33% ratio because they will interfere with the later scoring of your loaf. However, if you're like me, then lightly spraying the top of your loaf with water, scoring the loaf as you'd expect, then gently patting/sprinkling the seeds around your scored bit makes a lot of sense.

    While you can smell the honey as you're mixing this dough, there's a hefty complexity and bready smell before you even start to bake. There's a lot going on in there, so if packing your breads with nutrients, complex and rustic flavours and getting your slow proofing on for even more flavour development, then this recipe, dear reader, is for you.

    I'm literally writing this as I make it, I'm currently proofing my two loaves in two separate, oiled bowls.. but my kitchen is at 15C at the moment. So I'm warming one in my oven on proofing mode, and because my oven isn't big enough for two large bowls, I'm literally sitting the other bowl in a larger bowl of warm water, and simply slapped a plastic chopping board on top to keep the heat in.

    Unfortunately, during the transfer from the bowls to the bannetons, the oil failed, so the dough stuck to the mixing bowls, and this caused significant deflation in the transfer. So the bread as you can imagine, lost some height.

    Now, if you can imagine a sourdough, with rye flour, and nearly 10 additional varieties of seeds added into (or onto) the mix, then toasted in (or baked if you will) you'd have a pretty good idea of what this bread will taste like. The sourdough tang is there, but it's woven into the tapestry of other more complex flavours. Toasting each slice individually also enhances some of the flavours even further. So if you like rustic, healthy breads, it should be definitely on your "to do" list.

    Alt Text

    The crumb & crust of the Ancient Grain Sourdough (Pic by Ham!)

    Ok, so I may be struggling to get the rise I'm aiming for in the depths of Canberra winter during renovations, but there's 9 or 10 different types of of grain in this recipe, three different forms of flour, and then dusted with.... you guessed it, more flour and seeds.

    I'd say that this particular slice is actually 10cm (4") high (or wide in this orientation) and about 28-30cm (11-12") long

    The flavour is as described above, but on the "day after" the tang is a little stronger, (or maybe I'm just eating a slightly less chunky piece of crust that is packed with toasted sesame/pepita seed flavours).

    The texture of the crumb isn't as gritty as I expected, and while there are some seeds in there, they're either small like poppy seeds, or somewhat pulverised/broken down.

    Ren suggested that this would be appreciated by her mother, who is of a somewhat health-conscious persuasion, and likes older/more rustic flavoured breads.

    It's not Ren's favourite.... apparently. "Only because of the seeds on top".... sigh. Soon I won't be able to get her to eat her vegetables. ;~P

    I on the other hand, quite enjoy the seeds on top, and ok it's a healthy bread that I don't think would bother many people... if you keep the seeds on top to a somewhat reduced state.... I should mention that I didn't use the entire mix that the recipe asked for... so make of that what you will when applying it to your bake and household member preferences.

    SourdoughSchool-VanessaKimbell

    The Sourdough School by Vanessa Kimbell

    I want you to note the "school" part of the title. While it is roughly 50% theory and 50% recipes, make no mistake. Every recipe assumes the knowledge provided from the previous ones, and each recipe is designed to teach you one specific thing.

    Think about that for a moment...

    Vanessa came to bread later in life than most, but she's made up for it in enthusiasm. Having spent time with the crew at Tartine. Honestly at this point, I'm starting to wonder; "Who in the bread book world hasn't?!"

    Every time I read this book, I learn a little more. That said, this book is more about encouraging you to find out how your dough behaves in your kitchen, rather than prescriptive ingredients, times, and temperatures. So it can be a little wishy-washy (or surprisingly vague) in places. If that doesn't suit your style of baking, then there's other books. However, you'll miss out on what this book will teach you.... if you spend enough time with it. It covers advanced topics like sprouting your own seeds/nuts and making malt, even how to smoke ingredients and/or whole loaves. All of this to increase flavour, and enhance the nutritional value of bread.

    The tag line: "The ground-breaking guide to making gut-friendly bread" is also a major focus of this book, so if you know someone who has gastro-intestinal issues, or diabetes, has a mineral deficiency or just want to get a bit healthier, this is a good book for that.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: This is almost a "pure sourdough' bread textbook. Perhaps it's actually more accurate to say that it's a sourdough bread baking course in book form. What's the difference? You can read the theory section in any way you like. However, the recipe section is a regime that expects you to make the first recipe 7 or so times, then move on to the progressively harder recipes. There's a lot of reward if you follow their process, but plenty of people won't want to work this way. So it's definitely aimed at a certain type of aspiring baker who want to know more, and have the path laid out for them... but it won't appeal to some other bakers.

    Total page count: 206

    No. of pages before recipes: 103

    Metric/imperial units? Pure metric, no volume measurements. Everything is in grams and temperatures, Celsius.

    Number of recipes: 29

    Photos for every recipe? Yes, but not all of them show sliced loaves which doesn't depict the crumb.

    Price range (new): $35-$70 Australian for a hardcover. No soft cover found. E-book can be found as low as $4.27

    Price range (used): $32-$59 AUD for the hard cover.

    Notable Features & FYI: In short, this book goes way beyond most books at this price point.... at least in specific ways. So let's discuss the strengths here.

    The pros of this book:

    This book has some of the most interesting ideas for making starters and controlling the acidity and flavour. Naturally there's the white flour starter, and rye starter (that's the low hanging fruit) but when you get to freshly milled wholegrain starters things start to branch out, but the crown jewel here is the chocolate starter. (No joke!) I've had to restrain myself somewhat.

    There's a lot of information on how to use malt, and even make it from scratch by sprouting and drying/baking and milling the results. That said, while it does discuss stone vs. roller milled flour, the details on how best to do that is somewhat lacking. So the books specialising in home milled flour will offer some comparative advantage in this area.

    It also discusses some of the more unusual processes like "Bassinage" and clarifies some oft-confused bread baking terms regarding:

    Leavened versus levained, how preferments, starters, biga, poolish, pâte fermentée, differ (and are sometimes used erroneously or even interchangeably) it also discusses some of the variations to autolyse procedures (and when/why) you'd choose them.

    If that's not enough... it also discusses how to smoke your ingredients (or loaves) and which smoking woods you need.

    Perhaps the defining feature of this book is rather-detailed look at the health benefits of sourdough breads. Naturally it's called "Digestibility & Nutrition". It discusses the different conditions that may contribute to wheat intolerance (it's not just one). It discusses the gut "microbiome", the role of fibre, nutrients, phytonutrients, phenolic compounds, vitamins & minerals found in wheat grains, FODMAPS which discuss carbohydrate groups that can be difficult to break down in the human digestive system, lipids, fatty acids, even bioactive peptides. The chapter rounds off explaining how sourdough is better for managing blood sugar levels and being less harsh on those with wheat intolerances. It's not however, "a green light to eat bread without care" and of course, professional medical advice is recommended. That said, sourdough is healthier (relatively speaking) than most commercially made industrial breads.

    Now, I've read the nutrition section a couple of times and while I certainly don't remember all the saccharide types (mono, di, oligo?) in FODMAPS-based analyses.... I didn't find it too heavy or difficult to understand. That said, I don't think I'd want to read much more in a bread baking book. However, it has gone far deeper than some of the "Gluten free" specialty books that simply provide a list of recipes and the basics to follow them. This is more about understanding the why, as well as the how of making bread more suitable for those with digestive issues.

    Many other books simply state that the slow-fermented breads like sourdoughs are often partially broken down in ways that those with intolerances are more capable of handling... and move on. So I really like how much effort Vanessa has gone to with this. She's cited studies and professors from multiple universities, so it's based in some serious science there.

    The down-sides of this book:

    There's a lot of theory before (and after) the recipes and that theory section is heavily referenced from the recipe method sections. Even the method sections within the recipes are laden with theory, so much so you can be honestly wondering :

    "Where the heck is the baking temperature? Is it in the general guidelines of the basic procedure in the theory section, or is it buried somewhere deep in the procedure/recipe specific method somewhere?"

    I personally find this quite frustrating, particularly when you're deep in mid-make, time is ticking away, and I'm frantically looking up one bit and scanning pages (note the plural) to find key times/temperatures/procedural notes. Vanessa suggests keeping a log of your bakes, but instead of retrospectively noting what you did, I honestly think it's helpful to pre-emptively plan your bake out entirely by filling out that log book entry first and running from that.

    The biggest complaint I have is that as an Australian baker, there's little chance I can just "pop down to the shop" and get some organic UK/European flour. My flour is fundamentally different and also, my baking environment is clearly different, so my first attempts are going to experimental to say the least.

    Do I need expensive equipment?

    All recipes assume that they'll be mixed by hand. This is aimed at teaching you to get a feel for your dough. That said, stand mixers are discussed, albeit in less detail than other books. This can be can pro and/or a con depending on how you look at it, so I think it suits beginners and experienced bakers alike in this regard. However, "slow/medium/high" speeds on differing stand mixers can have very different results so you will need to tinker a bit with trial and error to see what works best with. your particular stand mixer.

    Conclusion:

    I think that if you (or anyone you know) has specific bread-related allergies/intolerances and like sourdough, then this is definitely one of the most cost-effective (and surprisingly underrated) sourdough books. While you're encouraged to start at the first recipe, repeatedly make it until you're comfortable, then move on, I just don't see many people sticking to the recipe "regime?" (for lack of a better word) if they just want to try someting new, or have other ideas on how best to learn.

    If you can cope with the changes that your locally-available flours & baking environment might bring to your particular bread make, then this is an excellent book. Particularly, if you cut yourself some slack and expect a rough first-attempt or two. If you're expecting bomb-proof and battle-tested recipes that are quite forgiving, you'll be hard-pressed to succeed without spending a lot of time preparing before starting the make. This book is about getting you familiar with sourdough procedures to the point you can probably name the famililies of microbes found in your starter. It's not a last-minute, "just pick a recipe and go" kind of book at all. If you do that, expect some variable results. However, whatever happens you'll definitely learn something. :-)

    That, dear reader, just might be the entire point... even if you do diverge in... shall we say.. approach?

    Let's see how I go with a first attempt bake...

    Classic white sourdough boules (first attempt)

    Classic white sourdough boules... first attempt (Pic: Ren)

    Ummm that doesn't look like a boule to me! I couldn't find my lame, so I tried to score the loaf with a sharp kitchen knife. It didn't go to plan.

    Vanessa is very clear across the entire book that her recipes work for her, with her particular kitchen, with her particular ingredients and techniques. Everything else is "find what works for you"...

    Unfortunately, I don't have any of the U.K. or northern European grains Vanessa recommended, and I used my home milled flour sifted as a replacement for the "stone ground flour"... even though my mill does not use stones per se. Honestly, I think it was closer to wholemeal than the usual bread flour the recipe asked for... this is what happens when there's shipping delays on your bread flour! Sorry... I did the best I could!)

    I don't know whether it was my colder than average kitchen, my starter was feeling sluggish that day, but it just did not want to rise.

    Curiously, these two breads were cooked in entirely different ways. The first one (upper right) was baked as instructed for an hour with some browning at the end, but it became more like 90 mins of baking and 25 minutes of browning because it was a pretty chilly day!

    The second one (lower left) was baked at 230C from start to finish, this was done in 38 minutes then browned for 20. Honestly, I think I got an extra two centimetres of height. So while I didn't "find what works for me"... I did find what worked better for me, even if it's only a marginal improvement.

    With all that said... this is some seriously tasty bread! It's just dense. So we've been happily slicing it a bit thinner to offset that density, and it's a rustic fresh sourdough baguette... with a chewier crust, and a less airy crumb. Oh the hardship, I'm telling you! (Alright, I admit it, I'm completely ok with it).

    Want to see an interesting use for this bread? Keep reading!

    Classic Whilte Boule... Rusks.

    Classic White Boule... Rusks.
    (Pic: Ren)

    One of the things you can do if your boule is somewhat deflated, is make rusks. The narrower shape lends itself, quite well, to such crispy deliciousness. It's almost like it's "meant to be"... even if it wasn't what was originally intended.

    This image kills two birds with one stone. The first, showing the dense crumb from my less-than-ideal proofing strategy... and the second is of course, showing that slowly dehydrating your bread at low-ish temperatures can make the metaphorical "lemonade from lemons".

    You can really see the somewhat golden/reddish hue given by the use of khorasan/kamut flours and it adds a slightly nutty/sweeter flavour... admittedly sacrificing a little rise height along the way due to the lower gluten content.

    Now I can tell you with reasonable certainty that you will not find a golden emmer/khorasan sourdough rusk in most supermarkets and they just happen to go really well with some cream cheese and smoked salmon... which is definitely on my "to do" list... once I get more salmon. :-)

    Yes, it's hard life, but I am proud of my bread/rusk/biscuity work.... and I could break these up into delicious croutons if I wanted..... if Ren could get over her erroneous dislike of croutons. :~D

    Artisan Sourdough Made Simple by Emilie Raffa

    Artisan Sourdough Made Simple by Emilie Raffa

    When I first read this book, I had barely sat down to read it, I then started to wonder where I'd put my half-consumed tea, grabbed it, and as I picked up the book, I realised I was already on page 36! I don't know what it is, it's like the literary equivalent of Teflon, I just slide through it. I just don't have that feeling of wading through one chapter after another. Even though I'd still slog through it anyway out of sheer stubbourness.

    The recipes are inviting rather than basic/boring or challenging/experimental. This book takes sourdough, and specialises in adding fillings, or toppings, ranging from cheeses, herbs, and fruit, to chocolates, jams, and even yoghurt! The whole book makes "labours of bread baking love" far less draining. It even provides easy ways to fancifully decorate it (braids, wreaths, scrolls, etc) and incorporate it with everyday meals or special treats.

    It's definitely aimed at sourdough-focussed beginners, but if you value quality "how to" images and the fastest results are important to you, this is the book I'd recommend.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Easy to read and do, beginner-to-intermediate sourdough making.

    Total page count: 208

    No. of pages before recipes: 22

    Metric/imperial units? Metric quantities in grams, temperature is in Celsius.... but for you imperial-loving bakers out there, it includes volume (cups/spoons) as measurement backup with Fahrenheit temps throughout the procedures as well.

    Number of recipes: This is an odd one. It's 68 total, but that can be broken down into 55 bread/sourdough starter recipes, and 13 more recipes on how to use that bread.

    Breaking it down even further into the bread bits...

    11 "Sweet and Savoury" breads, 6 "Pan loaves and sandwich breads", 7 "Whole grains and specialty flours", 19 "Focaccia, rolls and everything else", (which doesn't include everything else) 5 more recipes in "bread art", 7 "recipes for leftover sourdough starter"

    Then to use the breads you've made, there's a "To enjoy with bread" with 13 more recipes ranging from salads, jams, dips, gelato on a brioche bun, and a "rum & raisin bread pudding".

    Photos for every recipe? Yes, and the earlier recipes have step-by-step images along the way too. If you're unsure about things, the first recipes have detailed images to get you started (I recommend making the first one if you're a beginner) and then way up the back, there are two chapters complete with images on how to shape dough, score dough, and even start dabbling in simple-but-effective bread "art". No rambling Youtube references needed! In terms of introductory "how to" images, I'd even put this above most of the popular books, and even rivals "Bread Illustrated" (reviewed below) because the images are larger (even if they're less numerous) so you can see the details of what they're trying to do.

    Price range (new): $30-$57 Australian for the softcover, $71 Aud (spiral bound) and $21-$26 for the e-book

    Price range (used): Honestly, $36-$75... it's more expensive than buying new and we're only discussing the softcover here.

    Notable Features & FYI:

    There's a lot of good books that help you to make sourdough. After a lot of thought....

    I'm hard-pressed to think of many other sourdough books that are as accessible (in terms of ease of use) as this one. "Wild Sourdough" strikes me as the most similar to it, but where "Wild Sourdough" feels like a 90s era school book on the subject, and features a quick transition from theory into "pure recipe book". "Artisan Sourdough Made Simple" takes a little less time in the theory, offers a bit more detail in some of the basics, (less in others) but holds your hand in the first few recipes instead, particularly where it's covering techniques.

    This book cuts to the chase, assumes no experience, it shows key steps that you might not be familiar with, but trusts that you know how to use your scale/mixer/hand to get the rest done... So there's no "bloat" in the text. Once the basic procedures and techniques are covered in the introductory recipes, later recipes become more streamlined. I don't have a problem with that.

    If you're still unsure of something, the sections in the back can guide you on the more troublesome steps without getting in the way.

    If you are, or someone you know is a sourdough baker with sight issues, I'd recommend this book over "Bread Illustrated" even if this book has fewer recipes overall. Also, "Artisan Sourdough Made Simple" doesn't need crutches like YouTube to clarify images. So, if you're on a farmstead in the middle of nowhere, with little if any Internet access, this is the book I'd recommend to sourdough beginners.

    Also, for those with teenage bakers in the household, it's not a tome so I feel that the time poor, or perhaps more timid beginner folks would find this book less intimidating. Don't get me wrong, "The Bread Baker's Apprentice", "Flour, Water, Salt, Yeast", "Tartine", and "Dough" are amazing books in their own right, but they just take longer to read, and most aren't exactly "sourdough centred". I'm not trying to start an argument here.

    If that isn't enough, there's sections in the back to do "bread art" that are easy to do and none of the beginner books at this level have included. I have been baking for over a decade and I learned something here. Fewer books have dedicated a whole section on simply shaping your breads like this one does.. It's not, "two pics and a blurb" approach, but pages of images making it clear what to do, one step at a time. Then it trusts you to take those skills to the later recipes.

    I like that each recipe after the initial step-by-step ones, still take at least two pages, sometimes up to four.. so you get images of the finished product, and any special instructions you need in good half/quarter page sized images with short description... not bad images with long descriptions.

    The Pros & Cons of "Artisan Sourdough Made Simple"

    Pros:

    The theory is well presented, the practical making tips, even more so. Obviously, this isn't going into the deep technicalities, but you don't need to. This saves time and gets you results fast that wow and impress..... if the recipes suit your tastes. There's a lot of great recipes that we would regularly make in our household, but yours mightn't like them.

    My personally favourite feature is the "how long will bread last"listing with each recipe. That tells me whether I can make a double batch and use it in time to save baking, or if I have to limit it to smaller batches and bake more often. Or.... that I have to freeze the bread on day one in order to minimise waste.

    As an experienced baker, this book dabbles quite a bit in fillings for the bread. This offers an effective means to amp up flavour without the more technical issues of extracting every bit of flavour from the dough itself. It's nice to be reminded of that option, because I routinely add seeds and new flours, and focus on the "advanced stuff" but I've slacked off on the fillings options for quite a while... so if you're like me, this book might be a gentle reminder/inspriation piece.

    One of the other things l liked about this book, is that it acknowledges that many home bread bakers are... intermittent bakers. Whether you bake weekly, monthly, or just when the fancy strikes, it's hard to develop the practical skills that benefit from repetition, like scoring your doughs. So Emilie has an ingenious way for folks to routinely practice scoring on playdough without making dough every time. However, I'd recommend thorough cleaning of the blade before switching to food, or better yet, have a dedicated playdough blade and keep the other ones for the bread.

    Note about lame maintenance: A razor blade, if well maintained and stored will keep an edge to last hundreds of loaves. However, carelessness, and slicing around and though seeds on top of your dough will dramatically reduce the lifespan of the blade. That said, it's only a matter of time before the blade needs replacing (if disposable) or sharpening (if not). Sharpening to a razor's edge is more involved than a standard kitchen knife, and you will have to do it more often. A sharper blade means a thinner edge, and a thinner edge means less material that's more easily blunted and damaged.

    Cons:

    Unlike many other bread books this is sourdough only. You have to keep that in mind, but it is possible to make flavoured sourdoughs that aren't sour. So there's some "wiggle room" there.

    While sourdough is easier on the stomach of many people with bread-related intolerances... there's no guarantee it's a good idea for some to eat it, no matter how it's made. Also, the book makes no allowances for people with other/additional special dietary needs. Many of the bread recipes involve cheeses, nuts, and other ingredients that many folks can't (or shouldn't) have. So this book won't cater for them at all.

    This is definitely more of a recipe book than textbook. Sure, it gives you the basics, but little of the logic behind it, so gaining the ultimate familiarity and adaptability is not going to happen from this book.

    Finally, I'm afraid that I actually disagree with Emilie's assertion:

    “GOOD TO KNOW: NO NEED TO PREHEAT THE POT

    Many breads baked in covered pots require the pot to be preheated beforehand. You can skip that step. Although a preheated pot allows for the dough to expand on contact, you’ll get comparable results, avoiding the inevitable wrist burns.”

    So here's my take (for what it's worth):

    Ok, I have cooked with cold pots... see the Dutch Oven Sourdough that I made under "Make Ahead Bread" by Donna Currie (above), and in my experience, I can say two (ish) things:

    1. While the crumb might be the similar, the crust is quite different, and that's where a lot of the aroma and consequently flavour comes from. Often the finished crust determines how crunchy/chewy/tough the bread ends up, which in my opinion, might be comparable but it's not always as similar as Emilie's statement implies. I much prefer the results from a preheated pot. I just think it's closer to the intended results of most recipes, and helps to deliver the bread anyone eating it expects. If you prefer your baguettes to not have that crispy flaky crust and prefer a chewy one, that's fine. But, if someone hands me a baguette with the same chewy specs, I'm more inclined to think it's hobbyist grade than professional. (I have flops, so why wouldn't anyone else?). Don't worry, I'll still happily eat it!
    2. Avoiding the preheating stage to reduce burned wrists suggests:
      1. That you need a larger piece of parchment/baking paper to increase the distance between hot pot and limbs while lowing the dough into the hot pot.
      2. Get a better pair of oven mits, perhaps ones that extend further up the arm to protect those wrists. If you have that...
      3. Use the longer baking paper to remove the cooked loaf.. or take the pot out, use your new gloves to gently/quickly tip the loaf out of your hot pot onto a large heat-tolerant surface (wooden chopping board, metal/stone/tile/concrete bench).
      4. If you're burning yourself on the Dutch oven, consider getting a cast iron bread baking pan like the famous Challenger pan... there are numerous vastly cheaper brands now that are a fraction of the price. Brunswick and Skitchen's "Brisbane" range (which I have both), I saw a Wolstead branded one in a local retailer, and I'm sure there are many others. These pans have low walls on the base, and the lid is a dome, this makes putting dough in and taking loaves out much easier and safer. However a pan like that is only worth getting once you're serious about the hobby.


    Conclusion:

    If your family has few if any allergies/intolerances, and you want one of the easiest, fastest, and clearest introductions to sourdough, then "Artisan Sourdough Made Simple" is an excellent choice. You can get great results in very little time.

    In a very real way, this is the sourdough-specific version of "Bread Illustrated".. but only the first recipes are heavily illustrated.

    It's also pretty enough to be a gift/coffee table book and can inspire younger and older bakers alike. Given that it's often cheaper than other, more popular books I don't see any particular reason not to get it, unless you have a die-hard hardcover requirement, in which case, this book doesn't have that.

    Compared to other books pure sourdough books reviewed here...

    Given that "Artisan Sourdough Made Simple" was inspired by an Australian baker, it doesn't surprise me that it's similar in some ways to "Wild Sourdough", (also written by an Australian). "Artisan Sourdough Made Simple" is fundamentally less verbose and/or technically demanding than "The Sourdough Framework", "Tartine", "Super Sourdough", "Homemade Sourdough" and "Sourdough School". That said, in terms of structure, the first recipe being done step-by-step is very similar to "Tartine" but "Tartine" is more technical and time consuming... no recipe in "Artisan Sourdough Made Simple" drags on for 20-odd pages. Which can be a little more stressful when you're doing it the first time, and you've forgotten where you're up to during the make 'n' bake.

    To my fellow cheesey bretheren....

    If you're a cheese maker (or cheese eating maven) and want to incorporate cheeses into your breads, (like I am) then this book is fantastic for that. So there's another niche group of hobbyists that this book works particularly well for.

    Easy bread basket rolls

    Ham's first attempt at: "Easy bread basket rolls"

    While it's all good and well to enjoy ever-fancier breads, sometimes you just want something simple, versatile, and less "experimental". That said, Ren decided that she wanted me to try this one.... while I was thinking more along the lines of English muffins. Ren won of course, but not for the reason you'd think. It came down to the simple fact that you can have dinner rolls without being looked at oddly... well less oddly than if you offer dinner muffins. So, here we are. :~)

    Useless musing imminent...

    It's odd that even McDonalds has historically limited the availability of the McMuffin to "breakfast until 10:30am". So, apparently they're not even normal for a late brunch.... It's not like they're completely "retooling the kitchen" for lunch when burgers with both egg and bacon remain available all day at Maccas and any other café who short-sightedly refuses to provide "all day breakfast". Yet, dessert-grade (non English) muffins (blueberry, apple and cinnamon, etc) are available throughout the day. Why is there so much restraint on the humble English muffin? How can we make English muffins acceptable at lunch, or perhaps, even dinner? Thoughts?

    Back to the recipe...

    For a sourdough, the early stages were a breeze, and the only difficulty I had was forgetting to keep my hands wet so I got a bit stuck as I was gently folding/kneading. Factoring in the starter's flour-to-water ratio, the water, and the added milk, this dough comes in at 67.27% hydration which for a sourdough, is truly at the drier beginner level. I don't expect a hugely open crumb with this one, but it is a nice stiff dough that won't turn into a tasty frisbee (or dare I say... "muffin"), when I bake it on a stone or steel.

    I tried my new lame, which I have to say, got a rather impressive ear going on such small rolls. Honestly, these rolls averaged about 150g-160g instead of the nominated 80g, and that is a much more useful size for general roll purposes instead of dainty dinner sides.

    I like these rolls!

    Ok, so they may not have insane amounts of shelf life, but my solution is to box them for a day or so, or for longer term storage, simply freeze them. The tanginess was there, the texture was soft, and the crumb was crispy on baking day, and soft and chewy after that. Having boxes of these rolls in the freezer is a great cheat to toss into lunch boxes or compliment an impromptu gathering.

    I'll definitely be making this recipe again! (After trying some of the other recipes of course).

    The Perfect Loaf by Maurizio Leo

    The Perfect Loaf by Maurizio Leo

    Maurizio Leo runs a bread baking site "ThePerfectLoaf.com", and this book is.. quite oddly, of the same name. "The Perfect Loaf" is another IACP and James Beard Foundation Book Award Winner, and quite notably, it was ranked 1st as the best-selling bread book in Amazon's "top 100 bread book" list in July 2026. However, it should be noted that it didn't even turn up at all on Shortform's "Top 100" or even Goodreads "Top 139" at the time... which for a book who won it's awards years earlier... is interesting, when newer books have been added to both lists. Don't let that dissuade you though, there's a solid-and-growing group of fans in the bread baking community... and I'm not talking about Marizio's 3000+ paying forum members.

    Honestly, there's a lot to like about this book, it is well illustrated, but it goes beyond photos. If a graphic, table or a chart helps to convey an idea efficiently, then it was used, and it links it back to the actual make 'n' bake process, so it's not as theoretical and disconnected as many texts/bread science books can be. I don't regret reading the other books. If you're on a budget and want in-depth, practical info about bread baking and a good range of recipes, it's hard to beat this one. That said, there is a definite time commitment required for this book that doesn't exist for simpler books. If money is no object, then the actual textbooks, and especially the multi-volume tome of bread science, "Modernist: Bread" will of course, take you far further down the rabbit hole of bread making.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus:  An in-depth look into bread. This book is a hybrid between most beginner level bread books and technical/professional/bread science. Reading the intro (at least pages 147-150) before attempting any recipe is essential for anyone not proficient in baker's percentages.

    Total page count: 432

    No. of pages before recipes: 150, however there's some amazingly useful stuff littered amongst the recipe sections, so don't assume all the theory is "up front".

    Metric/imperial units? Temperature is in both Celsius and Fahrenheit.

    All ingredients are in grams or units (such as the "zest of one lemon"). There are no volume-based amounts because even the liquids are done by weight. Similarly, there are no imperial measurements whatsoever..... However, the one notable exception is equipment dimensions, "prepare a sheet pan 18" x 13" by liberally coating it in semolina..."

    Number of recipes: There's a total of 60 recipes. The break-down is:

    22 "Free form loaves", 6 "Pan loaves", 8 "Pizzas and flat breads", 13 "Buns/rolls & more", & 11 "sweets".

    Photos for every recipe? Yes! They're even on the opposite page as the recipe. This helps with choosing your next recipe. That said, any step-by-step stuff is in the introductory section, rather than the recipes.

    Price range (new): The usual hard cover ranges from $52-$83 (Australian). Signed copies can be found at $138, and for the truly fancy-schmancy, there's a leather bound (clearly after-market modded) option at $440-$560 (https://www.ebay.com.au/itm/405641964262) However, for those of us who are sane....

    The Kindle edition is $12 (Australian), e-book $17 from other sellers online.

    Price range (used): Actually, I haven't found any worth mentioning... they're more expensive than new!

    Notable Features & FYI:

    Once you get your head around the three baker's percentage tables found in most recipes (The complete, overall recipe, the levain, and the main dough... However, a glaze or filling may add additional tables, or replace others). The recipes make far more sense than some of the odd-ball layouts found in some other books... but if you're expecting recipe book simplicity and are faced with the tables.. that can be quite intimidating to the uninitiated.

    Delving into the details...

    There's two features found in select recipes that I really like. They are the:

    • "How to tinker", and
    • "Troubleshooting" sections.

    Now, if you've read this far in this article, you know I'm almost a pathological bread tinkerer. I like how this offers recipe-specific options rather than the often-generalised "you can add seeds, nuts, or dried fruit into your bread"... without much regard about which recipes that such options would work with. It also helps you to keep coming back to this book which is always a good sign for your next book investment.

    The troubleshooting section is also a key feature that takes the often generalised troubleshooting guidelines and makes it specific to that recipe. After my first go at a recipe in this book, this is my first port of call if the bread has differed somehow. Again, this brings you back to the book for post-bake analysis. That repetition will train you quite well, and you won't even notice it.

    Expectation management of the troubleshooting section.

    Maurizio, as an author had to acknowledge (consciously or otherwise) that a book can only go so far. Ingredients, equipment, kitchen environmental conditions, and even the bakers themselves all vary in numerous ways. The recipe is literally a starting point that may require adaptation.

    Now, it's understandable to think:

    "Hey the troubleshooting section is in the recipe, I can adjust during the make"

    Unfortunately, the troubleshooting section can only really help after the bake is done. It's for helping you next time, not this time. (Although it can be a gentle reminder later on).You need a reference point. Was the loaf too slack/lacking strength? Was the sourdough flavour too strong/weak? Did the rise happen as expected? Is your flour anything like what Maurizio uses?

    You just don't know what needs changing until you have a finished product. That's why the troubleshooting and tinkering sections are at the end.

    Moving beyond the recipes... kind of...

    Between the recipes is one of the best sections I've found in controlling the sourness/tartness/tanginess of your sourdoughs, and this would apply to any recipe. It describes which metaphocial "levers to pull" and how to adjust each either way... and the expected result. One of the things you can do is balance each adjustment, or combine all of them for maximum flavour, and adjust the time line accordingly.

    You might be wondering: "Why isn't the sourough control with the rest of the theory?" After some thought....

    I actually like how the "intro to bread" didn't include this as it simplifies things for a lot of non-sourdough breads. Once you get into the section involving sourdough, it puts it there, which helps to keep it freshly in mind for the actual make 'n' bake. It just reduces page flipping. I appreciate that. Do what I do, add a book mark there and just reference it if you need to.

    What's "The Perfect Loaf" like to bake with?

    As I've mentioned, the baker's percentage recipe style is not going to be immediately understandable to a beginner who hasn't read the key sections between pages 147-150.

    If you've baked before and are familiar with such formats, then you can of course, run the recipes as described.

    Honestly, the recipes work well for the most part if you have similar conditions to what Maurizio expects.... or at least the dough temperatures are close enough... however you accomplish that.

    As an Aussie using different flour, in a cold environment, and no air con to speak of.. I have to acknowledge that I'll have some variablity. That's not the book's fault. However, there's a few things that could be clearer or more universally described.

    You see, I made the English muffins (see below) and the recipe states: "Liberally dust a 13x 18-inch baking tray..." Place 12x 80g tight balls of dough onto it with plenty of room to spare...

    Except my tray is smaller, and I honestly had no idea about "how strong/tight" should those dough balls needed be.. (A specified size would have helped so I know "up front" if I was too loose, too firm, etc) I proofed it as they were. Ultimately, it was down to "trial and error".

    Conclusion:

    I can see why this is a very popular book. The range of recipes is quite good. The recipes, (once adjusted to your situation) do work well. However, some willingness to tinker is important in this book.. perhaps moreso than other books. So if you're a "strict adherence to the recipe" kind of person, then this probably isn't your ideal choice.

    While it's "beginner friendly", it's a relatively detailed/big book to read and that can discourage some. So I don't think this should be the first book that a complete beginner should start with. I'd like them to even try a basic recipe book with minimal instructions, just to get going. That said, if the beginner is happy to read everything and familiarise themselves with baker's percentages and are of a relatively technical/tinkering mindset, then please don't let me discourage you from this book.

    English Muffins

    Sourdough English Muffins!

    On the left, you can see the paler, original muffin as the recipe wrote. However, the other ones are all fruit muffins that have a darker hue due to the addition of finely diced dried fruit and the addition of cinnamon. The imbalance happened because fruit toast is Ren's favourite type, and since this was her breakfast, here we are. 

    Maurizio states in this recipe that he likes to double the amount. Like many of my "first attempts" I thought that was the perfect opportunity to bake one batch as indicated, and another with some "Ham experimentation". This time, the second batch was adorned with diced dried fruit, and a bit of cinnamon for extra effect.

    Let's talk about the time commitment...

    Like all good sourdoughs, this recipe has the levain prep on day one. Most of the mixing, a first 3.5 hour proof with multiple kneading sessions, and preshape on day two. An overnight cold proof brings us to day three, and that starts with a final warm proof, with the initial skillet browning, final bake, and inevitable cool-down that follows.

    Honestly, I don't normally think of muffins as a three day process. It was fiddly on the first attempt due to temperature fluctuations and the inability to put both mixing bowls into my proofer. That makes it far less "hands off" and more tiring than you might first think.

    Let's talk about the procedure and equipment...

    Now, Maurizio has given "The Perfect Loaf" recipe format in Baker's Percentage format. If you don't know what that is, then you must read the intro section in order to understand what's going on. His section isn't just one table per recipe, but often three. It's critical that you pay attention to the right table.... Yep I've made that mistake before!

    The procedure and equipment outlined in each recipe are highly interdependant. Which can be a bother when one isn't ideally described.

    For example, the muffin procedure asks for 80g balls of dough be placed on a floured baking tray 18" x 13" (or whatever, please note that it's not in metric when equipment is mentioned) But.... what if you don't have a tray that size? I'm supposed to be able to space them out with room to spare, (how much room, is not mentioned either). I won't fit things as described if my tray is smaller. I would much prefer if the size of each ball was described, and how much room around each one should be needed... and figure out however many trays I need from there. The size of the tray should be irrelevant. So from my point of view, there's some room for improvement if Maurizio want's to make a second edition, or new book entirely.

    Some quick guide lines and images showing scale here can make a world of difference in a 3 day procedure.

    How'd they turn out?

    Honestly, I was little disappointed. I didn't get the rise from each ball, and got more "sprawl". So, those spaced out balls did join up, prior to being toasted on the stove and later baked. Ultimately, I ended up with some misshapened muffins, which were thinner than the pretty pictures in the book depicted. That said, the taste is very good, and the fruit toast version is amazing. The flavour is there, the chewy muffin texture is too, it's just that the crumb isn't as open as I hoped.

    Bread Illustrated by America's Test Kitchen

    Bread Illustrated from America's Test Kitchen (ATK for short)

    If you like being shown how to do something in photos, without wading through YouTube presenters and waiting for them to get to the point... then this is one of the more heavily-illustrated bread making books I can whole-heartedly recommend if you're living in the U.S. Ok, it's very U.S. centric (no metric, not even Celsius) but I just added post-it notes/spreadsheet print outs with the metric conversions (and page number if it falls out).

    It's obviously aimed at beginners, and all those images take up real estate in the book, so the recipe count is high but by no means insane for a 432 page book. It's also a pretty decent class on functional rather than fashionable food photography.. if you have an interest. Since it seems every U.S. "mom" with an interest in baking has a blog that involves taking photos, that's not nothing.

    Obviously, it's another award winning book, and like most award winners, they're aimed at the masses (i.e. beginners and hobbyists). You can get a lot of use from this book, even as an intermediate, even advanced baker in the right circumstances.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Step by step introductory bread making instructions, heavily laden with photos for each stage. Written by and largely for American bakers. If you don't like doing conversions from imperial to metric, then skip this book.

    Total page count: 432

    No. of pages before recipes: 67 of introductory theory, including equipment, ingredients, the overall process, with a section outlined for each stage.

    Metric/imperial units? Imperial only.

    Most ingredients start with measurements by volume such as cups, and tablespoons. Then backs some of those measurements up with equivalent weights. The weight units are only in ounces and pounds. If it's not in volume or weight, some ingredients are done by unit count (e.g. "two eggs").

    If that's not enough imperial, every piece of equipment, whether it's a sheet pan, a stand mixer, a dutch oven, or a skillet... the dimensions are in inches, the mixer bowl in quarts... you get the idea.

    Finally, while most of the temperatures do not specifically say Fahrenheit, (not even an F after the numbers), assume it's Fahrenheit. If it were in Celsius, you'd absolutely cremate the bread. 

    Number of recipes: Total: 106 recipes (although some are starter recipes and extensions/modifications of other recipes). The break down starts from the easier end and works up in is as follows:

    12 "starting from scratch" bread recipes, 11 "sandwich breads/everyday loaves ", 17 recipes in the "mastering size and shape: dinner rolls and more" section, 15 "pizzas and flatbreads", 19 "sweeter breads and treats", 15 recipes in "upping your game with sponges", and 17 recipes in "raising the bar" (the signature recipes)

    Photos for every recipe? Yes! Each recipe has at least four how-to photos, some even have twelve! Most recipes have between 4-8 though.

    Price range (new):  The paperback ranges from $51.63-$105 (Australian). There's a spiral bound version on Amazon for $65.

    If e-books are your preference...

    The Kindle version is a surprisingly expensive $46, while the "e-textbook" is only $28 on Booktopia.

    Price range (used): It seems not many people let their copies of Bread Illustrated go. Those who do, charge a premium over new prices. If money is tight, just buy a new on on sale.

    Notable Features & FYI:

    I think that if you liked King Arthur Flour's "The Big Book of Bread", (The BBOB) then this definitely has a similar American-centric feel, comparable recipe count, and diversity of recipes in it's repertoire. I feel there's a little more science but fewer recipes (although not by much) in this book, but in stark contrast to this book, "The Big Book of Bread" has fewer images, some recipes have no images whatsoever. On the other hand, "The Big Book of Bread" included a "Flour Primer" section in the back that "Bread Illustrated" simply doesn't cover as "in-depth". Also, BBOB included metric measurements in the recipes, where this has none.

    In short, this book has more pictures, particularly "how to" images, but no metric whatsoever. Conversely, "The Big Book of Bread" has fewer images, but includes metric quantities and additional information. Both books failed to provide Celsius (metric) temperatures. So some conversion is necessary on both options if you're a metric user.

    I'm going to skip the rest of the notable features and start looking at the detailed stuff by questioning a fundamental assumptions about this book.

    Does having more pictures actually help you with your baking?

    Personally, I have found that despite being shown a detailed and specific way to do things through the images provided here in "Bread Illustrated".... they aren't necessarily the method I should use to get the best results. Now, obviously, how you handle your dough, knead it, and shape it must be tailored to the situation, but my familiar techniques generally work better for me because I'm "feeling the dough" more through familiar sensations, rather than "sticking to a recipe's somewhat unfamiliar script and awkward movements". It doesn't sound like much, but I did two doughs, one kneaded my way, and the other, the books way, and I got a much better rise out of my approach. It's not that their method is wrong, it's just different, and that makes things a little harder to get a feel for.

    Pictures help beginners most of all, but don't close yourself off to differing techniques if they already work for you!

    So should more experienced bakers bother with this book. Is it even good for beginners as well?

    "Bread Illustrated" is aimed at beginners who don't know any techniques, and/or just need more guidance throughout the process. Naturally, using recipes that are somewhat more forgiving is also very helpful. That's not to say that intermediate bakers won't enjoy these breads though. Advanced bakers might also benefit from this book if they're helping their friends start their baking journeys... and might need some guidance on the teaching aspect of bread making... or at least see tips that beginners appreciate. So in that situation, more advanced bakers might also find value in this book.

    Like I said, if you're a metric user, you need to do one or more of the following:

    1. If possible, switch your digital scale imperial to and oven temperature units to Fahrenheit and run from that. (You can switch it back later!)
    2. Convert every amount to metric before starting your make 'n' bake process. This includes ingredients, temperatures, even the equipment sizes.
    3. WARNING: Realise that an US "cup" (240mL) is different from an Australian "cup" (250mL) and that a US "tablespoon" (15mL) is quite different to an Australian "tablespoon" (20mL). I don't know what sized measurements are used in other countries, so you should look into that if you live elsewhere!

    Here's a few of my conversion spreadsheets from this book

    I use spreadsheets for my metric conversions...

    While I can do mental mathematical conversions very well, (and often do) I find that my calculation skills themselves aren't the problem. However, remembering whether or not I'm doubling a recipe or adjusting the entire recipe to the amount of starter that I have on hand... and remembering which ingredient is for which recipe when I'm doing both concurrently...well that adds a whole level of complexity that I'm prone to messing up.

    Even with spreadsheets, formulas, colour-coded hydration and temperature layouts... doing it for all 106 recipes is a pain. I honestly feel like I'm doing the work that the authors, editors, and publishers failed to do.

    It's not just typing in preformatted tables, each recipe can have more or less ingredients, so each recipe needs the hydration calculation formula to be built on a case by case basis. Urgh!

    "Bread Illustrated" - Pros and Cons:

    The Pros:

    Another popular IACP award-winning bread book. Everyone agrees that it's good. However, how good is a matter of some debate.

    Of all my bread books, it's one of seven that featured on all three of Amazon/Goodreads/Shortform's "Best 100 (or more) bread book" lists. Sounds good, right?

    Well.. it also has the widest ranking range. Shortform ranked it at 4th. Goodreads ranked it at 40th, and Amazon ranked it at 87th at the time of writing in 2026. That shows that each list had different priorities when reviewing it, not that the book suddenly became less useful if you bought it on Amazon. However, it alludes to a simple fact:

    This book is far better suited to some people, than others.

    For an American baker, I can see why this book has such a fervent following. It literally lays everything out, using popular equipment and ingredients. The steps are laid out and they don't need crutches like YouTube videos to get the point across. That said, there are additional videos through ATK's social media platforms as well as ATK's own web site that can help with basic kitchen skills... if you're really starting from scratch.

    Continuing on with the pros!

    It has lots of step by step instructions, augmented with lots of photos and the recipes are quite reliable. The range of recipes is quite broad for a book with this design, and would be more than enough for many households. While the bread recipe selections may seem quite well rounded, make no mistake, that this is aimed at a distinctly wheaten/western/American palate. Some other grains are mentioned, but they're not mentioned the overwhelming majority of the recipes in this book.

    Some notable cons...

    Let's talk baking equipment recommendations...

    While it's good to list useful equipment, and quality gear at that, America's Test Kitchen (ATK) frequently recommends popular/often brand-name/high-end gear.... to a concerning degree.

    Do you need to buy a Le Creuset/Chasseur cast iron dutch oven that costs hundreds of US dollars to bake your first bread? Of course not! It's like buying a teenager a Porsche instead of a Toyota as a first car. Both will absolutely get you to your destination.

    The prices indicated for Le Creuset's pot in my circa 2016 edition are substantially lower than current (at the time of writing) 2026 prices. So prepare for a shock when you shop!

    The Le Creuset 7¼-Quart Round French Oven, that was priced in the book for $350 USD in 2016, is now $650 USD in 2026. That's basically $1000 Australian... which is almost as expensive a professional-series Kitchen Aid stand mixer. By the way, that particular product isn't sold on the Australian Le Creuset page and no equivalent exists. The American LeCreuset site won't ship overseas either. U.S. Sales tax to Hawaii (the closest to Australia) added $35 USD in taxes and $55 USD in shipping. Pushing the total US price to $760 USD.

    Think about that price for a moment.... That's nuts for a beginner book! I've been using a no-name $40 dutch oven for over a decade, that same device now sells for $70 new. While I've used my friend's Chasseur/Le Creuset cookware to bake bread in the past, I will tell you now that there's no discernable difference in the finished bread. Regardless of whether it was a baked in a high-end or "cheap-and-cheerful" pot. Yet that's not all of the story.. for the more anxious bakers out there....

    Taking your enamelled pot beyond it's max temperature can be stressful.

    You could put an expensive pot in a super-hot oven, but...

    Why on Earth would anyone do that?! If you're spending $650+ USD ($1000AUD) and then baking at 275C/527F, which it's explicitly not rated for... good luck trying to claim any problems under warranty.

    So check the specs of your pot from the manufacturer's web site. Also, make sure the lid handle isn't plastic as well. If it is, replace it with a metal on ASAP.

    Why bake so hot?

    Going hotter gets more oven spring (rise), and the dutch oven keeps the shape of a boule symmetrical and well constrained as it rises. Every hobbyist aspires for tall, beautiful loaves, and this is a reliable method to do that.

    Now, in fairness, high temperatures alone are not guaranteed to break your fancy cookware, and you might be fine for years, particularly if you heat it slowly and evenly. You may get some discolouration of the enamel, but in extreme cases, you may crack the enamel, making it harder to clean, with a distinct liklihood of rusting or the cast iron itself may crack and then it's a replacement job.

    However, while the risk to your cookware is relatively low, plenty of bread recipes specify temperatures that exceed a high-end enamelled Dutch oven's maximum temperature rating. If there's a minor manufacturing defect in the pot, pushing the boundaries with temp may rapidly exacerbate that fault... and the price of that failure in fancy gear is high.

    So buy a cheap dutch oven that you don't really mind damaging for your own piece of mind.

    I'm much happier taking a cheap pot to 275 Celsius (527F) which is beyond the high-end manufacturers 250C (482F) max temp recommendations.. assuming your pot does not have the plastic handle rated to only 200C (392F).. which would obviously need to be removed/replaced before doing so..

    Will a cheap dutch oven last?

    I've used my cheap dutch oven many hundreds of times, and I am not putting anything expensive at risk. When my friend asked me to make a high temp bread in her fancy pot.. I stressed... so I adjusted the bake as much as possible (and the bread was less good) and I was still worried it might crack the enamel. It worked perfectly fine, but just because it worked once doesn't mean you should expect that will always be the case. Expensive enamelled pots and bread baking is a risky proposition t at least some degree.

    Honestly, if you're willing to forgo the enamel coating altogether, a camp fire seasoned cast-iron pot is a fraction on the price, and works just as well. However like all good compromises, you have to season your pot and maintain the coating to prevent rust... and no seasoned pot is dishwasher safe.

    In Bread Illustrated, it's not just the cast iron pot recommendation that's unnecessarily expensive...

    • The $100USD Thermapen brand can easily be replaced by a $20 AUD ($12USD) Hygiplas-branded probe thermometer that's used in commercial kitchens everywhere.
    • The Wusthof bread knife ($200-300AUD.... we have one of similar spec), and interestingly, we favour a $35 AUD Mondo-branded cake knife.. see HERE for more details.

    Weirdly, "Bread Illustrated" teaches you to use disposable aluminium foil pie tins with volcanic barbecue rocks to generate steam, and a colander+tea towel combination to replace bannetons that you can buy for just $25 Australian ($15USD).... but then recommends that you spend thousands on brand named gear you don't need....

    If you spent $1000+ (USD or Australian, it really doesn't matter) on ingredients... how many years worth of experience and experimentation is that? You get far better by baking bread regularly in cheaper gear than you will by baking rarely with fancy equipment.

    Ultimately, this book does not recommend smart purchases for a beginner, which it's clearly aimed at.

    While I do think that the Pro-series Kitchen Aid is strong enough for almost any bread dough mixing in domestic quantities.... there are cheaper, stronger, and better mixers out there... especially second hand. Kitchen Aid makes planetary mixers, and they are very good, "jack of all trades mixers"... but spiral mixers do a better job of bread dough. That said, if you're embarking on your first bread bake... then a stand mixer is completely unnecessary.

    Buy cheaper-yet-decent quality gear, not cheaper rubbish!

    You can go too far with cost-cutting which will hurt your bread baking. The stuff with no moving parts, like mixing bowls, cookware, baking trays, dough scrapers, and sourdough starter jars are low-hanging fruit that you can save a ton on. I've seen sourdough starter jars sell for $50+ (I use a free empty Moccona coffee jar from work with the plastic seal removed, but tupperware works just as well). You don't need an expensive hardwood lame, just a good disposable razor blade and a serviceable handle.

    Bread does not need the newest fanciest cookware. I recommend silicone loaf trays for easy loaf removal, especially if you live in colder climates because the metal leaches heat out of your dough if it's not in a proofer. Get a scale that you trust. Honestly, it doesn't matter if it's incredibly accurate, as long as it's consistent. It's the proportions of one ingredient to another that's important, which is why weighing everything is recommended. However, don't spend hundreds as a $30-$50 works just as well as a $120-150 model. I can't tell the difference.

    Hedge your bets when starting out!

    By starting off with significantly cheaper gear than the recommended names here, once you out-grow it, you can still use it as a backup, or sell off your old cheaper gear or give it as a gift to a friend, you're not losing much if it's well used and gain some amazing good-will while saving kitchen space. If you decide that bread baking isn't for you, then you've just dodged many hundreds, perhaps thousands of dollars worth of unnecessary expenses.

    How cheap can you go?

    I've made bread with little more equipment than a plastic camping-grade soup bowl, a spoon, and baked it on a stick over a campfire (by wrapping it around the stick, and slowly rotating it over coals near a hot rock for wind protection). You almost certainly have enough gear at home to make bread without buying much compared to that caveman setup. So just ignore ATKs gear for now. Look up some cheap bread baking equipment recommendations on YouTube or online. There are loads.

    You can probably bake bread with what you have already....

    Try to use what you already have for the first bakes. Much of ATK's recommendations are ridiculously overpriced. Ok, I have a KitchenAid stand mixer, and some shiny gear, but I've baked over a thousand loaves, and it's a long-established part of my routine. I would never buy the kind of gear ATK suggests without at least a year of weekly bread baking. Afterall, you can buy a lot of bread from the shop (and save a ton of time/effort) for the circa $2000 worth of equipment. Keep this in mind.

    A second hand or off-brand stand mixer can be as little as a third of the price of the Kitchen Aid. An off brand cast iron pot can be an eighth, perhaps even tenth of ATK's recommended item price. Heck, skip the mixer altogether and use a $14 dough whisk, a $10 dough scraper and a $5 mixing bowl. Spend the money on ingredients and get the experience because that will make more improvement to your bread than the equipment. You can't taste a stand mixer difference over hand-kneaded. Trust me. I switch between the two regularly.

    Seriously if you don't have a kitchen scale, get that before any other piece of equipment!

    Just promise me you'll buy a digital scale and ditch the volume measurements as soon as possible, ok? You won't regret it, your consistency will go way up, and they're not expensive.

    No metric in the book at all? Really?!

    Warning: this might seem like a bit of a rant... but please bear with me.

    While the information is well presented, adorned with images and arranged logically. If, you're in a metric-driven country, then this book makes it an absolute necessity to convert every unit in the book... and I do mean everything.

    Now yes, there's some conversion tables in the back. I'd be ok with that if it were written by a hobbyist retiree in rural America..... I'd love to indulge an old retiree who's sharing her worldly knowledge. Personally, my willingness to tolerate a complete omission of metric by an organisation specifically aimed at teaching beginners how to cook is much lower. Especially, when that organisation uses internationally-available means (internet/books sold overseas, etc)... to convey that information to paying customers who'd benefit from it.

    U.S. books can do metric!

    Other American bread books such as "Tartine", "Flour Lab", "Bread Baker's Apprentice", the entire "Bread in 5" series, even the "Freshly Milled Flour Bread Book" by hobbyist-come-pro baker, Tim Giulfi who's busy raising kids and baking bread in his home kitchen can find the time to include metric measurements. Yet America's Test Kitchen, with all their staff, editorial folks, and time-saving equipment, as a teaching/testing organisation who instils a sense of professionalism and precision..... choose to omit the units that 95% of the world use every day? Only the US, Myanmar, and Liberia continue to use imperial units. That has to be hurting the international sales of an otherwise amazing book. Perhaps this is the reason for such a wide ranking spread amongst reviewers? ATK, if you're reading this.. fix this nonsense across your entire library of publications and web sites!

    Bringing it back to "Bread Illustrated"...

    It's all the more ironic when the whole book is marketed on trying to make bread baking as "reliable and easy to understand/do as possible". When it's targeted at people who don't necessarily want conversions or any other confounding issues to plague their first steps into the bread baking hobby... unless of course, they're a Liberian/Burmese/American... then it's perfect.

    Rant over, and soap box put away. Now let's show a more empathetic issue.


    Step-by-step, and well illustrated is great..... but it does not guarantee success. Don't beat yourself up if things go awry! Ok?

    My first attempt of the first recipe from this book, didn't go to plan.

    It was a while ago now, but I remember closing the book and seeing the catch phrase on the cover:

    "A step-by-step guide to achieving bakery-quality results at home"...

    If "bakery quality" was my goal on the first try, I fell far short. That phrase rubbed an extra saltiness into my slightly bruised ego and I started thinking:

    "I can't even follow step-by-step instructions laid out as simply as this?" As an experienced (albeit hobbyist as I was) baker at the time, that is a humbling experience. :~/

    Naturally, self-recrimination came next. If I can stop you, dear reader, from looking at a "less-than-ideal" bake this way, and just learn what you can and try again without so much negativity, then my work here is not in vain.

    I want you to understand something. Bread baking has variances. You can faithfully follow a recipe step-by-step and find your starter wasn't active enough, or the weather changed suddenly and that "three hour" bench rest warm up from the fridge needed six hours to get where you need. Naturally, something else comes up in that delay... because you have a life to live... and that delay ended with a dough sitting for twelve hours in a coolish-corner, or back in the fridge. I get it... stuff happens!

    Now why is this a con?

    I feel that through the promise of beginner-friendliness, the book, combined with promising catch-phrases, it can convince you of near-guarantee chances of success.... which aren't realistic. It takes practice, and even pro bakers who are baking the same recipe their bakery specialises in for the 10,000th time have good days and bad.

    Also, what is "bakery quality" to you? There are bakeries that are good, and you'd be happy eating their bread every day. There are bakeries that are great who charge a premium for their breads because they more involved to make, use better or more ingredients.. but are also probably... a little more fattening. Even small bakeries use commerical computer-controlled, steam-infusing ovens with constant monitoring and data collection that are light years ahead of the average home oven. They have walk in proofers that keep doughs the perfect temperature for hours, even days on end. Then there's the matter of experience. The bakers in even small bakeries make hundreds of loaves a day, shape thousands of doughs a week, and score dozens, if not hundreds of times a day. They're not baking 1-2 loaves once or twice a week...

    My point is this...

    Bakery-quality bread in this book's context, means breads with flavour and style that you'd probably find in a bakery.. Not that you'll get the perfect bread every time... or that you would be able to be employed as a pro baker from simply reading this book. Expectation management is key here. You can absolutely make some gorgeous breads with a bit of practice. It will probably take you less tries than with other books tackling harder breads and techniques, but it will need practice.

    Even if you do have a "flop", it's still extremely tasty bread.... as long as it's cooked, and not dough/ash at the end.

    Conclusion:

    Now, I don't want to demonise this book. It's a very good book for beginners, but it's also useful intermediate/advanced bakers for different reasons. If you are comfortable with imperial (or doing all the conversions) then by all means, get this book. l think it works paticularly well if used as a simple recipe book that has in-depth instructions for each and every recipe. So as a quick reference, it's amazing.

    Honestly, I don't think its a requirement to read the introductory section if you've baked before, but your odds of success go up if you're new to bread and want to get a good foundation. Just start with cheaper equipment ok?

    Yes, ATK's equipment recomendations subscribe to a "buy once for life" mentality. I respect that. It can be important for space saving and long-term savings. However, that's only valid if you use the gear regularly, or have the cash to begin with. Clearly that's not everyone.

    I like this book, but it has it's quirks, and it will suit some beginners (namely Americans) more than others. However, even Americans should look for cheaper gear when they're just starting out.

    I've made some very nice bread with this book, and although the instructions are clear, that's no guarantee of success. So please be kind to yourself. I'm not saying you'll fail. Far from it, but it's a constant possibility... regardless of which book you're baking from.

    Let's see an actual bake!

    Honey Spelt Bread

    Ham's first attempt at honey-spelt bread! (Pic: Ren)

    If there is a bread that is likely to appeal to Ren, then the venerable honey bread has to be amongst the most likely candidates.... including others like fruit toast, maple syrup & cinnamon, and Babka of course. Ren has an undeniable sweet tooth. This one, while more savoury, absolutely makes up for it in rustic flavour, and general versatility.

    Honestly, the make went pretty well. Although I only had spelt flour rather than grains... so I did exactly what the recipe recomended to replace the spelt grain soak.

    I think it went pretty well.

    Actually, I got quite the rise on this one. That ear is just under 17.5cm (or a little over 6.75") tall. The overall "dome" is about 15cm high. You can see at the bottom where the dough hit the edge of my loaf pan. Otherwise it would have been more circular. The only downside is that my scoring was inadequate so it had some "blow out" (cracks)... so remember that this was a first attempt ok? :~)

    Bread Illustrated- Honey Spelt Sourdough, sliced to show crumb

    Let's have a look at the crumb...

    Yep, this pic was done by Ren... who'd have thought, right?!

    This was a surprisingly pleasant and versatile loaf. While Ren loves this with (you guessed it), even more honey/jam. I found it also went well with honey ham (the sliced meat kind) and even quite savoury steak and salad sandwiches, and saltier condiments like Vegemite/Promite, even anchovette.

    Yes, I know, that's weird and unexpected. I did say I'm wayward, right?

    Subway's honey oat roll, has nothing on this flavour, you can smell the honey across the room, and the sourdough hint just accentuates it. In short, we like it.
    Sourdough Bread from Bread Illustrated

    Ham's first attempt at "Sourdough Bread" from "Bread Illustrated" (Pic: Ren)

    Somewhat ironically, this step-by-step book couldn't save me from overproofing this dough.

    Timing is everything.... and I missed the train... by a lot.

    I started day two with mixing the dough well before breakfast. By the time I'd put it in the fridge for the second bulk fermentation, it was only mid day. Technically, the bread was ready to come out between 8pm-4am but I didn't get back to it until the following afternoon. I left it on the counter to warm up as instructed, but half-way through that stage, it was very soft and didn't spring back all the way... So it was on the way to sourdough pancake batter. I preheated the oven immediately, gently put it in the dutch oven. However, scoring the dough prior to baking deflated it considerably. Which you can see. 

    Ok, it's a little taller than a tasty frisbee, and has a denser crumb than I wanted... but it actually has a delightful flavour. The crust on baking day was crispy and browned beautifully, absolutely covered in the sourdough blisters I aim for. It became a little softer/chewier on the following days. Just smelling it as it baked indicated that this was going to be a tangy sourdough. However, at first bite it had a hearty rustic flavour, and not in the tangy way. It's there, but the tang builds up as you eat it, but stays at a level that's actually quite pleasant. I was really surprised by just how flavourful this was, considering there were two flour types,  no herbs/spices, no fillings, no toasted grains, not even much flour on top. They really did work hard to extract the most flavour from what are, fairly simple flours, and balanced that with a 72% hydration mix (not exactly beginner level,  but "beginner friendly with flavour improvement". I suspect I can fix this up very easily for next time, but I show this one for honesty's sake. 

    Richard Hart Bread: Intuitive Sourdough Baking by Richard Hart and Laurie Woolever

    Richard Hart Bread: Intuitive Sourdough Baking by Richard Hart & Laurie Woolever

    While there are many great bread books that have come out around the time of the 2020 pandemic and since, I think this one is truly special, and it seems many agree.. because it's all about your relationship with your ingredients, the procedure, the environment, and of course, the baking. As Richard states: 


    "You know when to sharpen your knife when it's harder to use.... You know when your bike needs a tune up by the way it rides...." He's saying that you intuitively grasp a lot of stuff, and you do it every day in a number of ways, you just have to learn to do that with your bread making.

    Richard is another guy who spent time in the trenches of Tartine's regime under Chad, alongside other former "Tartinians?" who've gone onto their own bakeries across the globe.

    Why read from the student when "Tartine" is a direct line to the master?

    Because Richard's emphasis on adaptability, reading the situation and adjusting rather than adhering to technicality is, (in my opinion), the difference between forgoing being technically "right", to becoming actually more "effective" in getting the desired outcome.

    Before we get to the key stats, a "heads up"...

    Richard is an extremely practical baker. While there is an excellent theory section and diverse range of recipes, it also comes with a blunt/honest choice of wording. If Richard feels strongly about something, he alludes to swearing and sometimes uses it explicitly. It's not as bad as "Good F*cking Dough" but again I wouldn't recommend giving it to a deeply Christian mother in law... at least, not without a heads up first.

    Case in point:

    "[To make a great cheese bread], take your dough and chuck a shitload of cheese into it..."

    While I agree that the language is unnecessary, it's also refreshingly honest and sincere. He makes no pretensions of complex language, he just calls a spade... a spade! 

    The things you learn from Amazon reviews...

    Many people give this book high praise (4+ stars) However, there are the die-hard haters of this book. When books weren't physically damaged in transit, the main complaint was the swearing. As one 1 star reviewer stated: "I'll be sending this book back as it's inappropriate for a Christian women's baking group..."


    I should also mention.... that she went on.... citing:

    "There is a picture of a fully clothed (and I will add, apron-adorned), man suggestively holding a baguette as if it was his manhood"... too.

    As a middle-aged Aussie bloke with more years in a country town, boarding school, and university college (later as a staff member) than most, that kind of behaviour barely registers with me. I get that I'm not most people, and that there are situations where this book is more trouble than it's worth.

    If that's too offensive/risque for you, then find another book. I hope this warning, along with all the other book reviews here help you to do so. That said, if you can see it as the light-hearted, perhaps frivolous nature of a baker who means no harm, then this is a book that has some real benefits over many of the other books on this list, particularly at this price point.


    Key Stats:

    Area of focus:  This is a hard one to describe. It's a surprisingly in-depth, beginner-friendly but also surprisingly short bread baking book that includes some techniques that few books in this list cover. 

    Total page count: 304

    No. of pages before recipes: 71

    Metric/imperial units? All ingredients by metric weight (grams for improved accuracy) and temperatures in both Celsius and Fahrenheit

    Number of recipes: I'm going to call it 63 recipes total. It's more like 65 or so if you include the fillings for the panettone... but you're not likely to make them separately. The break-down is this:

    13 "Rye breads and pan loaves", 8 "City loaves and variations", 9 "Wheat loaves flavoured with other grains", 8 "Flatbreads + Focaccia & Ciabatta", 11 "Mixed bag breads", 3 "Baking with sourdough discards", 11 "Sweet breads", and a whole chapter on Panettone, broken into 7 sections, making components (via individual recipes) that go into it, and a variation on the overall panettone or two.

    Photos for every recipe? Each recipe has a photo of the finished product, but not much in the way of "how to" images in the methodology section.

    Price range (new): $42-75 (AUD) for the hardcover. $69 for the "spiral bound" version, and $25 for the Kindle. However it can range from $20-40 in other e-book formats through other online retailers. 

    Price range (used): Hardcovers can range from $38.71-$101 (although that 101 might be a signed copy or something). Often, new books with free delivery is cheaper than second hand with additional expenses. I haven't seen any spiral bound versions second hand.

    Notable Features & FYI: This book stands out to me for several reasons. Firstly, it's a book that prioritises using a rye starter over the usual wheat-based varieties. In fact, the first chapter of recipes shows a heavy reliance on rye as a whole. However, it does move onto wheaten starters later in the book.

    Secondly, It's also a little odd to me that the book discusses "city breads" by name, as opposed to the usual rustic/country loaves and everything else being considered "less country" (rather than city-affiliated). Furthermore, I don't see all the other recipes in the other (non city) sections being limited to or even associated with the countryside. Richard has an intriguing viewpoint, that's for sure.  

    Thirdly, while I've discussed the language issue, however terminology is also a strong suit of this book. It's one of the few books (and the only book aimed at beginners I've read so far) that discusses "scalding", which is a process of making a boiling water/flour mix (sans yeast/starter), cooling it down, then adding it to your starter and/or dough.

    Another term "scaling" (I've moved on from "scalding" please don't confuse the two terms because of their similarity), isn't just about multiplying/dividing the recipe to intended end quantities, but the process of weighing out all the ingredients individually before mixing. This is akin to the "mise en place" most chefs are familiar with, but with a goal of seeing all the ingredients laid out before mixing, so any adjustment can be made before it's too late. It's not just for the usual time saving reasons and organisation reasons of mise en place. I don't always do this myself, but I can see real benefits when I do. 

    Fourthly, this is the only book I know of that lists the ingredients in alphabetical order when it's discussed in the introductory/theory section. It's odd since most books order it by perceived importance, like flour, then water, then salt, and yeast... then various addendums. It's refreshing, and makes using this as a reference book far more efficient... without that somewhat-disconnected feeling of looking up appendices, and the usual "oh it's up the back, it must be more technical/less important" impression.

    Fifth and finally, there aren't whole sections dedicated to various grains/flours, or treatises on certain techniques. At most, there's a paragraph or two. It's an extremely lean book that covers greater key details in just 70 odd pages of intro than some books do in 100+. It's not as "boiled down" as some other books go, but it has the right mix of detail to word count that I believe many would appreciate. Even if a few words are a little crude.


    A notable quirk with the linked videos....

    In my e-book edition, within the "Real Italian Ciabatta" recipe, there's a link to show how the dough is divided and shaped. The faulty link in my e-book is:

    https://richardhartbaker.com/baking-bread-with-richard-hart-videos/v/real-italian-ciabatta-divide-and-shape-the-dough

    However, the working link (at the time of writing in September 2026) is:

    https://richardhartbaker.com/baking-bread-with-richard-hartvideos/v/real-italian-ciabatta-divide-and-shape-the-dough

    See how that ....richard-hartvideos has no hyphen between "hart" and "videos" which the first link has.

    Close but no dice!

    Never fear, if you can use the link above, or go to richardhartbaker.com and search for ciabatta, the correct video was the very last entry in the results list.

    Picture coming soon!

    Ham's first attempt at "Authentic Italian Ciabatta Rolls" (Pic: Ham)

    Ok, it's my breakfast bacon & egg multi-stacked "authentic italian ciabatta" roll. Few things in life make me happier when I wake up than real home made food that's this tasty. I wish I could share the smell of the bread with you.

    Now you may have seen a few of my "Ciabattas" before on this page. However, I have to say that this is very different to the others. Firstly, being Italian, it uses a preferment called a "biga" which is a very low (45%) hydration alternative to my usual (100%) hydration "poolish" starters. However, this recipe is the first biga-based bread recipe I've baked.... where no additional flour whatsoever is added once the biga itself is made. The "dough", merely adds the salt, diastatic malt, and more water to the biga.

    That's... unusual! Most of my breads use the preferment as a flavour development enhancement that is later added to a wet dough.

    I also learned that Biga is readily turned into a brick if you don't add all the water it needs (or use whole wheat flour which needs more water), so much so, that my bowl-lift Kitchen Aid stand mixer (that's heavier duty than the "tilt-head" variants) could barely cope with it. So.. I mixed it by hand, and let the water soak for a while, then did some more hand mixing ach time I added some more water.

    It may start off dry, but that hydration gets up there, ending up circa 75% (that's pretty high). By adding the water in stages, we're really doing one of the largest, multi-staged Bassinage methods I've ever done.... and that hydration was firmly demonstrated by the significant rise in the first few minutes of the bake.

    Am I happy with the result?

    I think for a first-attempt, it's actually very, very good. However, a little more proofing time, and sifting out some of the bran of my wholemeal flour (my last minute improvisation because I ran out of bread flour) would probably have avoided the "brick masquerading as dough" issue, and it would have helped with getting the iconically open Ciabatta crumb I fell a little short on. It wasn't dense or wrong... just not as airy as I expected.

    The bread is delicious though! Ren took photos of the rolls after they were baked, but I haven't been given the file yet. That pic will come up next, I'm sure.

    Five

    The "rustic" ciabatta rolls (Pic: Ren)

    Ok, these aren't the most even dough divisions, but if you've read this book you'll know that my "rusticly shaped" rolls are not far off from the photos in the recipe.

    I kinda like them, but they're hard to shoot.

    After discussing it with Ren, we feel that given the roll's finished "golden-but-floured" colour... shooting rolls like this is quite hard against the usual wooden backdrops, but also against a completely black or grey background, that they look surprisingly flat.

    That place mat is 45cm wide by 32cm (about 18" x 13") for scale. Normally I'd put them in a basket/bowl with a white/cream cloth on it, but we've kinda done that a bit too often already. :-)

    We can't exactly do the white linen table-clothed, fine dining experience as these rolls aren't really what we'd normally go for in that setting, so this will have to do. I'm not waiting any more to eat them :~)

    Poilâne by Apollonia Poilâne

    Poilâne by Apollonia Poilâne

    This is a work in progress, please check back soon.

    Apollonia Poilâne runs a rather famous parisian bakery (well, chain of bakeries/dare I say, empire) of the Poilâne family name. The bakery differs from the baguette-based bakeries that French culture is known for. Instead of rushing down the white bread craze that started in the early 20th century, Apollonia's grandfather chose the more traditional/rustic route which continues today as their signature bread.

    This is a beautiful book, that's part family biography, part bread book. While "Poilâne" has bread recipes aimed at bread baking beginners, it ends up as more of a general bread-using cookbook. I've also never seen another bread book include a recipe on (no joke) "how to toast bread". Which isn't quite as absurd as you might think.

    Poilâne covers topics that other books don't. You see, the bakery makes "hug-sized" loaves, so you need to know how to cut such enormous and diet-destroying boulders. It also covers a range of bread-based meal ideas that would be perfectly in-keeping with fare you'd get from a bakery (or boulangerie)  in down-town Paris.

    However, from a bread making perspective, the catch phrase on the cover (see left) might set readers up with false expectations. Apollonia says that the recipes are "similar" to the taste profile of the bread they bake, nothing more. So you still have to visit Paris or one of it's international resellers to know what the Poilâne flavour is all about. 

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: It honestly feels like mix between "Tartine" or "Beyond Bread and Butter" with a french bakery-themed general bread using recipe book. It's basically a french bakery book that's tailored to U.S. readers. (It says so, literally). Poilâne's quotes:


    "Use all five senses, trust your instincts. For everything else, weigh your ingredients, and take notes". Poilâne's breads are more of a rustic persuasion. However, this book dabbles in things that border on cake decoration, how to improve jams with additional infusions, and making simpler-but-oh-so-effective meals to incorporate bread into.

    Total page count: 288

    No. of pages before recipes: 42. Usually, I'd say that the theory is fairly lean at this page count, but most of the theory is spread amongst the recipes in this book. The transition between introductory theory and recipes is undulating and swings back and forth for quite a large part of this book. 

    Metric/imperial units? While everything is in metric, there is the backup of cups/spoons, as is popular in the U.S. It's a little ironic that it says to weigh everything, then be written for American sensibilities/sensitivities, only to have imperial weight measurements, skipped.

    Number of recipes:

    • 16 recipes in "Breakfast and Breads": It includes the initial sourdough/rye loaf recipes, and how to make that bread really sing with condiments for breakfast.
    • 58 recipes in "Afternoon: The main meal, the art of keeping bread, and sweets": Which is about using breads, croutons, etc in Tartines (open sandwiches), as well as many other lunch time staples like salads adorned with croutons.
      • 31 recipe ideas in "The main meal"
      • 5 recipes in "The art of keeping bread".
      • 22 recipes in "Sweets" (need I say more?) and...
    • 14 in "Nightime: Dreams and Explorations": It's a mixture of more breads/crepes based on corn, barley, millet and rice, there's syrups to put on them, and grain-based puddings to be made from them as well. Some of these I'm sure would be welcome any time of the day.

    Photos for every recipe? Not quite. Many do have luscious full page images, but some of the salads, and recipes with multiple variants are skipped.

    Price range (new):

    Price range (used):

    Notable Features & FYI:

    Poilâne" is a famous family-run bakery buisness centred in Paris that is currently in it's third generation. The bakery was created in 1932, by Apollonia's grandfather. This book draws from that history. It's an interesting read, and shows how historical highs and lows in Paris' history shaped how the bakery itself looked, and operated, as well as it's role in the community there. 


    Experienced bakers will note that the key sourdough recipe uses a yoghurt culture in lieu of an actual starter, and much of the "secret sauce" of making Poilâne's famous bread, ranging from the original french ingredients themselves, through to the starter-based processes they employ... has been largely skipped. Instead, Apollonia has provided recipes with the home baker in mind. So it might be "in the ball-park", but there's really no guarantee at all. 

    Some of the negative reviews of this book are a little unfair in this regard. It's certainly not limited to "Poilâne". Again, catch phrases on the cover "The secrets of the world-famous bread bakery..." can raise unfounded expectations though. Although, any secret that's shared to the public, is fundamentally, not secret anymore. Logically speaking. So there's a bit of irony for you.

    Furthermore, the recipes have been adapted to U.S. ingredients... which doesn't help an Australian like myself. From the handful of bread making recipes, it quickly becomes more about making meals with that bread... so it becomes a somewhat general recipe book centred on but not always making bread, but using it. However, viewing it as a bread making book... it really would fit into many bread baker's libraries quite nicely, especially if they're a francophile or french bread lover of any degree.



    An enormous 3kg+ sourdough

    Ham's first try at Poilâne's home-styled sourdough (Pic: Ren)

    Poilâne bread is famous for rustic flavours and "hug sized" loaves... and I wanted to get as close to the "Poilâne experience" as possible. I think of the cover image of "The Bread Baker's Apprentice" when I think of "hug sized" loaves. (see above)

    This loaf is massive. Roughly twice my normal loaf size, and it dangles off the back of this cooling rack. That's not surprising, considering I scaled the loaf up to use all of my starter (I have one already, I don't need more). The assumption that I'd want yet another starter left over is one of my pet peeves about some bread recipes. This is no exception.

    While Ren took the shot, I asked her to include my Moccona 400g (the extra large jar) with my normal starter in it for scale, but it's hard to see the full impact. You see, loaf is oriented "end-on", so that's the width of this loaf, it was shot at a somewhat-zoomed 67mm focal length @ f11 which at this distance, gets rid of most of the unsightly distortions that would absolutely show up with that cooling rack in the image, but at the expense that it compresses the image and diminishes the bread somewhat.

    Poilâne-styled soudugh

    The "hug sized" loaf (model: Ren, pic: Ham)

    Inspired by the cover of "The Bread Baker's Apprentice", here's our admittedly plagiaristic homage to show a "hug-sized" loaf. Now, admittedly, we could have worked with some more directional light to add shadows and give it some depth, but I didn't. Ok? This is just for scale.

    How Baking Works, Third Edition - By Paula Figoni

    How Baking Works, 3rd Ed. by Paula Figoni

    Paula is a food scientist and Associate Professor at the College of Culinary Arts, Johnson & Wales University, (Rhode Island USA)... and this book clearly reflects that.

    This isn't just bread related, it's baking related.... 

    If you took a theoretical book like "Bread Science", put it in textbook format, added tons of food science theory, images and instructive diagrams, then extended it to encompass all boulangerie/patisserie/viennoiserie baking, this is what you'd get. While there are recipes, there are surprisingly few, and each on is aimed at teaching you something along the way during the end-of-chapter exercises.


    This book is aimed at training your understanding of what's going on when you choose kitchen equipment, select ingredients, hydrate and mix your ingredients, proof it, knead/shape it, bake it, cool it, fill it, taste it, and store it. It also has a chapter on baking for dietary requirements and general health stuff too!

    In each section, the book goes through the science of each step along the baking procedure, along with each benefit and drawback each choice along the way entails, and how to adapt to them. 

    Don't panic, it's actually very good!

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: General baking (not just bread) food science theory, using a few recipes to test/educate/reinforce the lessons taught in each chapter.

    Total page count: 516 pages

    No. of pages before recipes: Technically, the first recipe is on page 29. However, it's only to test where the hot/cold spots are in your oven by analysing which cookies browned more or less than the others, and noting where they were on each shelf/tray at the time. There's hundreds of pages of theory to go after that. So this book should be considered all theory, with some exercises to demonstrate key concepts.

    Metric/imperial units? Both, although US (imperial) units are used first. Unsurprising for a U.S. based book.

    Number of recipes:23 recipes, however many of them are for short crust pastries, custard fillings, cookies and cakes. This is not a recipe book, rather the recipes are there purely to back up the theory with a real-world example. On page 107, there's a lean-dough formula for comparing the effect of different flours on a simple bread recipe. You're not going to find a "rustic sourdough" or Parisian Brioche in this book.

    Photos for every recipe? Nope, not a single one.

    Price range (new): I haven't found a hard cover, but most soft-covers range between $60-85 Australian.

    Price range (used): Soft cover ranges from $47-64.99 (Australian). If you prefer an older edition, 2nd editions cost about $32-46 (Australian) and the only difference is the health and well being chapter that was added in the 3rd edition.

    Notable Features & FYI: Yes, this is a textbook full of theory, but practical theory.

    I really liked how in the "science of heat" section, it discussed how aluminium baking trays behave differently, depending on if it's clean and shiny, or if it's dark with burned on residue. The darker/covered bits absorb more heat, causing uneven heating... so keeping your trays clean is a way to reduce issues and increase reliable results. It really isn't hard, but it's not something most pure theory books cover, and most recipe books gloss over, assuming that your bake ware is always kept immaculately clean. Which isn't the case in this household. :~)

    "How Baking Works" is like that, full of practical tips and explanations, but theoretically sound information dominates throughout the book. Then, like most textbooks, it has the review questions at the end of each chapter which aids memory and tests your understanding. Most chapters finish up with exercises to give you real-world experience that shows how the theory is useful, and how to apply it using simple procedures and noting down the results you got with your own gear using your equipment. This sets you up for more-informed bakes later.

    Are you in the U.S. of A?

    One of the things that most impressed me was that Paula had not only researched food science, but also provided a map of the continental U.S. with the "water hardness" for each area. The quality of water has real impact on finished baked goods, and this is the first book that I've ever seen to do that.

    That said....

    Obviously, if you're elsewhere on the planet, well it's up to you to figure out how hard/soft your water is. Perhaps searching online (make sure the site knows what they're talking about, because many don't) and if that doesn't work, try contacting your local water utility company. You probably pay their wages by using and paying for their services, afterall. :~) However, for the most accurate reading for your home's tap water specifically, then you will need a water hardness testing kit.


    Pros of "How Baking Works"

    While each chapter builds on the last, it's actually an excellent reference book. Want to understand what eggs are really used for, how they impact your baking, and situations to use alternatives, there's a section for that. Want to look at various dairy products, how they impact a bake, and any considerations/techniques to maximise results... or improvise with time-saving substitutes, there's a section for that. Want to incorporate chocolate into your bake... you guessed it, head to that section. Want to add a syrup, or fruit, or make an amazing cocktail/spirit infusion for the filling, again that's described.

    If you're the kind of person who references things like "The Flavour Bible" or "The Vegetarian Flavour Bible", and wants to know the ins and outs with every ingredient, technique, piece of equipment that's commonly used in home kitchens, even some commercial bakeries then this is an excellent addition to the bread baking library, even if it has no real bread recipes to speak of.

    I loved "Chapter 4: Sensory properties of food".

    This talks about everything from how light bounces off foods, showing colour and texture of the surface. It talks about taste, and it's interactions with aroma to make flavour. It discusses texture and "mouth feel", along with the usual salty, sweet, sour, umami, etc aspects that people are often looking for.

    The cons of "How Baking Works"

    Firstly, there's no bread recipe. Sure there's tables of baker's percentages using breads, but there's no method section to compliment them. There is a recipe for bread rolls... sortof... because it's explicit goal is to try a simple bread using different types of flours and comparing the results. It's not aimed at making an amazing bread with it though. It's a one-size-fits all approach so the number of independent variables and any differences in result is directly attributable to the changes in ingredients.

    It can get pretty dry in places.

    This is a textbook. However, if you have a question that needs answering like "Where are the hot/cold spots in my oven?" It shows you how to find that. It's not necessarily long-winded, but does cover a lot of technical stuff.

    If you have school-based PTSD...

    Honestly, this feels a lot like a high-school text book. While I've been out of high school for decades, and spent most of the intervening years studying at, living in, and working for a university and the private sector, a reminder of high-school isn't a positive association for me. While it is more... vocational than many school texts, it just has that feel about it that causes some stressful memories for me. Like I'm going to be tested on it tomorrow morning, and I've just read up to chapter seven.

    As I said, no typical recipes here:

    Ok, I admit there's a pound cake, a cookie recipe, how to make custard.. but if you're looking for a recipe book, you should look elsewhere. This book isn't for you. It's a pure theory book/classroom lab work book smashed together. If that's what you're looking for, it's a bargain. If that's not what you're looking for, then there's plenty of other books in this list.

    Conclusion:

    I genuinely believe that this is an excellent text book for highschoolers or short-course students looking to get into a baking apprenticeship, or go onto becoming a pro baker, food scientist, or home economics teacher. Can it teach you a lot of stuff as a home bread baker? Absolutely! I think you'd have to be a particularly enthusiastic foodie to warrant such a book purchase though. If that describes you, then you're my kind of crazy!

    That said, if you already have a lot of experience with baking, even if it's at an intuitive, less-theoretical state and you've ironed the kinks out of your routine baking, then this book won't help much. However, if you're a bit more "hit and miss" than you'd like to be, this can definitely help you to track down those problem areas and help you to find a real solution.

    It's not about bread specifically, but this book can certainly help bakers of any age and experience level, particularly if they're trying something new... or have gotten a litle rusty after a hiatus.

    Ham's first attempt at a low-hydration bread

    Ham's first attempt at a "Adapted lean (and low-hydration) bread loaf".

    Technically, there's no recipe for bread in this book. There's a table comparing two bread loaf ingredients in the "baker's percentage" section on page 11, and I tried a scaled-down version of the first formula. However, it looked suspiciously boring, so I tweaked it further, using some sourdough starter, and then utilised common mixing techniques, with an adapted baking process based on the size of the loaf more than anything else.

    On Baking by Sarah Labensky, Priscilla Martel, & Eddy Van Damme

    On Baking, 3rd Edition by Sarah Labensky, Priscilla Martel, & Eddy Van Damme

    This is a work in progress, please check back soon.

    Professional Bread Baking by Hans Welker

    Professional Bread Baking by Hans Welker

    This is a work in progress, please check back soon.

    The Fabulous Baker Brothers by Henry and Tom Herbert

    The Fabulous Baker Brothers by Henry & Tom Herbert

    Tom and Henry are brothers who also happen to be UK celebrity makers/purveyors of foodstuffs. Henry is a butcher, and Tom is a Baker and they run their respective butcher/baker shops next to each other in Hobbs house. They also have a TV show, and this is one of their books.

    What I like about this book is that it's centred on the bread side, but includes a lot of meals and meat products to use the bread, or go with the bread. Or turn bread into crumbs, coat some meat with it, and make all manner of delicious meals. 

    If you subscribe to the blokey-blokes (or teenager) approach to food (meat, carbs, desserts and some incidental vegetable matter, mostly for flavour) then you've come to the right place. There's even a "Get out of trouble chocolate cake" (which apparently makes "one big cake"), so there's humour too.

    Part biography, part bread book that feels somewhat "TV cooking show in book form", but definitely a recipe book as well. All quite prettily presented in a nice hardcover book. 

    This is also a work in progress, please check back later!

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Some nice bread recipes, followed up with sandwich/toastie ideas. There's tons of mains(often meat-augmented) meal ideas on how to use the bread, and recipes to make condiments and other addendums that would encourage even more bread consumption. This book would be particularly well-suited to a male (or tomboy) foodie, particularly if they have meat/barbecue/roasts/burger/meat pie and bread interests. Which is almost every non-vegan/vegetarian bloke I know.

    Total page count: 255

    No. of pages before recipes: 49 is the official count but.. Please note: It's not all theory but a bit of a biography/history, then it gets into 12 pages of actual theory, interspersed with decorative-but-not-necessarily-educational images.

    Metric/imperial units? Metric only. It's all in grams or millilitres. Temperatures are only in Celsius.

    Number of recipes: From a bread perspective, there are just twenty one (21) bread recipes. Seven are up the front in the bread section. However... that's not all because they're scattered throughout the rest of the book:

    • There's three flat bread recipes are, unsurprisingly located in the "Chapattis, Pittas, and Pizzas" section, one recipe for each type, midway though the book. The flat breads come along with an additional 8 other recipes (the pizza has 5 topping recipe variations as well).
    • In the Sourdough section, there's another three breads (sourdough, sourdough pancakes, and soda bread)... and the eagle-eyed reader will note the additional four variations of soda bread at the end of the chapter... amongst 20-odd recipes ranging from patés, stews, salads, toasties, et al that would use the bread types.
    • In the "enriched dough" section, there are three more bread recipes... and another seven recipes on how to make your own sausages/frankfurters/pickles that would make great burgers/hotdogs/cakes.
    • In the "buns" section, there's five more bread recipes. Two different hot cross bun recipes, muffins, doughnuts and thin "dippy bread sticks", along with additonal condiments, jams and custards that work with them.
    • While there are no breads in the final "Things that men like to make" section. There's some amazing roasts, full English breakfasts, a meat pie, puddings, cakes, and final addendums like marmalade.

    Photos for every recipe? Most of the main recipes do, but not the more minor recipes or their addendums.

    Price range (new): Hardcover: $49.95-$72 Australian. Kindle: $15

    Price range (used): Hardcover: $20-$41.45 Australian.

    Notable Features & FYI: This is about as English as a bread book gets. Now I know that James Morton and Vanessa Kimball are of UK persuasions too, but as a borderline-luminescent white Aussie with Scottish/English/French ancestry (no tensions between them at all if you know any history ;~p), this is the kind of food I was raised on in rural Australia... some decades ago now. It's also the kind of food I often crave after a big day of laying a concrete slab, gardening, or heavy concentration.

    The Sherston Loaf (in two forms, original and fruit loaf)

    Ham's first attempt at "The Sherston Loaf": Made in two forms (Pic: Ren)

    Now, I have a bit of a love/hate relationship with loaf pan recipes. I never seem to have the correctly-sized pan.. and things always get worse as I'm hopping from one new recipe to the next, often from different books assuming you have the same pans as the respective author. Just what constitutes a "regular" or "large" loaf anyway?

    On the left, we have the Sherston loaf exactly as the recipe dictated. It looks pretty good from where I sit. Since the dough is an "overnight" recipe, Tom dialed the yeast back quite a bit. It's not going to be the huge open crumb when it's made this simply.

    Here comes the inevitable Ham tinkering...

    On the right we have the same loaf, infused with dried cranberries and dates. However, when I say dried, what I really mean is that I diced up dried fruit, then soaked it in cold water to stop the fruit from drawing water from the dough, then added it during final mixing. Dicing the fruit quite finely (for the most part) distributed the load a little more evenly for a better rise, and I added some extra cinnamon into the bread which compliments the fruit and slightly enriched milk-infused bread nicely. Normally I'd get a notable reduction in loaf height when adding seeds/fruit but you can clearly see that this didn't happen here.

    This was a very easy recipe to do, and it's clearly quite forgiving. It's closer to a lightly-prefermented bread than a multi-day sourdough, but the flavour is good for very little work. You could make this quite routinely, even play with it like I have and tweak it to taste.

    The

    It's around the wrong way, but here's the crumb of both loaves (Pic: Ham)

    Sorry about not showing the original loaf's crumb structure in the previous image. I didn't give Ren any instructions, so I take full responsibility. :-) Also, unlike the previous image, the left slice is the fruit loaf, (obviously). You can see how the cinnamon and the fruit bits have drastically darkened the crumb, and the right slice shows the milky Sherston crumb as intended, soft and cream-coloured without such colouration. Whether you're on the sweet/fruity/spiced team, or milky/somewhat savoury team, either loaf toasts well and tastes as good as any bought milk bread or fruit loaf.

    Bourke Street Bakery New Edition: by Paul Allam & David McGuinness

    Bourke Street Bakery: New Edition by Paul Allam & David McGuinness

    Finally, a well-known Australian bakery with a book. I knew this day would come... Ok, it's been around for a while, but here's the revised edition. Bourke St. Bakery is apparently, a popular bakery that started in Surry Hills, Sydney that now has 16 locations around Sydney.

    The book combines the three specialist books Paul and David have published over the years. The first part's about bread, the second part covers making the classic Australian savoury meat pie, and the thid part covers the patisserie/sweets side. While the book is "generalist" in nature, it alone basically has the combined page count of the Bourke Street Bakery's three specialist books.

    There's a lot of bakery books that cover breads and pies, but notably, only the sweet kinds of pie. Honestly, no disrespect to international authors, but to an Aussie like myself, that's like having a "diverse" bread book that only does hot cross buns, pannetone, conchas, chelsea buns and babka. Consequently, I've been looking for a decent savoury pie book for ages, and honestly, I'm really looking forward to trying it.

    This is the newly released (in 2026) second/new edition, and while the slogan "21 years and counting" might be inferred as 21 years since the first edition, it's actually how long the bakery itself has been running. The first edition of this book was only released in 2013, so about 13 years ago from the time of writing.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: A very Australian take on general bakery. Home made breads, savoury meat pies, and numerous sweet treats.

    Total page count: 457

    No. of pages before recipes: 50 (although there's some more in each chapter when it's needed)

    Metric/imperial units? Both. Ingredients are often in grams, but if imperial units are needed ounces/pounds/spoon measurements are provided. Temperature is provided in both Celsius and Fahrenheit.

    Number of recipes:

    BREAD: 23 recipes total. The breakdown is: 4 sourdough bread recipes, 8 "derivative breads", 6"yeasted breads", 5 "olive oil breads/flatbreads/pizza doughs" (with numerous topping suggestions)

    PASTRIES: 13 total. 6 Pie doughs, puff pastries, and short crusts, followed up by 7 danish/croissant/bear claw recipes to use them.

    PIES AND SAUSAGE ROLLS: 18 total. 14 meat pies and sausage rolls, 2 sweet pies. 2 Empanada recipes

    TARTS: 17 tart recipes (most sweet)

    MORE SWEETS: 18 total. 15 "cakes and biscuits", 2 meringues and 1 trifle.

    Photos for every recipe? No. Many do, but the placement can be on the opposing page, sometimes at the end of the recipe. Sometimes they're clumped between recipes (unlabelled of course) and it's confused by the constant sprinkling of unrelated filler images. I'd much rather that they stick to the picture-per-recipe script and stop trying to be arty in unhelpful ways.

    Price range (new): $35-$64.95 Australian (Soft cover) $526 AUD for a hard cover (Are you high, Amazon?!)

    Kindle e-book: $2.99 (AUD)

    Price range (used):

    It's newly released, none found at the time of writing.

    Notable Features & FYI:

    Things I like about the book:


    It's a very practical range of recipes. You can tell it's done by a pro baker because it's about useful recipe choices that are popular here (if somewhat more main stream) and nailing the reliability of the recipes. 

    One of the very few books that specifies the size of the loaf pans. This allows me to figure out how much dough to put in the pans I actually have, relative to the size of the dough in the recipe.

    Has savoury meat pie recipes, again a rare feature in books like this, and even the "general bakery" books I've read. This is huge to an Aussie, or a New Zealander, or even some UK folk.

    Things that could be improved with this book

    While it's a nice enough read, and the recipes I've tried (so far) have been quite reliable. There are some notable areas for improvement.

    1. A book that doesn't have a picture for every recipe better have a way to compensate for that. Whether that's a high recipe count or extremely detailed instructions with how-to pictures along the way. A total of 89 recipes might be a lot to some, and it's fine for general baking... but as a bread book the 23 recipes is quite low..... it isn't bad, but it also isn't remarkable either. There's a lot of "filler" images that could have easily been replaced with more meaningful images.

    2. No recipe index or specific recipe links in the contents: Honestly, when you have a picture for every recipe this is less of a problem because you can simply flip to the pretty picture you remember. When a recipe is limited to some text, flipping through the book when you're looking for something is more challenging. In an ideal world, there would be both detailed, conveniently located pictures with a recipe index or detailed recipe-to-page link in the contents for every recipe.

    3. Inconsistent picture placement. I just find it frustrating and largely unnecessary. Frankly, it's a dog's breakfast, and there's no excuse for it. It's putting form so far above substance, then got the form wrong. Whoever did the layout should not be allowed near the next edition or any bread books for that matter.

     4. The pie recipes, great idea... but flawed execution: Ok, you want to make a great Aussie meat pie, but instead of the classic beef or chicken and vegetable/leek foundation then going into a couple of esoteric "Bourke Street Bakery specialities".. it quickly launches into pie flavours that are.... somewhat unusual.

    Warning: Rant imminent:

    Chilli con carne sausage roll? (Why not call it "Blame the dog roll", with all the butter in the crust, and generally fattier meat cuts, add beans, onions, and chilli to boot? All that increases gas production in the GI tract along with some ingredients exacerbating smelliness too). Now I'm not going to try and tell you that most meat pies/sausage rolls are healthy for you, but that's one recipe I'm staying away from. This is not a typical example of Australian bakery offerings from where have lived (or currently do), and I'd like to say that our food isn't usually as gas-invoking, ok? Rant over.

    If you like their pie/sausage roll fillings, fine! However, it might be worth using their crust recipe (if you're not buying it), use their filling recipe for inspiration ideas... then finding your own filling recipe that suits your tastes.

    That's not to say that I dislike all of their pie/pasty (or is that pastie?...) /sausage roll filling recipes though. But a good steak+red wine, or a steak and gravy, or mince and potato pies, herbed to your tastes are meals in a holdable package, and cooked in bulk, can save households a fortune on their weekly shop, especially when upping the quality/healthiness (relatively speaking) of the ingredients.... and those savings add up, particularly if you have teenagers in the house and constantly need a microwavable/re-heatable snack.

    Let's talk about Bourke Street Bakery's "nominated recipe yield".

    On page 150, there's a recipe for shortcrust pastry, and the yield is labelled as (no joke or even paraphrasing), "one quantity". One family pie, a bucket, a metric (or imperial) olympic-sized swimming pool are all "one quantity". <cue melodramatic slap to the forehead here> (I'm sure I'm going to be accused of being un-Australian here).

    Note, that's not a ballpark estimate of how many individual pies, not even a finished weight. Why even bother mentioning yield at all?! Aren't bakers supposed to be precise?

    Also, remember how I said that it's amazing how this book includes the size dimensions of bread loaf pans, well... unfortunately, that all stops in the pie section too. Even mentioning which pie tins they use would have been a reference point a home baker might be able to start from.

    Pie tins come in all sorts of sizes and shapes. You might think you know how large to cut a circle of pastry out when you read 12.5cm (5") pie tin, but... it doesn't include how deep the tin is, nor the steepness of the walls. This plays a huge role in how many pie crusts are made from a batch of dough. I have some pie tins that have the same diameter, but some are "deep dish" (5-6cm deep), others are "normal depth" (which also varies from 3.5-4.5cm). This drastically changes the size of the dough required.

    Including all the dimensions (or volume) isn't something that any book seems to do, but using an online pastry calculator like:

    https://handychefdom.com/shortcrust-pastry-calculator/

    ...with the final combined weight of the dough a pretty good start, although even that isn't perfect. Sometimes, you just have to give it a go and see what works. :~)

    Conclusion:

    Aside from low recipe image count, weird placement of images, some odd recipes for meat pies and pasty/pastie recipes, and quirky quantities, this is a book where all the bread recipes I've tried, are solid, quite adaptable, easy to work with (for the most part) and taste great. From a bread perspective, it's solid. Although if high recipe counts are your goal, then this is not the book for you. That said, it has enough to get you started, or add some Aussie (well, Aussie multicutural) twists that seem likely to work quite well for the most part.

    If you're a savoury (or savory if you're abroad) pie fan then this is a book for you. If you don't like the filling, there's plenty of recipes online. I'd honestly choose bakers over chefs in this particular case, because they're more familiar with the integration of baked pie crusts than most chefs... but feel free to disagree and go your own way.

    Despite my focus on pies, the book also includes commonly bought breads, pizzas, and sweets too. So you're not missing much. Although I acknowledge it's a bit "jack of all trades" in design.

    If a true "global bakery" experience is what you're after, then this, I'm sorry to say, isn't for you, but if you want a good Aussie bakery experience, then this is the best bread book I've read so far.... because it's the only one so far. Just don't let me dissuade you though.

    White semi-sourdough loaf

    Ham's first go at "White Semi Sourdough" (Pic: Ren)

    As a visual learner, I have to say that this is a recipe that does not have a picture in the book. So I was literally "flying blind". It's not often I choose a recipe like this, because it's always nice to have a reference point to confidently say "It came out like it was supposed to...." However, I looked at the recipe, the amount of starter I had on hand, and decided "why not?!".

    Honestly, it's a bread that works exactly as it stated, and I'm getting to the stage where I can start to adapt the more reliable recipes in my mind with a decent (if not always ideal) degree of accuracy.

    That said, when instructed to mix it on slow, and then "fast" (which in my Pro series KitchenAid, was more like higher-mid speed like 60% of maximum throttle, otherwise things got a bit... errr... violent. I was definitely getting a decent amount of elasticity/extensibility in the dough but by slowing it down a tad, I think I could have done another 30 seconds to a minute and that would have been even better.

    My usual sourdough starter has 100% hydration (same amount of flour and water). I was pleased to see that the book also used the same hydration level with their starter. So when I didn't quite have enough sourdough starter, I simply gave it as much as I could, added the usual ratio of flour to water to fill the shortage (I basically fed my starter) left it for a while, then proceeded with the rest of the recipe.

    I truly appreciated how the recipe specified the size of their suggested loaf pan. I knew what sized loaves they were intending and it made life much easier. So I got my ruler out, measured my tins/pans/silicone loaf moulds.... Then I knew that I didn't have three of that sized loaf tin, but I did happen to have one that fits the entire recipe in one loaf.

    Since I made a much bigger loaf, it took longer to proof. During the bake, I had to do adjust some stuff. Baking a larger loaf than specified at the high temps for short periods (as described in the recipe) would simply burn the crust and undercook the crumb.

    I started high as suggested, then I lowered the temperature in stages. I preheated to 240C, I immediately dropped it to 220C and turned off the fan in the oven when I put the loaf in, poured boiling water into the dripping tray and baked for 20mins. I then dropped it 210C and baked for 10 mins, then dropped it to 180C for another 35 minutes. To improve the evenness of the crust's browning, I pulled the loaf out of the pan, then browned the loaf for another 11 -12 minutes at 180C. This is a step few people do, but it improves the flavour. I didn't want to go as brown as the top, just a bit of brown so it actually looked cooked.

    So yes, I've tinkered again, but it was to adapt to the equipment I had on hand. I also sprinkled some sesame seeds on top... that I just did for fun. :~)

    The white semi sourdough loaf, sliced to show crumb

    The "White semi sourdough", sliced (Pic: Ren)

    Both Ren and I quite like this bread. It's soft without being too soft. There's flavour there from the sourdough infusion, but it's not so strong that it'd bother non-sourdough fans. Well, unless you're insanely sensitive to the flavour course. :~)

    Semi sourdough loaf, modded with seeds

    Nigella, poppy & quinoa seed semi sourdough (Pic: Ren)

    Technically, this is the same recipe as before, but "modded". The book states that this recipe is quite versatile, and I wanted to test that assertion. Now while I baked it in the same enormous loaf pan as the previous loaf, it's loaded with seeds, and I added a stronger starter presence to the last, but ran the retarded proof for a shorter time.

    Baking at a lower initial temp, (230C) for 20 mins and lowering it to 210C for the next 10, then 180C for 45mins rendered a chewier on top crust, but the tang of sourdough is light but noticeable. How you bake it as well as what you do with the dough can have distinctly different results and through the variations I've tried so far, all come out as different, but delightful, serviceable bread loaves that many would enjoy.

    Semi Sourdough modded and sliced showing seeds and crumb

    Nigella, poppy & quinoa seed semi sourdough sliced (Pic: Ren)

    Unsurprisingly, this is the same loaf, just sliced to show the quinoa and poppy seeds, as well as the crumb. I apparently managed to create a large pocket of air during the folding of the loaf but that's the only one we've found so far.

    I like adding seeds because they're a great source of minerals & vitamins, but with such a soft crumb I thought it best to keep them light-weight and small. I really like the aroma of toasted Nigella/Kalonji seeds, they add a tang I appreciate too. The black quinoa and smaller black poppy seeds add a hint of flavour. Although, please note that poppy seeds can cause false positives in some drug tests if consumed. Don't worry, the seeds here, being related to, but are not actually the opium poppies that make morphine, confuse the test, so it's safe. Feel free to skip the poppy seeds if you wish because they're entirely optional.

    The fresh bread, sliced and toasted with my favourite condiments does make me happy though. Does that make bread a drug? Side effects may include gaining weight, and an urge to bake more bread. ;~) Ren then feels compelled to make more jams from or home-grown fruit, and I feel compelled to make more cheeses, salamis, patés, smoked meats, etc.

    I didn't know I was going down such a dubious road... we can totally stop when we want but... you know... we don't want to. What would I talk about? :~)

    You didn't think I'd skip a photo of the pies, did you?

    Now, I'm going to be honest here. I didn't make the puff pastry topping. Ren had some left over from her previous baked treat projects. So I used that up instead of making more. However, I did make the short crust recipe from "Bourke Street Bakery" from scratch and pre-baked the shells before filling them to avoid that soggy crust bottom issue.

    As always, this is my first attempt at making pies with this recipe and it was a little different to what I'm used to.

    A lot of pies...

    This might seem like overkill, but it makes a lot of sense... (Pic: Ren)

    Here we have 14, individual-sized, deep dish, slow-cooked chunky steak pies, with a classic thickened gravy featuring carrots, onions, spices, garlic, tomato paste, worcestershire sauce, soy sauce, thyme, and lemon juice. You might be forgiven for thinking that these are party pies without a scale to reference, but each of those pie tops are 14cm (5.5") in diameter.  

    The main reason we used this filling rather than the options in the book was not because the recipes were bad, but:

    1. We had a lot of steak in the freezer and almost no mince.
    2. We went with a recipe we've used before for casseroles/stews/shepherds pies, because it's great, and it reduces some of the chances of failure.
    3. We could just dump most of the sauce/vegies into the slow cooker, and the meat too, after browning it. We make a lot of stuff in the kitchen, and anything to reduce the mess is always appreciated. :-)

    I know that they look a little odd, but when I finished these pies, I'd travelled multiple hours each way to the coast and back, and had walked 15Km over 3.5 hours, stopped off at another town for Ren's gig for about 90 mins (walking some more) came home, and was working into the small hours of the morning, desperately trying not to wake Ren up. So these were photographed the morning after, cold. Ok, they look a little blah... but heat them up to finish the bake and they'll become more lustrous and golden. (Please ignore the tops washed in pure egg yolks, the bowl slipped and I splashed it a bit... after that, all I could do was brush it so it looked more even. In any event, the pies still need a little finishing).

    So yeah, we have a stockpile of pies for easy meals, rainy weekends or unexpected guests. I think they came out pretty well for a first try.

    Pig with books

    Some bread-adjacent books..

    Sometimes, I have a book that includes useful information that other bread books might include (or benefit from), but when all is "said and done", it's not, strictly speaking, an actual bread book.

    It might be a treatise on a particular type of grain, or more of a social commentary on the direction commercial bread making is going, or it might just focus on pizza without a single bread recipe to join it to the other books above. Whatever the reason, you'll find some "hard to categorize" books that may help you with your bread baking journey below, or at least help you use the bread skills to make something equally tasty.

    Panini by Veronica Lavenia

    Panini by Veronica Lavenia

    Panini is the plural for panino which (as the image states) is basically an Italian sandwich/roll.

    This book has just two bread recipes in it.... both bread recipes are based on durum/khorasan flours which does make them a denser, heartier meal. That said, they're tasty, quick, and easy to make. This is why Panini is a household staple across Italy.

    From there, this book is overwhelmingly focused on the toppings and fillings common to bruschettas, panini, tramezzini, and even plain old toast... and it's those fillings that elevate a simple bread to a truly Mediterranean experience.

    That said, from a bread making perspective, it's extremely limited. However, from a bread using experience, this book is amazing. Which is why it's in this bread-adjacent category. So if you make ciabatta, foccacia, pizza, or even calzone from another book, this book can give you some very nice recipe ideas... by why limit yourself to just Italian breads?

    I really like that it talks about the seasonality of toppings. If you have fewer ingredients, each stands out more, so it makes a lot of sense to buy the best darn ingredients you can, because it really is the difference between an ok sandwich and wow. That said, some of the toppings seem simple, but would make any Italian nonna (grandmother) proud.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Authentic Italian styled sandwiches, a little bread making, but lots of sandwich fillings/toppings.

    Total page count: 144 +6 in index and acknowledgements/bio which aren't in the page count for some reason. I have no idea whatsoever where Amazon gets it's 224 page cound from. (Maybe the Kindle version?) My hard-cover barely comes to 150.

    No. of pages before recipes: 0. It's a recipe book. Not much theory to speak of outside of the preface, and it starts with the two recipes for bread.

    Metric/imperial units? Both, for all quantities but only Celsius for temperatures.

    Number of recipes: 62 recipes in total. The break-down is as follows:

    2 bread recipes, then 30 filling/topping recipes in the bruschetta section, 15 in the tramezzini section, and 15 in the toast section.

    Photos for every recipe? Almost! each recipe has a two-ish page format, a recipe on one page and a full-page image opposite. With a notable exception with the breads

    Price range (new): $26.95-$57.93 Australian (hardcover). Note: some stores have stock, but it seems this book is out of print. No e-book edition has been found.

    Price range (used): $22.95-$105.90 Australian (hard cover). This may or may not include shipping. eBay is your friend with this particular book.

    Notable Features & FYI: This is almost a pure recipe book, so there's little introductory material to speak of beyond. That said, in such simplicity with the book layout, it's a quick read, and even when using a recipe from this book, there is a time-saving aspect that can't be ignored.

    Honestly, I think it's an excellent gift to the Italophiles or someone wanting to put on something "a little special" when making sandwiches for a tea party or something.

    It's well presented, and the recipes both diverse as well as attractive.

    From a western (pasty white anglo/Scottish Australian) perspective, there's a few recipes here that I probably wouldn't like much because I'm not the biggest fan of olives, but the recipe for home made jams and cream on tramezzini (white crustless bread) certainly does appeal.

    Speaking of which...

    The big "con" with this book is that it gives you a rustic yeast-based bread, and a focaccia recipe too. Then gives you topping recipes for breads that (as far as I can see), aren't given recipes for. (I assume I have to buy white bread and cut the crusts off, or make a white bread from another book). It's just weird if you ask me.

    Let's see how I go with the "Yeast based" panini bread

    Panini bread made with dried yeast

    Ham's first attempt at Khorasan & fine semolina panini bread made "with dried yeast" (Pic: Ren)

    I didn't have any specifically "durum" flour. However, since semolina is made from the exact same species of wheat that "durum" is made from I found a bag of "finely ground" stuff and use that.The other 50% of the dough was made with Khorasan (Kamut) flour which certainly adds a rustic taste/feel that's a very-filling (if slightly more densely structured) bread.

    The rolls from initial weighing out, through mixing and baking was incredibly fast (about an hour) in the making. From an effort to reward perspective, this bread is very good, and is different from most of the simpler breads used in this list.

    Burgers Bagels & Hot Dogs by Valery Drouet Pierre & Louis Viel

    Burgers Bagels & Hot Dogs by Valery Drouet Pierre & Louis Viel

    I'm pretty sure I'm being a little unfair with this book because I've added the "25 Techniques for Woodfired Ovens" up in the bread section, and relegated this one to the "Bread Adjacent" section, despite having two bread recipes (each with 5-6 variations). I feel the relatively high price point for bread-centred knowlege and recipes is too high... if compared to other bread recipe books. At least with "Woodfired Ovens", there were instructions on how to use a new type of oven, which offers some potential bread making theory to offset the low bread recipe count. Here... that hasn't happened as there is no theory at all.

    The bread recipes here are quick, easy, and adaptable, and can certainly have a "wow" factor if you're entertaining or feel like making something "a little special". However, it seems disingenuous to call it a bread book. It certainly can inspire bread making, but that's a definite side note here.

    That said, if you do want to make quick and easy rolls that range in both appearance and flavour. Don't give much thought to the "theory and/or craft of baking" and just happen to love good burgers.. then this is an excellent and well-presented hardcover.

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Hamburgers, as a stand alone snack or combined as a meal. This book aims to elevate home-made burgers to that of a "luscious" meal and debunk the oft-present association with junk food. That said, yes you can make healthier burgers, but I think it's pretty safe to say that this is aimed a flavour over health benefits. Just saying....

    Total page count: 140

    No. of pages before recipes: 0. It's a recipe book. Not much theory to speak of outside of the preface, and it starts with the two recipes for bread.

    Metric/imperial units? Both, for all quantities and temperatures.

    Number of recipes: 70 total, with the following break down:

    Just 2 bread recipes, although each has about 6 variations... not including various toppings like seeds, egg washes, etc. After that, there's 6 sauces, 8 side dishes, 12 beef-centred burger recipes, 19 "chicken, lamb, etc" burger recipes, 8 "fish & vegetable" burger recipes, 13 "hot dog and bagel" recipes. Then 2 "sweet burgers".

    Photos for every recipe? Yes, each recipe has a two-ish page format, except the breads and sauces, where all the various breads and sauces are depicted on a separate two-page photo. Each of them are clearly (and nicely) photographed, as well as labelled. The recipe section is usually just over the page from there.

    Price range (new): $26-$57.93 Australian (hardcover). Note: no e-book or soft cover has been found so far.

    Price range (used): $19.95-$38.90 Australian (hard cover). This may or may not include shipping.

    Notable Features & FYI: This is a pure recipe book, so there's no theory or introductory material to speak of. That said, in such simplicity with the book layout, it's a quick read, and even when using a recipe from this book, there is a time-saving aspect that can't be ignored. Sure, you could buy your bread instead of making it, and it even has some recommendations on how to do that, but it gives you that choice.

    Honestly, I think it's an excellent gift to the burger/barbecue mavens or budding chefs. It's well presented, and the recipes both diverse as well as attractive. Usually there's a lot of recipes that don't suit everyone in the household.... yet both Ren and I would probably eat most if not all of the recipes listed in the book.... even if we have to dial the spice back a bit here and there.

    Let's see how I go with two different loaf types...

    Paprika and Black

    Ham's first attempt at "special rolls" because I'm ever so special (photo: Ren)

    These loaves were made using the "special rolls" recipe. Specifically the squid-ink and paprika variants. However, since I was out of squid ink, I used the food-grade ash I have from my cheese making. The recipe is a "straight, and somewhat enriched dough", meaning no preferment or sourdough efforts. The butter does make it an eriched to some degree. It's soft, and the crumb is equally so, but it also has a scone-like sheen on it. This recipe is extremely easy, and there were no problems with the recipe whatsoever.

    This bread isn't likely to have much shelf life, so it's best "baked on the day" but can be frozen. The black bread tastes exactly like bread... a simple one for sure, but bread nonetheless. The paprika one does have some warmth to it, and I'm a little unsure how Ren will cope with it. We'll find out.

    Actually, Ren quite liked it, and it went quite well as a breakfast bacon & egg roll. Unfortunately, the new backdrop Ren was experimenting with lends a surreal appearance which makes it look a little fake or copy/pasted. The sideways light doesn't quite match up with the printed shadows on the "textured" background. The bread itself is real, I assure you. Thease loaves are sized as though the entire quantity of dough was made into a boulle, rather than individual rolls.

    Bao&DimSum-OrathaySouksisavanh

    Bao & Dim Sum by Orathay Souksisavanh

    This little book is a surprisingly well-used book in our little household. While bao is indeed a levained bread, and dim sum are akin to any flat bread that you'd normally wrap a filling of some variety in. I've put this down in the "adjacent" section for the simple reason that you're never going to eat plain bao/dim sim dough in any sort of stand-alone snack. So it's less about the dough/pastry and more about the filling/toppings... much like the "Burgers, Bagels and Hot Dogs" book above, and any exclusive pizza book.

    This book is actually quite useful if you are tired of buying various steamed buns from Asian supermarkets, and/or want to have more control over what goes into your steamed buns. (No innuendo intended). The various recipes are actually quite economical to make, but if you wanted to put higher grade fillings into them, you could.

    This fills a common gap in most bread or bread-adjacent books... as Chinese, Korean, Japanese, and other countries "in that neighbourhood" are often under-represented in the other bread books. Steamed bao is in my humble opinion, the Chinese equivalent of a meat pie/sausage roll and the dim sum, probably a smaller, juicier version of poplar Aussie pasties.

    If you have children that eye off unknown quisine with suspicion, perhaps selling it like that will help bridge the gap?

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Bao buns (much like the ever-popular "Chinese pork buns" only much more versatile) and dim sum (dumplings). As such this book is highly focused on Chinese/Cantonese bread-based snacks.

    Total page count: 160 pages.

    No. of pages before recipes: 15 pages of theory, equipment, ingredients. This is very much, a beginner's recipe book.

    However, I must note the "Technical Manual" section found on page 132 onwards, which provides a lot of step-by-step fold processes (including images) for differing dumpling styles, and some notes about differing pastry/pancake dough processes. Finally, the last couple of pages lists all of the recipes in alphabetical order.

    Metric/imperial units? Metric & Imperial weights/liquid volumes. However, small volumes and liquids are mostly in tsp/tbs

    Number of recipes: 60 total. The break down is 15 bao bun (including filling) recipes, 24 dim sum recipes (naturally separated by filling more than wrapping), 15 sides and sauces, 4 "sweet snacks".

    The more mathematically/astute amongst you might be asking:

    "Doesn't that add up to 58?" Yes, yes it does! However, there's a couple of recipes that include two variations... so there's your 60.

    Photos for every recipe? Yes, most get a full page photo on the opposite page, but the condiments (sauces specifically) may only get a half page space, but that still includes a small photo.

    Price range (new): $12-$58 Australian for the hard cover. No soft cover version found. $19-$22 for the e-book.

    Price range (used): $22-$28.85 Australian on eBay.

    Notable Features & FYI:

    Orathay Soksisavanh has authored/co-authored several cook books, most centering on South-East Asian cuisine, and oddly a text on Charcuterie, but only the French edition. That said, the instructions in "Bao and Dim Sum" are clear, concise, well laid out and for the most part, authentic-ish in flavour profiles. In our household, we don't necessarily subscribe to authenticity over enjoyment... but we could go that way if we chose.

    We've made several recipes from this book and they've always been tasty, easy to eat, and most importantly, easy to make in bulk, then freeze until we want an easy meal. Fresh is better, but I'd never complain about the difference if I can just pull out of the freezer, microwave, and serve.

    Ren's bao buns

    Ren's first chicken bao buns! (This one is all Ren)

    These buns are about 10-13cm in diameter... (I know it's hard to judge scale sometimes). Yes, some stuck together, but that's easily fixed. 

    Unlike most of the breads baked here, this is the second (chronologically, not the order of the bakes listed here) that Ren has done entirely by herself. I played no part in it... mostly because I was barbecuing vast quantities of meats to go into many meals like this one. Actually, I baked these in the barbecue (amongst roasts, steaks, pizzas and various sausages) so they have a lightly smoked aroma which in my opinion, only adds to the experience. However, you can of course, cook them in a conventional oven too.

    As you can see, these buns look great, I can only tell you that they taste great, they're easy to freeze and pull out when needed, and they compliment many sides/sauces (not just the traditional ones) if you ever need to entertain on short notice.

    Organisation really pays off!

    If you're committed enough to read this far, you know that making your own food well saves money over ordering takeaway ("to go") or eating at fancy restaurants. It's also a great way to get food exactly as you like it. This is all obvious.

    Sometimes, we do get organized and commit to re-stocking our freezer with pre-made meals all at once. It sounds crazy at first, but the sad part is, when we go out for a nice meal... we're often shocked by how average the food provided in expensive meals have gotten... and we pine for our home made food. There's a famous/popular "Dumpling House" in town, and frankly we're catching up in quality... but at a small fraction of the expense. The restaurant charged us $4 per dumpling.. that's like paying $4 per two pieces of ravioli. I can buy a whole duck for $25, smoke it, mix up sone seasoning/sauces and shove it into dumplings for under $35... and that would feed 2-3 adults well!. Naturally, we'd make a variety, not just duck. One type is fine for a snack, but not necessarily for entertaining.

    Our guests certainly haven't complained about our offerings made from this book, and in fact, they complimented us and asked for the recipe. 
    The Miller's Daughter by Emma Zimmermand

    Emma Zimmerman's The Miller's Daughter: Unusual Flours & Heritage Grains

    This is an interesting book where Emma (the Miller's Daughter and author) discusses her family's restoration of the Hayden Flour Mill in Tempe Arizona. Their business centres around bringing back heirloom varieties of grains and operating the old stone mill business in the old-fashioned, and multi-generational family business way. This is just a small part of the renaissance artisanal bread is having in several countries across the globe.

    Part autobiography/chronicle of the family's farming and milling business experiment, part social commentary on the farming and food industries, and part general (rather than bread centric) recipe book. But it does have bread baking recipes too.

    This book is much more about the grains/pulses themselves and their non-bread uses than bread. That said, I think this would be of interest to any serious bread baker... although the exact varieties of grains discussed here may not be available abroad. However, the included heirloom grain supplier lists across several countries have been added in the back of the book, which surprisingly helps even Aussies like me out. Very few books do that!

    Key Stats:

    Area of focus: Heritage grains, unsual flours, and using them not only in general baking, but general meal preparation as well.

    Total page count: 225

    No. of pages before recipes: 51

    Metric/imperial units? Both, although some are purely volume based, rather than weight. Which can be less precise.

    Number of recipes: 87. Only 5 bread/bread-like offerings like bao buns, flat breads and rye loaves. Actually there's more cakes, muffins, biscottis, pancakes, cobblers, and even a parfait. This is more a general "heirloom grain" cook book, than bread book.

    Photos for every recipe? 62 images for 87 recipes= 71.26% So let's just say 70% for simplicity.

    Price range (new): $30-$57 (Australian) for the hard cover. $15-25 Australian for the e-book.

    Price range (used): N/A (none found)

    Notable Features & FYI: Ok, this is not a great bread book per se. Yet please, "hear/read me out". It is a great bread resource book.

    Not only is this good for finding out about different grains, it puts them to work in breads, salads, cakes, muffins, pasta, mains, sides, even crackers. If you'd like a little break from making bread, but have a pantry full of exotic grains, then this is great choice to have in your bread and "bread-adjacent" cooking.

    Page 221 is of particular interest to me, as a number of heirloom wheat providers are listed across the U.S., Canada, United Kingdom, New Zealand, and here in Australia! Thanks Emma, I've been struggling with this!

    That's something that Flour Lab didn't help me with, since it centred on U.S. heirloom grain/milling companies.

    My helpful? humble? thoughts about this book...

    The restoration of heirloom grains is discussed in several books in this list. However, it's seldom from the view of the miller. It's nice to read about real people in their roles, trying something new and learning something worth sharing.

    This book is somewhat unusually arranged by heirloom grain type, with various recipes to use White Sonora, Heritage Bread Wheats, Barley, Einkorn, Corn, Durum, Chickpeas (is that a grain or more a lentil?) Oats, and finally Rye. Lets just say it made counting recipe types across the grain sections much more complicated than it had to be.

    It really isn't various shades of brown foodstuffs with these recipes!

    Grape Focaccia?! Tibetan Purple Barley Berries & eggs for breakfast? Rainbow Einkorn Berry Slaw? How often are you offered such meals? I don't think it's unreasonable that with this kaleidoscope of colour.... you might be wondering "What on Earth are you slipping into the meals beside heirloom grains?!"

    I think for the price of this book, it's good if you approach it like a general recipe book. If you're looking for a pure bread book, then this is not the book for you. That said, it's hard to deny that it has more bread recipes as "The Sourdough Framework" and "Bread Science".. thus, it's has made the grade of "bread book" by that virtue alone. It'd also make a good present for a foodie with a taste for biographies/autobiographies/investigative journalism.

    Ham's first attempt at Danish Rugbrød, a seedy loaf

    Ham's first attempt at Emma's version of Danish Rugbrød (Photos care of Ren).

    While it may be my first attempt, this is the last recipe in the entire book. I'd like to say that this is one very strange recipe indeed.

    This recipe contains no salt whatsoever, but adds pickle brine (and failing that, butter milk) to the recipe. Since I don't eat pickles, but often have butter milk from my cheese making and butter making endeavours, buttermilk was used. I've never done that before.

    While it looks like a loaf at the other end, it's very much a "batter bread". Which you pour/scrape into a loaf pan.

    Other firsts, well I've never added malt extract and stout beer, to a loaf before... or made rye flour with my stand mixer attachment (much slower than my experiences with wheat). Also, this is the first recipe where the amount of water to add, was not in the ingredients section.

    Let's talk about the baking prep...

    So, the recipe (once you've made your batter, soaked it overnight, proved it, you're then expected to pour the batter (it's not dough I assure you) into loaf pan(s)? Of a certain size. Which honestly... I don't have. I have some slightly smaller ones.. so now how many do I need to use? That was not in the recipe's method section... at all. There's no yield, of 2-4 loaves... it just tells you that it can feed 10 people.

    Now, I have quite a bit of batter, and it's not going to fit into one pan of that dimension.... especially with a 1-2 hour "bench proofing" afterwards. Only thing is, I don't know how many pans to split it up into... nor do I know how much this will rise in the pan.... The usual "wait until it doubles in size" does not apply to a dense bread like rugbrød! Some recipes only expand 10% others, 30%...

    If the recipe had a number of loaf pans specified, I could at least evenly distribute the batter between them, then waited until it rose to the top of the loaf pan... but honestly... I had no idea at this point. Do I split it into two, and wait for it to fill the pan, or will I divide it by three and wait longer? 1-2 hours can make a lot of difference in bread!

    Experimentation is the slice of... "I'll figure it out..."

    Ultimately I decided that since this is supposed to be a denser bread, I'd split the batter into two loaf pans, filling them to 3/4 full, just to see how that would go over the prescribed 1-2 hour rise time. At one hour, the pans were full, and my fourth (much larger) pan that flattened the equivalent dough over its wider area, was given an extra 20 minutes to puff up beyond "a thick slice" and rise to something closer to a loaf height.

    Now, I'm supposed to be poking holes into the dough just before baking, to keep it square and dense, but frankly I prefer a slightly airier loaf, so I skipped that bit.

    Honestly, in retrospect, that was a mistake, because it did rise, then it collapsed in the middle. It may be grainy, incorporating both rye flour and lots of whole seeds... but it just doesn't have that kneaded gluten network holding it together, so not only is it very seedy, it's very crumbly as well. If I had to vote for one of the messiest loaves to make, this would be first or second on the list. 

    That said...


    Now if you love Rugbrød and all the Norse, extremely seedy breads, it's a healthy, and filling bread (There's no denying that). Yet I'd be inclined to put other bread books featuring norse recipes ahead of this one. It's quite expensive to make, I feel the bread isn't that much better than other types, it was quite involved to make, and I've had an easier time with some similar recipes from the other books in the past, and those loaves seem to hold together better. 

    As a general "lets use grains in everyday cooking" recipe book, it's fantastic, but a bread miller's daughter isn't a baker's daughter, or even a self-professed pro baker herself. As such, if bread is your goal, I'd stick to the books written by people who bake a lot. However, as a "how are things going in the flour world" perspective, it's interesting, and has a lot of ideas on how to use grains beyond bread.

    Pizza: Authentic, Rustic, Artisanal

    Pizza: Authentic, Rustic, Artisanal by Cider Press

    I'm sure you've guessed that this book is dedicated to pizza. There is not one bread recipe in the entire book. However, pizza and bread are of course, intrinsically linked in many ways. "Crusts/Bread: The Ultimate Cookbook", "The Bread Bible", "Flour, Water, Salt, Yeast", even "The Bread Baker's Apprentice" amongst others, all have sections dedicated to pizza, some of them substantial portions of the bread book in question.

    If you'd like a range of pizza dough varieties, and of course, various sauces and toppings from around the globe, then this book is definitely for you. Whether you like thin crust, thick crust, deep dish, cutting-edge, or authentically traditional, it's got you covered. Interestingly, from a bread baker's perspective, it has a quick dough, or more challenging high-hydration variants for a levain flavour without the whole sourdough starter stuff.

    Also, if you're looking for a coffee table book, or a pretty house warming gift for your favourite Pizza afficionado, there's more than enough pretty pictures, clean layouts, tons of recipes and biographies of famous pizza makers and their pizzerias around the world to suit many readers.

    Ham's first attempt at the 62% hydration pizza dough. (Yet I was the last to try it)

    62% hydration pizza dough

    How to show you my dough?

    Pizza doughs are challenging to photograph for three key reasons:

    1. One pizza base looks much like another in photos until it's baked and... who bakes a plain base?
    2. They're usually covered in toppings, so all you're likely to see is the cheese, sauce, and salami/pepperoni/bacon... maybe a little crust.. but that doesn't say much.
    3. Come on guys, you let me do most of the prep work then ate it all while I was on a call? Not nice!

    Clearly it was popular. I was able to eat a pizza from the second batch baked form this dough. Although with the strongly flavoured pizza toppings (spicy pepperoni, smoked bacon, a version of the pizza sauce found in this book, but made with home grown tomatoes, some home smoked paprika and onion powder.... it was difficult to discern the base's flavour. That said, I ate the crust alone later, and it was more flavoursome than your average store-bought base, that's for sure.

    If you're going with plainer pizzas, or ones with fewer "in your face" flavours to contend with, I think this dough definitely adds something. However, for bold spicy pizzas, you're almost certainly going to get better effort-to-reward ratio if you go with a simpler pizza dough (or shamelessly cheat by replacing a section of the water with beer). That said, I firmly believe that no pizza dough should be used before it's mixed and proofed for at least 2 hours in a pinch, but much better 4 hours, or even overnight in the fridge. It just increases the flavour, and it's often worth the extra effort.

    Can I have a bread baking book rant of biblical proportions?

    So many books claim to be bread making bibles....

    Give us this day, our daily bread....bible?!

    Seeing the sheer number of so-called bread baking bibles, you might be forgiven for thinking that man can live on bread alone. Now while I'm delighted that there are so many books to learn from, it's important to realise that having so many bread making books with bible in the title can lead to confusion.

    I was discussing bread baking books with three grandmothers on one of my favourite bread baking forums. Each grandmother was in a different country in Europe (because of the time of day, the Americans were likely asleep, and I'm a night-owl Aussie). We were all discussing our respective copies of "The Bread Bible" and confusion quickly became almost heated. It wasn't until we each listed our book's author(s) that we realised that we each had a different book!

    So if you're looking for advice on which bread baking books to get, or wish to discuss bread baking books that has "Bible" in the title. Life becomes much easier if you're aware of this problem, and specific from the outset. We don't need any more disagreements on a forum. They're supposed to stay friendly, afterall. :~)

    More to follow, this is a work in progress.

    This is work in progress. While I have owned many of these books for years, I just want to make sure I finish a refresher reading before I comment here. Check back soon.. However, I have a lot going on right now, so this is "spare time" dependent.